News blog

Britain frets over ‘cloned milk’

milk.jpg milk.jpg
milk.jpg milk.jpg

The UK’s Food Standards Agency has announced an investigation into reports that milk from the offspring of cloned cows has been sold to an unwitting public.

Last week the New York Times reported that an unnamed British dairy farmer was producing milk from a cow bred from a clone. The farmer also claimed to be selling embryos from the cow to Canadian breeders.

The FSA says its interpretation of the law leads it to believe that any animal product from a clone or the offspring of a clone would need to be authorised as a “novel food” before it was placed on the market. “As the UK authority responsible for accepting novel food applications, the Agency has not received any applications relating to cloning and no authorisations have been made,” it said in a statement released today, while promising to investigate any reports of such unauthorised foods.

Grahame Bulfield, former director of the Roslin Institute – famous as the place where Dolly the sheep was cloned – says, “Given that the farmer wishes to remain anonymous, it is very difficult to evaluate this story. So it should be taken with a pinch of salt. I don’t know of any cloned animals in the UK so I would be very suspicious.” (Comments distributed by the Science Media Centre.)

A number of scientists have insisted milk from any cloned cow – or cow with a cloned parent – should be entirely safe. One question remaining to be answered is what colour code cloned milk would end up with if it were to be approved (maybe black?).

Other reactions

Earlier this month the European Parliament voted to ban the sale of meat and dairy products from clones and their offspring. However, it has yet to pass into law.

Daily Telegraph

“The scientific opinion of Efsa – the European Food Safety Authority – confirms that there are no food safety risks posed by the products of offspring from cloned animals.”

Martin Haworth, director of policy at the National Farmers Union.

There was concern about calves from cloned parents three years ago when it emerged that a calf from a cloned cow was born on a British farm. … Later that year public outrage caused Dundee Paradise and her brother, Dundee Paratrooper, to be withdrawn from auction. It is thought they later went on sale privately.

The Guardian

“There is no genetic modification. It was for this reason that the FDA has approved consumption of milk and beef from the offspring of cloned cattle – they are just normal animals, and I do not understand the EU position on this. Obviously the FSA have their rules and need to look into what has happened, but it is more likely to be the milk of kindness than a horror story.”

Robin Lovell-Badge, Head of Stem Cell Biology and Developmental Genetics at the National Institute for Medical Research (via Science Media Centre).

“Outrageous! I shall be looking for French milk and French cheese from now on! The risk is just not worth it!”

Commenter on the Daily Mail website.

Image: photo by striatic via Flickr under creative commons.


  1. Report this comment

    Patrick said:

    Just a further example of why UK public get very excited about GM without much recourse to the facts.

    This article shows how some of the problems with some of the information in the public debate about GM in the UK.

  2. Report this comment

    Ian Skidmore said:

    Irresponsible journalism again,no GM involved. As R L-B comments these are normal animals and if the law says they are not then the law needs redrafting.

  3. Report this comment

    How-to-save-the-world said:

    I think everyone is missing the point on this story and on cloning in general.

    The real DANGER with cloning has nothing to do with the misconception of eating dangerous food, it has to do with SURVIVAL OF THE FITTEST.

    Clone herds of cows, and what you will end up is a huge number of replica of the same strengths and flaws. Now, it would suffice that ONE BACTERIA finds a killer flaw, and we would end up with a very large scale disaster. The more cloned animals/plant there are, the more prone to large-scale disaster global agriculture will be.

    Instead of creating nature freaks, scientist should focus on how to make a sustainable agriculture based on biodiversity

  4. Report this comment

    Tor said:

    Hi Daniel Cressey,

    I am part of Compassion in World Farming which is the only charity working specifically to end factory farming. We are a small but dedicated team who work tirelessly to promote better treatment of farm animals. We are highly impressed by your fantastic blog, britain frets over cloned milk; we’d like to congratulate you on highlighting said key issues. We were particularly impressed by your focus on mention aspect here.

    It would be fantastic to an eloquent advocate such as yourself to spread the word about farm animal welfare. Digital online technology has made it possible to reach an audience of millions using the peaceful weapon of the word. It is amazing to note the impact that just one person can have! We would be very grateful if you would like to consider blogging about us and are more than happy to provide you with any additional information or resources which would help you with this.

    It’s always great to read comments from fellow supporters of farm animal welfare. I wish you all the very best with the your britain frets over cloned milk blog, what a fantastic resource. If we can be of any future assistance please do not hesitate to get in touch and we’ll help you in any way we can.

    Kind regards,

    Tor Bailey

    Supporter Services Officer

    Compassion in world Farming

Comments are closed.