News blog

Chemistry paper pwned by live-blog experiments

Here’s a brilliant example of scientists at a chemistry blog providing instant high-quality peer review of an odd paper – complete with live-blogged experimenting.

Spotting a surprising claim in a paper published by the respected Journal of the American Chemical Society (X. Wang et al, J. Am. Chem. Soc., DOI: 10.1021/ja904224y), an organic chemist flagged it with a terse “WTF is going on here?” in the comments thread of an unrelated post at widely-visited chemistry blog, Totally Synthetic.

WTF indeed. The paper claimed that sodium hydride, a strong reducing agent, was acting as an oxidant – converting an alcohol to a ketone.

Less than 24 hours after that alert had appeared online, blog-savvy chemists had repeated the paper’s experiment, and shown that the authors had their reaction right but their mechanism mistaken: some other oxidant (probably trace amounts of oxygen in air) was doing the work. Totally Synthetic’s author, medicinal chemist Paul Docherty, live-blogged his own experiment to kick off the fun.

“This is perhaps the first time that such a ‘web2.0’ approach to chemistry has occurred, and I’m indebted to my readers for their effort!” Docherty tells Chemistry World.

Comments

  1. Uncle Al said:

    Ph2CH(OH) plus H- to Ph2CH(0-) and H2, no problem. The anion kicks out H- to give Ph2C=O on paper. That atmospheric oxygen is the true hydride acceptor is irrelevant to Official Truth – a high density gas storage tank for the H*Y*D*R*O*G*E*N car.

    Massive Department of Energy funding must investigate crowned and crypted cation hydrides with the benzophenone system in a plethora of solvent systems and then neat. Then di-t-butyl ketone, diadamantyl ketone, and finally fenchone (all natural!). Thermodynamic impossibility cannot be allowed to constrain political desirability. More studies are needed.

    Report this comment Cancel report
    Your details

    Please confirm the words below

    In order to reduce spamming, this process ensures you are a real person and not an automated program.

Comments are closed.