News blog

New theory on bat flight has experts a-flutter

BatsInFlight.jpgPosted on behalf of Matt Kaplan.

You have to walk before you can run, and — if you’re a vertebrate — you have to glide before you can fly. Or so the theory goes. In evolutionary biology, gliding is widely thought to have been a prerequisite for powered flight, a transitional step along the way to full-fledged flapping.

Now, two researchers are challenging that notion with a theory that suggests that early bats used proto-wings to flutter to the ground in a controlled manner that helped them to better capture crawling insects.

Presenting today at the annual meeting of the Society of Vertebrate Paleontology, Kevin Padian at the University of California, Berkeley, and Kenneth Dial at the University of Montana, Missoula, described their idea, which arose from an investigation of the bat family tree. The researchers say that they knew there were no gliding species among bats or even closely related to them, but when they expanded the scope of their search, they found that gliding vertebrates and flying vertebrates were never closely related. The observation eventually led them to explore the possibility that gliding might have had nothing to do with the evolution of bat flight.

“With gliding being a habit that we rarely see in living bats and with the behaviour notably absent amongst their relatives, we really started speculating that something else had to have led to bat flight”, says Padian.

“It is a simple but amazing observation that there are no flying lineages of vertebrates with gliders as a sister group”, says evolutionary biologist Nancy Simmons at the American Museum of Natural History in New York.


Bats first appeared in the Eocene, roughly 50–55 million years ago. When the researchers looked at which modern bats are most like those ancient progenitors, they realized that they are climbing, cave-dwelling, insect feeders rather than tree-dwelling, pollen, blood or fruit eaters. But this presents a mystery, because most insect-feeding bats today are fast and powerful flying animals that rely on echolocation to zero in on their prey. Palaeontological analyses of bat skulls conducted in recent years indicate that early bats lacked the bony structures that would be required for echolocation.

On the basis of this, Padian and Dial theorized that bats started out eating crawling insects that would not have required echolocation to be caught. Yet if such insects were the preferred diet of early bats, they wondered why these bats had evolved to become capable climbers that could hang upside down from cave walls.

An answer came to the two researchers while they were looking at video footage of a baby bat being dropped off a ledge in a lab (onto a pillow). The bat, they noticed, rapidly fluttered its wings to help it control itself as it fell. In the same way, they propose, proto-bats, when dropping down from the ceilings of caves, could use flapping to control their descent and land in the right place to gobble up prey.

“There are a number of bats alive today that drop down from a perch and grab insects that they hear landing on nearby leaves, so this idea of bats evolving as drop-down hunters seems pretty logical”, says Simmons.

Further to this, they argue that bat development in the womb hints that developing a membrane between fingers at the end of the forelimbs would have been a mutation that could have easily emerged in early bats and then, over time, been selected for as controlled descent, and eventually powered flight, became ever more useful. “The reality is we don’t see gliding in extant bats, its doesn’t seem to be present amongst extinct bats, and when baby bats fall, they flutter. Gliding isn’t part of the equation”, says Padian.

Photo credit: Strange Ones, Creative Commons

Comments

  1. Report this comment

    rick adams said:

    This article is mostly false. The idea that bats did not go through a gliding stage dates back at least to Jepson 1970. The video they refer to is mine and I sent it to the authors just last week to use in their talk, so they did not come up with this idea after seeing a video. I’ve been talking about development showing no evidence of gliding flight to Dial for 10 years. As usual, Nature gets it all wrong.

  2. Report this comment

    Dr. Günter Bechly said:

    The crucial statement that “there are no flying lineages of vertebrates with gliders as a sister group” is not a fact at all. There are only three groups of actively flying vertebrates: bats, birds and pterosaurs. The sistergroup of pterosaurs is far from certain. They are either basal archosauromorphs or nested within prolacertiforms. In the latter case, the sistergroup would be Sharovipteryx, which is a glider. The closest stem group representatives of birds are small theropod dinosaurs, which in the groundplan apparently were four-winged gliders (Anchiornis and Xiaotingia as basal troodontids, and Microraptor as basal dromaeosaurid, as well as Archaeopteryx as basal bird). Thus only bats have no known gliding sistergroup, which of course does not preclude an unknown gliding fossil ancestor. Consequently the hypothesis of Padian et al. is built on a dubious or even incorrect assumption as foundation.

Comments are closed.