News blog

Predictive search and science

The Google search engine offers a predictive function, where it will suggest things you might be looking for in advance of you completing your query. As these are at least partially based on what other people have been searching for, can they provide some insights into the way science is perceived on the interwebs? The Great Beyond investigates.

Initial results are not promising. There seems to be widespread skepticism of evolution for a start. This page is from the US version of Google:

evolution us.bmp


‘Science’ doesn’t do much better, with “Science is a…” yielding “religion”, “lie” and “sacred cow” in the top ten suggestions (View image). Stem cells fare a little better, with “Stem cells are… good” being much higher up the suggestions list than “Stem cells are… wrong”.

Green issues are also controversial, with “Electric cars are…” yielding “for girls” and “a joke” alongside “the future” and “here”.

Searching for “Climate change is…” yields the slightly depressing “natural”, “not real”, and “fake” before you get to “real”. Things get worse from there.

climate change google.bmp

But what do people who do trust science want to know about? The answer is, as Nature correspondent Emma Marris points out, almost poetic:

Scientific information about dogs

Scientific information about dreams

Scientific information about global warming

Scientific information about roller coasters

Scientific information about smoking

Hat tip: This blog post was inspired by this post from the UK political blogger Guido Fawkes.

Comments

  1. Report this comment

    Lak said:

    Actuallly, the list is NOT ordered by frequency of searches. The algorithm is merely guessing that you (based on your previous searches) are sceptical of conventional wisdom and suggesting “false”.

  2. Report this comment

    Uncle Al said:

    Diversity demands all voices have equal merit. The more empirically defective the voice the more deserving it is of compassion. The Age of Science is being suffocated by an Age of Splendor – a dominion of poverty, hunger, disease, filth, death, and silk-clad priests with whips extorting salvation, “hodie mihi, cras tibi”.

  3. Report this comment

    Noah Gray said:

    @Lak, that can’t be right because for every one of Daniel’s searches, I get the identical set of choices. So either both Daniel and I have eerily similar “Googling” habits, or…….

  4. Report this comment

    Lenny said:

    On the bright side, the one with the most results is “evolution is a fact.”

Comments are closed.