« September 2007 | Main | November 2007 »

Archive by date: October 2007

October 31, 2007

Bookmark in Connotea

Leslie Orgel - October 31, 2007

Leslie Orgel, head of the Chemical Evolution Laboratory at the Salk Institute, has died. Orgel pioneered the theory that RNA preceded DNA as a replicating molecule. At the time of his death his work was focused on searching for a precursor to RNA

He was also one of the first to suggest that life on Earth might have been seeded by extraterrestrials. His name is attached to Orgel’s rules:
“Whenever a spontaneous process is too slow or too inefficient a protein will evolve to speed it up or make it more efficient.”
&
“Evolution is cleverer than you are.”

LA Times obituary
Salk Institute statement
The Scientist obituary

Bookmark in Connotea

Spooky science for Halloween - October 31, 2007

ghostPunchStock.jpgWooooooooh. It’s Halloween!

Over at AP Seth Borenstein reveals that scientists now know more than ever before about “what’s going on inside our brains when a spook jumps out and scares us”. Borenstein also has another piece on David Zald, professor at Vanderbilt University, who every year “turns his house in Nashville, Tenn., into a Halloween fear lab”. Zald previously featured on the Great Beyond for his work on why fear gets noticed faster than other emotions (along with his not very scary actually music).

Over at the Technician online Emily Kiser has another piece on “The science of fear”. Inside Higher Ed reviews new book Haunted Halls: Ghostlore of American College Campuses. They better add those nice people at Idaho State University who have set up a haunted laboratory for students with children to celebrate Halloween “the physics style way” (KPVI).

Wired has some terrifyingly impressive geek jack-o'-lanterns while NBC5 has a slightly bizarre video item about a science store selling robotic rats and glow in the dark worms. “And also here is dad shopping for that moveable lawn ornament that he will use to scare his son’s friends right out of their bodies!”

Finally, to wrap up these terrifying proceedings, here’s one you may have missed from a few days ago: film director David Lynch has teamed up with pop star Donovan to teach transcendental meditation in British schools.

Image: Punchstock

Bookmark in Connotea

Tiger tales triple bill - October 31, 2007

tigerBUSFWS.jpgIt’s a good day for tiger news, less good for the tigers themselves. Here’s the run down...

China
Authorities in China have set up check points around the area where a rare South China Tiger was reportedly photographed recently. A team of State Forestry Administration experts is to be sent in to conduct a special investigation, state news agency Xinhua reports. The Times dredges up questions over the authenticity of the original photograph, citing a blog by a botanist from the Chinese Academy of Sciences which voices doubts about size of vegetation shown in the photo. Xinhua also covered doubts on this a while ago.

Indonesia
Tigers - along with elephants, sun bears, tapirs, golden cats and clouded leopards - have been detected in forests allocated for the chop in Indonesia. Scientists from the Zoological Society of London detected at least five different tigers on camera traps placed in 2000sq km of forest already partially logged and recently earmarked for clearance. Sarah Christie, ZSL carnivore programme manager, said, “This work shows that the criteria for developing land in Sumatra need to be urgently reassessed. Just because forests have been logged does not mean they have lost their value for biodiversity” (press release, coverage in Telegraph, Guardian).

However Xinhua was told by Forestry Minister Malam Sambat Kaban “Should the animals found in the non-forestry areas that will be used for palm oil plantation, the animals must be relocated.” Good luck with that minister...

India
England’s slightly tardy paper the Independent has noticed that there are only 1,300 tigers left in India (the story is splashed across its front page today). Similar figures have also surfaced recently in:
Reuters ‘India's tigers need miracle to survive’ 1 October
Washington Post ‘Poaching and Population Threaten India’s Tigers’ 16 October
The Hindu ‘There is hope for the tiger yet’ 14 October

Image: US Fish and Wildlife Service

Bookmark in Connotea

More space station woes - October 31, 2007

arraydamageNASAedit.jpgFollowing the news that a vital joint on one of its solar power arrays appears to be gently tearing itself apart, a rip has been found in a new panel being installed on the international space station. This leaves just one set of panels problem free on the power hungry station (AFP, AP, BBC, NY Times).

NASA halted deployment of the new, third, array after the damage was spotted (statement). Deployment was about 80% complete at the time. The panel is continuing to supply 97% of the power that it should, according to news reports, suggesting given its 80% deployment it is providing about 78% of its possible supply. Keeping the panels partly extended could cause additional problems, as they are not designed to operate in that position

The station has panels attached in arrays on both sides. Joints allow these to rotate and face the sun. One side is already locked down after astronauts found metal shavings inside its joint. Now the other side, where the new array was being added, has been hit with what we can prematurely call the curse of the ISS panels.

Mike Suffredini, ISS program manager, apparently came up with the not-entirely reassuring statement that these problems aren’t as serious as the computer glitches that bugged the station last year (Space.com). “I have in my mind a path through the wilderness on both of these problems. It will take time, but I have a path through the wilderness,” he said. Readers with long memories may be reminded of Skylab’s problems back in the 70s when only heroic work managed to fix the damaged sustained during launch, which included the total loss of a main solar panel

UPDATE – 01/11/07
NASA is leaving the joint problem well alone to focus on the torn array and things to do not look good (NASA statement). They can’t leave it alone and they can’t just extend it. Suffredini is now talking about jettisoning the whole array if it can’t be repaired (NY Times, Houston Chronicle). Appropriately the Houston Chronicle has a photo of flight engineer Clayton Anderson wearing a deathly black cape (for Halloween) as he works aboard the space station. The Chronicle also has a nice editorial on the ‘can do’ attitude of those now called upon to be engineers, builders, and electricians in space.

Image: damaged solar array wing / NASA TV

October 30, 2007

Bookmark in Connotea

FEMA fake press conference scandal - October 30, 2007

A fake press conference staged by the US Federal Emergency Management Agencyhas claimed its first victim. Last week FEMA held a press conference on the California fires with 15 minutes notice and therefore no reporters present (CNN, Time, and everyone else). In the absence of the fourth estate the agency’s own staff asked less-than-difficult questions.

John Philbin, FEMA’s public relations chief last week, will now not be taking up a new role at the Office of the Director of National Intelligence. Philbin has admitted he realised there were no reporters at last week’s conference. “I should have jumped up regardless of how awkward it would had been and said, ‘Wait a minute, time out’,” he said (NY Times).

FEMA’s administrator David Paulison has put out a statement apologising “for the inexcusable actions and remarkably bad judgment exhibited”. Whether this is enough to save heads from rolling remains to be seen. FEMA was already unpopular after its perceived mishandling of the New Orleans disaster and the US press are lining up to take shots at them.
- Rochester Democrat and Chronicle calls it “new evidence of FEMA ineptness”.
- SF Chronicle reckons “This was a doozy even by the standards of an administration that has created a culture of contempt for the role of the press in the workings of democracy.”
- The Fort Worth Star Telegram says “Halloween came early at FEMA.”
- Updating on developments MSNBC ends with a low blow: “No press conferences are scheduled at this time.”

Currently no one is suggesting that this was all done deliberately rather than merely by incompetence, Hanlon’s Razor being called into play again. We called up a press officer we know who said using your own employees to make conferences look busy is common practice, but getting them to ask question is quite another...

Bookmark in Connotea

52m year old spider X-ray - October 30, 2007

oldspider.bmpThe internal organs of a 53 million year old spider have been imaged by researchers from Belgium and the UK. After being trapped in amber the spider fell into the clutches of David Penney from Manchester University, who subjected it to ‘Very High Resolution X-Ray Computed Tomography’.

If there was any justice in the world this would have resurrected it as a rampaging super-spider. However as this was not a B-movie we are instead left with these rather impressive images that Penney thinks could revolutionise the study of amber fossils. The level of detail revealed by the new techniques could help in revising modern taxonomy and in classifying long-extinct beasts.

“This technique essentially generates full 3D reconstructions of minute fossils and permits digital dissection of the specimen to reveal the preservation of internal organs,” said Penney (press release). “My colleagues in the department of Subatomic and Radiation Physics at Ghent University in Belgium have significantly increased the resolution of the technology, bringing some quite amazing results. This is definitely the way forward for the study of amber fossils.”

This is apparently the first time the technique has been applied to fossils in amber, although some imaging work has been undertaken in Texas. A rather wonderful database of their and other images is available at Digimorph (thanks to Wired for pointing that out).

oldspider2.bmpCoverage of this really quite cool story has been hampered by the fact that Penney is now in the African jungle for an indefinite period and therefore unable to get to a phone (stories have made it on to the BBC and Wired). As the press release notes, Penney actually has a slightly younger spider named after him: a 20 million year old species found by a colleague in Mexico was named Episinus penneyi in his honour.

Images: The University of Manchester / Ghent University

Bookmark in Connotea

Organic food ‘better for you’ - October 30, 2007

fruits-citrus.JPGOrganic food advocates have been celebrating today after a major new study appeared to show their choice is better than non-organic food. Previously there has been little or no evidence that pricier organic options had any health benefits for consumers. Now a study funded by the European Union apparently shows organic foods have more antioxidants and nutrients than non-organic foods.

The study has yet to be peer reviewed and I haven’t unearthed a press release yet so the best guess I can provide is that the current (mainly British) media storm has been led by articles over the weekend in the Sunday Times (one, two). One of these opines: “The evidence from the £12m four-year project will end years of debate and is likely to overturn government advice that eating organic food is no more than a lifestyle choice.”

That was then followed up other reporters. The BBC notes that “researchers did admit the study showed some variations”, although variation in what it doesn’t say. Other coverage is lacking even this caveat, the Guardian says organic fruit and vegetables contained up to 40% more antioxidants than non-organic examples while organic milk contained over 60% more antioxidants. Discussion of whether or not antioxidants actually benefit health seems to be missing from most coverage (read what the National Cancer Institute and Medline think, or just go straight to New Scientist’s The antioxidant myth: a medical fairy tale).

Organic advocates are having a field day. Patrick Holden, director of the Soil Association, says the EU project builds on what his organisation has been doing for years and he comes up with this odd quote:

Continue reading "Organic food ‘better for you’" »

October 29, 2007

Bookmark in Connotea

Power problems for space station  - October 29, 2007

ISStwoNASA.jpgSEE ALSOMore space station woes

The International Space Station is facing a power crisis after problems were found with a key solar panel component. Metal shavings were found in a joint that allows some of the station’s massive panels to rotate and face the sun. “It’s quite clear. There’s metal-to-metal scraping, or something, and it’s widespread,” said Daniel Tani, who investigated the joint on a space walk (various sources).

To alleviate possible damage to the joint NASA has cut the number of times it is allowing the joint to rotate (Reuters, NY Times, Houston Chronicle). The problem is this also cuts the amount of power the panels generate. Another set of panels is in place and a third set is being moved into position by astronauts currently aboard ISS (AP). A fourth set of panels is due to be in place by late 2008 / early 2009. However, unless the problems with the joint can be sorted there may not be enough juice generated to properly power laboratories due to be put in place later this year.

In December the European Columbus laboratory is scheduled. Japan has its Kibo laboratory pencilled in for launch early next year. Both could face delays. “You couldn’t add another element [in the current situation]. We’d be way under-powered,” said NASA station program manager Mike Suffredini (Florida Today).

There is a neat interactive graphic showing the evolution of the station doing the rounds on a number of US papers.

UPDATE – 30/10/07
NASA has extended the current shuttle mission to the ISS to allow astronauts more time to inspect the damaged joint. The move will shorten the launch window for the next shuttle mission (Reuters).

However ISS program manager Mike Suffredini told reporters that the panel problems will not impact the delivery of the Columbus laboratory later this year (AFP). Early reports that there might not be enough power to run Columbus may have been premature. According to Space.com, "The disabled component now limits the space station's power-gathering abilities, but Suffredini said there should be no issues in having enough power to attach the Columbus module in December."

This is lucky because the European Space Agency’s TV service proudly announced today: “Columbus is ready for launch ... excitement is building for the launch of ESA's Space Laboratory Columbus. Europe is poised for the start of the most intense period of human spaceflight since Spacelab.”

Image: ISS in June this year / NASA

Bookmark in Connotea

A clam named Ming - October 29, 2007

MingClamEdit.JPGFull fathom five thy father lies;
Of his bones are coral made:
Those are pearls that were his eyes:
Nothing of him that doth fade,
But doth suffer a sea change
Into something rich and strange.
Sea-nymphs hourly ring his knell

Those words from Shakespeare’s Tempest were first spoken some time in the early 1610s – at a time when, full fathom five or so below the seas off Iceland, a clam that would one day be called Ming was reaching its teenage years. Dredged up last year and since studied at the University of Bangor, Wales, this quahog clam – named after the dynasty ruling China in its youth – seems to be the oldest animal ever to have had its lifespan measured, having enjoyed a long enough span to listen to some 3.5 million hourly knells.

By counting its growth lines researchers put Ming’s age at between 405 and 410 years (press release). This dwarfs the previous oldest animal record. The Guinness Book of Records has a 220 year old quahog specimen listed and a 374 year old quahog has also been discovered in an Icelandic museum. Mere whippersnappers next to Ming, though all pale into insignificance next to some trees, which have clocked up ten times his age.

As the research was funded by charity Help the Aged we are of course obliged to speculate that Ming may even provide insights into human aging. “What's intriguing the Bangor group is how these animals have actually managed, in effect, to escape senescence,” researcher Chris Richardson told the BBC. “One of the reasons we think is that the animals have got some difference in cell turnover rates that we would associate with much shorter-lived animals.”

The Telegraph has dedicated an opinion piece to the memory of Ming while the Times’s leader on the subject is rather derogatory of the clam’s taste for the quiet life. We are left to mourn an animal that may have lived happily for many more years, had it not been cruelly dredged from its happy home. As the eternally sarcastic Register remarks, “We can conclude from this that to live a long and healthy life, it would be advisable for a person to avoid being sliced in two by someone intent on counting one’s rings.”

Image: Ming / Bangor University

Bookmark in Connotea

Arthur Kornberg  - October 29, 2007

Biochemist Arthur Kornberg has died at the age of 89. Kornberg won a Nobel prize for medicine in 1959 for his work with Severo Ochoa on the biological synthesis of DNA. His contribution to his field is detailed in a Nature Reviews Molecular Cell Biology piece from 2006 (subscription required).

“Dr Kornberg was one of the most distinguished and remarkable scientists in American medicine,” said Philip Pizzo, dean of the Stanford University School of Medicine where he worked for many years (Stanford press release).

“Fellow scientists say in 200 years, the world will remember the name of medical researcher Dr Arthur Kornberg ... the same way it does Albert Einstein and Nicolaus Copernicus,” says the Democrat and Chronicle, local paper of Rochester. Kornberg studied at the University of Rochester as an undergraduate.

Kornberg’s son Roger is also a Nobel recipient, having won the chemistry prize in 2006 (Nobel citation, Nature – subscription required).

More Coverage
SF Chronicle
Arizona Republic
San Jose Mercury
Daily Telegraph
The Scientist

October 26, 2007

Bookmark in Connotea

Weekly round up - October 26, 2007

What’s been on The Great Beyond this week and a few extras...

Monday October 22
Cracks in Shuttle, and NASA unity / All the leaves are brown... / Solar powered race sets off / Cod ‘recovery’ claims

Tuesday October 23
California sues for cleaner air / ‘Evidence ignored’ in badger cull row / Save the dinosaur! / Vibrating mice get thinner

Wednesday October 24
California fires from space

Thursday October 25
Global warming = mass extinctions / Saturn’s moonlet belt / Wildlife photographer of the year / Kyoto’s failings / 'I have been much blessed' - Watson retires

Friday October 26
Primates in trouble, including us / “Lesbian nematodes”

Other Nature blog posts you may have missed
Peer to peer: Should regulation of research be left to peers?
Nascent: Kitchen science in a comic style
Nautilus: Research in Mainland China and Hong Kong

Ones that got away
Marine sanctuary menaced by a Texas-size garbage patch, from Ars Technica
‘Future fibres’ feature, from the BBC
Tokyo scientists build ‘womb on a chip’, from the Boston Globe

Bookmark in Connotea

“Lesbian nematodes” - October 26, 2007

nematodesNOREUSE.jpgScientists have created ‘lesbian worms’ in a new development that some are suggesting could shed light on the nature vs nurture debate over sexuality, according to a number of licentious news sources (Sidney Morning Herald for example). University of Utah researchers tweaked nematode worms to make them attracted to worms of the same sex and appear to have demonstrated that sexual orientation is hard wired, at least in nematodes (abstract, pdf). “The conclusion is that sexual attraction is wired into brain circuits common to both sexes of worms, and is not caused solely by extra nerve cells added to the male or female brain,” says biologist Erik Jorgensen (press release).

The ‘lesbian worms’ line is a bit of red herring. There aren’t true females in the C. elegans nematodes used, only hermaphrodites and (rare) true males. “A hermaphrodite makes both eggs and sperm,” says Jorgensen. “... Most of the time, the hermaphrodites do not mate. But if they mate, instead of having 200 progeny, they can have 1,200 progeny.”

As attraction in the worms is based on smell Jorgensen and co monkeyed around with male worms to find out whether their attraction to hermaphrodites was influenced by core nerve cells, accessory nerve cells, or a combination of the two. The answer was both. They also took hermaphrodite worms and turned on the genes that determine maleness, these then became the famous ‘lesbian worms’, chasing after other hermaphrodites. (The Daily Utah Chronicle notes that Jorgensen calls hermaphrodites “females” because they reproduce independently.)

The Salt Lake Tribune is one of those taking on whether this means human sexuality is hard wired. Basically the answer is only “maybe”, but it adds some credence to the idea.

Image: hermaphrodite (top) and male (bottom) pair of worms / Jamie White

Bookmark in Connotea

Primates in trouble, including us - October 26, 2007

goldenheadedlangurNOREUSE.JPGSome people have a gift for the arresting figure: exhibit a) the report from international conservation experts which points out that every member of the 25 most endangered primate species on the planet could fit into a single football stadium (though they don’t let on as to whether you need a superdome or just a set of high school bleachers). Exhibit b) is the UN’s latest environmental audit, which reveals that the most numerous primate may be degrading its environment past the point where recovery is possible.

The few:
The World Conservation Union has issued a new report entitled Primates in Peril: The World’s 25 Most Endangered Primates—2006–2008. “You could fit all the surviving members of these 25 species in a single football stadium; that’s how few of them remain on Earth today. The situation is worst in Asia, where tropical forest destruction and the hunting and trading of monkeys puts many species at terrible risk. Even newly discovered species are severely threatened from loss of habitat and could soon disappear,” says Russell Mittermeier, chair of the union’s Primate Specialist Group (press release).

Mittermeirer reckons it wouldn’t take much money to make a big difference – just a few thousand dollars in some cases. “With what we spend in one day in Iraq we could fund primate conservation for the next decade for every endangered and critically endangered and vulnerable species out there,” he told Reuters. Putting a silver lining in the cloud, AP notes that nine primates from the last report in 2004 have now been taken off the list. Coverage has also reached the BBC, the Telegraph, the Times.

The many:

Continue reading "Primates in trouble, including us" »

October 25, 2007

Bookmark in Connotea

'I have been much blessed' - Watson retires - October 25, 2007

In the wake of his incendiary comments about race and intelligence, James Watson has retired from Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory. The full text of his resignation letter is below the fold. CSHL have also issued a statement and Nature’s editorial on this is now available to all.

Our sister blog Action Potential has heard some interesting noise following Watson’s resignation

Word coming out of CSHL suggests that this clean break may not be so clean. Watson will keep his house on campus until he dies, will maintain his office with a secretary, and most likely, much of his salary. In other words, to the outside world, Watson is gone, while on the CSHL inside, the only thing that has changed is the nameplate on the door (removing the word "Chancellor").

The NY Times has, as you would expect, an authoritative run down of the resignation. Wired’s interestingly off the wall take on events somehow manages to invoke the modern film classic Princess Mononoke in Watson’s defence. For local paper Newsday cash rules everything – Watson's “ability to tap rich donors” was compromised and “it was going to cost the lab way too much money if Watson stayed connected”.

Continue reading "'I have been much blessed' - Watson retires" »

Bookmark in Connotea

Kyoto’s failings - October 25, 2007

“Time to ditch Kyoto”. Putting that headline on a commentary by eminent economists social scientists* was always bound to excite debate and that is what Nature has done this week. The gist of the argument has already been broken down on our sister blog Climate Feedback (please post any comments there).

Science policy expert Roger Pielke Jr. calls the commentary “brave and challenging” on the Prometheus blog, but doesn’t add much else. Meanwhile countries that are anti-Kyoto have unsurprisingly taken the work to heart, ABC in Australia and CanWest in Canada for example. This has been somewhat assisted by comments from one author, Gwyn Prins from the London School of Economics, who according to ABC said Kyoto had become useful for people looking to kick US president George W. Bush and his Australian counterpart John Howard, “But here again the inconvenient truth is they did the right thing.”

Those looking for some audio can head to Radio 4’s Today programme segment on the topic and should also check out the new Nature Podcast.

*Corrected 26/10
Gwyn Prins is director of the LSE Mackinder Centre for the Study of Long Wave Events.
Steve Rayner is director of the James Martin Institute for Science and Civilization at the University of Oxford.

Bookmark in Connotea

Wildlife photographer of the year - October 25, 2007

The annual Shell Wildlife Photographer of the Year prize has really excelled itself this year. To put the standard of things in perspective, none of the stunning images that I’ve chosen to use here were winners in their respective categories. Seriously, these were not judged to be the best pictures on offer...

wildlifPaulNicklenNOREUSE.JPG
This photo from Paul Nicklen, entitled ‘Love of a leopard seal’, is the result of an unlikely infatuation. “From the first time I got in the water with this massive female leopard seal in Antarctica, it seemed to attempt to communicate with me,” says Nicklen. “Every day, it would offer me penguins, dead and alive, like this chinstrap. When I kept refusing to eat the offerings, it looked agitated before going to get me another penguin.”

I’d have eaten the penguin – you don’t want annoy something that size.
© Paul Nicklen / Shell Wildlife Photographer of the Year 2007

WildlifJeffYonoverNOREUSE.JPG
Normally fisheye lenses strike me as cheating, but when they produce pictures like this one by Jeff Yonover who can really argue?
© Jeff Yonover / Shell Wildlife Photographer of the Year 2007

wildlifArneNaevraNOREUSE.JPG
Arne Naevra’s ‘polar meltdown’ image is probably destined to illustrate features on climate change for years to come.
© Arne Naevra / Shell Wildlife Photographer of the Year 2007

See all the photos from the competition, run by the Natural History Museum and BBC Wildlife Magazine, at the official gallery website.

Bookmark in Connotea

Saturn’s moonlet belt - October 25, 2007

saturnmoonlets.jpgIn an interplanetary attempt to keep up with the Joneses, Saturn has, with the help of some University of Colorado astronomers, revealed more moonlets in its rings.

Earlier this month we reported that moonlets expected to be seen in a NASA fly-past of Jupiter were mysteriously absent, although some ‘moon-like’ lumps of material were found.

Saturn’s moonlets were probably created when a larger moon was annihilated in a collision with a comet or asteroid, according to Miodrag Sremcevic, lead author of a study published this week over at Nature proper (subscription required). “There was probably a bigger moon of at least 20 miles (32 km) in diameter or larger orbiting at that place. And that moon had the unfortunate fate to be struck by a large meteoroid [sic] or comet and was destroyed into pieces. And now what we see today are the remaining shards of that moon,” Reuters reports him saying.

The moonlets’ presence is indicated by propeller-like features that form in the ring around them. Although four of these features were detected in 2006, new evidence shows that there is actually an entire belt of moonlets around Saturn, probably consisting of thousands of mini-moons ranging from the size of “semi-trailers to sports arenas”, according to the UCB press release. However the moonlets were probably not formed by a single massive collision, as they are not spread uniformly. Instead their distribution supports a cascade of collisions in the ring, triggered by the more recent break up of a large moon. “We all expected they would be everywhere in the ring. Our study shows they are concentrated in certain regions in the ring like a belt,” Sremcevic told Space.com.

Image: Propeller features / NASA/JPL/Space Science Institute/University of Colorado

Bookmark in Connotea

Global warming = mass extinctions - October 25, 2007

industrial air pollution.jpgClimate change could cause a mass extinction in the near future, UK scientists are warning. Their research found global biodiversity was relatively low during warm greenhouse periods and that in these periods extinctions have been relatively high. Of five previous mass extinctions, four correlated with increased temperatures.

“Our results provide the first clear evidence that global climate may explain substantial variation in the fossil record in a simple and consistent manner,” says Peter Mayhew of the University of York. “If our results hold for current warming — the magnitude of which is comparable with the long-term fluctuations in Earth climate — they suggest that extinctions will increase.”

In fact, if temperatures predicted for the next few centuries do come to pass over 50% of animal and plant species could be put to the climate sword according to the press release, although at a quick glance I can’t find this figure in the paper (abstract, PDF). The story is getting wide coverage, mainly in the UK press (Guardian, BBC, Reuters, Times, Independent, Herald Sun, AP).

It’s worth noting that the mechanism for link is, as the paper notes, “still unclear, and only when they become clearer we will be in a position to comment confidently on the implications for future climate change”. Equally it’s not immediately clear how the relatively long periods of time detailed in the extinctions and warming in this paper relate to our current situation, which some people are already calling a sixth mass extinction, and Charles Petit is asking the question ‘what about the asteroids’.

October 24, 2007

Bookmark in Connotea

California fires from space - October 24, 2007

The massive scale of the wildfires devastating southern California has been made clear by these new satellite images from NASA.

wildfireMainNASA.jpg
This first image shows smoke from at least 14 separate fires ranging from north of Los Angeles to south of San Diego.

wildfireSpeedNASA.jpg
Fuelled by strong winds, the fires grew rapidly, as shown in these two images. The one on the left shows the situation at 11.35 on October 21 while the right image shows the same area at 14.50 on the same day, just over three hours later. See the NY Times for more on the importance of the local Santa Ana winds. For other wind stories see Charlie Petit’s run down.

AP has an overview of the fires and both the LA Times and the San Diego Union Tribune have a huge amount of space dedicated to this story.

Images: NASA

October 23, 2007

Bookmark in Connotea

Vibrating mice get thinner - October 23, 2007

mousepinkgetty.jpgWhy bother exercising when you can just stand on a vibrating platform? This is potentially the question raised by a paper published this week in PNAS. In it Clinton Rubin, of State University of New York, Stony Brook, and colleagues report that putting mice on a vibrating platform for 15 minutes every day made them leaner than a control group (AFP, National Geographic). There was a small reduction in overall weight but the vibrated mice also had 27.4% less fat in their torso than controls.

The paper suggests the vibration inhibited the formation of fat cells from stem cells. “It’s very exciting. It's a whole new concept of fat moving from one depot to another," study author Clifford Rosen told his local paper the Portland Press Herald.

There are some points to raise though. The paper says differences in food consumption between the two groups cannot be the cause but it would seem possible that the vibrating could tone up muscles slightly, resulting in increased energy use. Also, the paper has not been traditionally peer reviewed, it’s published as a ‘communicated’ paper. This means a member of the NAS has submitted it along with two reviews of the member’s choosing.

Some sceptical scientists are present in New Scientist's coverage.

So don’t run out and buy a vibrating bed just yet. Firstly because the vibrations used in this study are much softer than those in commercial products. Secondly because Rosen has already set up a company and submitted a patent for his own products...

Image: Getty

Bookmark in Connotea

Save the dinosaur!  - October 23, 2007

China has completed a giant earth dam designed to prevent erosion destroying valuable fossils near its Russian border. According to the state news service, every year erosion washes away bones from Dinosaur Mountain, which sits on the Heilongjiang River dividing Russia and China. Now, however, a 1,450 metre long dam has been completed on the Chinese bank of the river.

“The embankment could effectively protect the Dinosaur Mountain from threats of water erosion and floods, thus, the dinosaur fossils are rescued from being washed away,” said Li Jinshan, vice director of Jiayin Dinosaur National Geologic Park Administrative Bureau (Xinhua).

Thousands of bones have been excavated from Dinosaur Mountain, previously named The Mountain of Dinosaur Bones according to Xinhua. There may be enough fossils left to construct 100 or more additional skeletons. Although a Reuters pick up of this story has generated a lot of coverage, further details are in short supply.

Bookmark in Connotea

‘Evidence ignored’ in badger cull row  - October 23, 2007

badgersalamyedit.jpgThe UK government’s chief scientist stands accused of allowing political expediency to overrule good science after recommending the culling of badgers (BBC, Independent, Daily Mail, Daily Telegraph). There has been a long running debate on the British Isles over the merits of killing badgers to stop the spread of bovine TB, which they carry. Farmers’ groups have argued that the animals should be culled to safeguard cattle.

Earlier this week an independent scientific advisory group came down on the side of letting the stripy Typhoid Marys live, saying targeting one site would only encourage badger movement around the country. However the government’s chief boffin Sir David King thinks culling could be effective where badgers are contained, maybe by the sea or motorways. John Bourne, the author of the independent group report, said King’s conclusions were not in line with the science and were “consistent with the political need to do something about it”, many reports note. King’s comments do seem strange given badgers’ well known ability to cross or tunnel under roads.

The Telegraph points out that Bourne and King will appear together this week at an all party inquiry hearing. We can only hope that sparks will fly.

Continue reading "‘Evidence ignored’ in badger cull row " »

Bookmark in Connotea

California sues for cleaner air - October 23, 2007

carsonroadgetty.jpgCalifornia has finally got bored of waiting for permission to enforce higher environmental standards on car manufacturers. Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger is now moving to sue the Environmental Protection Agency, who have to issue a waiver to national laws so he can limit greenhouse gas emissions from new cars. This is getting massive play in the local press (for example: Copley News Service, SF Chronicle).

“It is almost two years since we asked for this waiver,” said his spokesman Aaron McLear (Reuters). “The governor feels we have been patient enough. He has met with the EPA administrator and with the president on this and has sent letters to them both. We have done everything we can and now it is time for action.”

The state appears to be generally backing Schwarzenegger. An editorial in the Mercury News notes, “It's not often we cheer the filing of a lawsuit between two government agencies. But ...”

If the EPA does give the go ahead there could be a knock on effect. As AP points out California has a unique status allowing it to enact its own air pollution rules, providing the EPA agrees. But other states can follow either national or Californian standards and a number are hoping to adopt Arnie’s air.

This is not California's first run in with auto makers. Last month a judge threw out a lawsuit from the state seeking to hold them responsible for global warming. For some, the temptation to wheel out catchphrases is too great. Wired have run with “Governor Arnie to EPA: Hasta La Vista, Bureaucratic Delay Monkeys”.

Image: Getty

October 22, 2007

Bookmark in Connotea

Cod ‘recovery’ claims - October 22, 2007

codgetty.bmpFishermen may have been rejoicing last week to see headlines proclaiming a ‘slight recovery’ for cod stocks in the North Sea (BBC, The Times, press release). However the so-ugly-they’re-kinda-cute fish still have a distinctly un-rosy future.

The International Council for the Exploration of the Seas is still saying quotas for cod need to be slashed. What is driving these ‘slight recovery’ stories is the number of young cod in the North Sea has shown a slight rise for a second year. Bertie Armstrong, of the Scottish Fishermen’s Federation, told the Times, “This is excellent news, reflecting scientific proof of what the fishermen had been reporting for some time – that cod was recovering in the North Sea.”

ICES breaks down its cod advice into geographic areas, here are the areas and some exerpt from their comments.
West of Scotland

The spawning stock biomass is at an all time low, but the total mortality is uncertain and probably high.
Irish Sea
Spawning biomass in relation to precautionary limits: Reduced reproductive capacity
Fishing mortality in relation to precautionary limits: Harvested unsustainably
Celtic Sea Cod
Harvested sustainably
North Sea / Eastern English Channel / Skagerrak
...at risk of being harvested unsustainably and suffering reduced reproductive capacity.
Rockall
No analytical assessment of this stock has been carried out.

Recovering they may be, but if fisherman want to be fishing a few years from now they’re still going to have to catch less cod. And if you are going out for fish and chips, don’t make it cod just yet.

Image: Getty

Bookmark in Connotea

Solar powered race sets off - October 22, 2007

solargetty.bmpAn environmentally friendly version of wacky races has kicked off in Australia, as 38 solar powered cars speed across the continent. The World Solar Challenge set off at the weekend, with teams competing to complete the 3,000 kilometres between Darwin in the north and Adelaide in the south (official website).

The Age reckons the Nuon Solar Team, with three previous wins under its belt, is favorite to win. It also holds the race record – an impressive 29 hours. However at the moment Japan’s Ashiya team is leading, followed by Belgium’s Umicore and Australia’s Aurora (ABC).

There has already been controversy. The University of Michigan is blaming the Stanford Solar Car Team for a crash could have put them out of the race. It’s heartbreaking stuff for Michigan. Before the race the team’s engineering director Alex Curaudeau said, “When the race finally comes, you’re really nervous because you have put an entire two years of your life into this project. It’s like watching your kid grow up; you just want it to succeed.” They do appear to be back up and running now though.

UPDATE – 30/10/07
Apologies for the tardy nature of this update. The winner of the race was indeed the Nuon team.

Michigan finished seventh out of 41 cars after their run in with Stanford (Michigan Daily). Stanford were put out of the race by a tyre blow out which flipped their car. The driver was uninjured (The Stanford Daily).

Image: Getty

Bookmark in Connotea

All the leaves are brown... - October 22, 2007

autumnleavesgetty.jpgThe latest victim of climate change is apparently emerging in Vermont – the colour of Autumn. Warmer temperatures are preventing “New England’s richest colours” from coming forth, according to a widely syndicated AP story. This is bad news for Vermont, where millions of visitors spend even more millions of dollars on the strangely named activity of ‘leaf peeping’.

This could all be down to Al Gore’s implacable foe, climate change. According to AP the National Weather Service data show temperatures in Burlington have been above the 30-year averages in September and October for the past four years (except for October 2004). This not only slows the breakdown of chlorophyll, it means better conditions for fungi that attack some trees. So, says Barry Rock, a forestry professor at the University of New Hampshire, “The leaves fall off without ever becoming orange or yellow or red. They just go from green to brown.”

But the New Hampshire Union Leader has been doing some additional digging. They reckon the leaf peeping season is about a week longer than usual down their way. It is, according to Alice DeSouza, director of the state Department of Travel and Tourism, “absolutely beautiful”. But she’s paid to say things like that.

Meanwhile, here at the Great Beyond, talk of falling leaves means only one thing: It’s time for our annual look at Carl Zimmer’s many blog posts on the subject

Image: Getty

Bookmark in Connotea

Cracks in Shuttle, and NASA unity - October 22, 2007

discoveryNASA.jpgCracks in the Space Shuttle’s heat shield appear to be worrying some NASA staff ahead of tomorrow’s launch. Engineers at the space agency have been overruled by managers according to various news outlets. The NASA Engineering and Safety Center said the launch should be put back to December so at least three heat-resistant panels on the leading edge of the craft’s wings can be replaced, according to the NY Times. They weren’t listened to.

“I didn’t say it’s safe to go fly and I wouldn’t say that,” said Wayne Hale, the shuttle programme manager (Guardian). It’s a dramatic quote, but one rather undermined by the fact he followed it up with, “The preponderance of evidence in my mind says that we have an acceptable risk.” As Hale noted to the NY Times the ageing shuttle “is not a safe vehicle by any normal standard”.

Why the panels keep degrading is something of a puzzle. “Right now, you have kind of a yellow flag out. We are trying to be very careful,” said Hale (Houston Chronicle).

The mission itself is key to NASA's plans for the space station. A major series of home improvements will be made to the station, including the addition of a room “the size of a school bus” (Orlando Sentinel). “This mission is off-scale high in terms of challenges. We have a lot to sink our teeth into,” said astronaut Scott Parazynski (Houston Chronicle).

In many papers the launch is raising memories of the Colombia disaster. On a more positive note, this is the first time two space missions will be led by women at the same time – the shuttle will be commanded by Pamela Melroy while the International Space Station with which it will be docking is currently under the charge of Peggy Whitson (McClatchy Newspapers). Given the number of missions NASA has flown it may be a bit surprising that it has taken this long. But then one of NASA’s problems is how old fashioned a lot of its things are – shuttle problems are at least partly down to it dating back to the 1960s so maybe we shouldn’t be surprised if they equal opportunities approach hasn’t quite made it to the 21st century yet.

UPDATE
It’s all going well so far...
25/10/07 - still no problems found.

Image: Discovery / NASA

October 19, 2007

Bookmark in Connotea

Inside the mind of 'Honest Jim' Watson - October 19, 2007

SEE ALSO: 'I have been much blessed' - Watson retires

With James Watson apologizing for his widely criticized comments on race and IQ, it hasn't excaped anyone's attention that when it comes to making incendiary remarks, he certainly has form. So Scientific American provides a very helpful 'greatest hits' list of his previous faux pas. This resource (and its seemingly constant updates) provides details of his somewhat unorthodox ideas on stupidity (it's a disease), and overweight black people (they have better sex).

Continue reading "Inside the mind of 'Honest Jim' Watson" »

Bookmark in Connotea

Weekly round up - October 19, 2007

What’s been on The Great Beyond this week and a few extras...

Friday October 19
Inside the mind of 'Honest Jim' Watson / Sea change brings coast guard to Arctic / Watson apologises; suspended from Cold Spring Harbor

Thursday October 18
X-ray sat laid to rest / An early taste for seafood

Wednesday October 17
Ice surveyors will walk to pole / James Watson’s race row / A feast of fossil footprints

Tuesday October 16
Dinosaur of the day / Gossip beats facts any day / Chimps exposed as liars

Monday October 15
South China Tiger spotted / Florida stops burying tortoises alive (soon) / Fear gets seen faster / New crew aboard ISS


Ones that got away
The hotly anticipated Star Trek film chronicling the early days of James T. Kirk and fellow crew members during their training at the Starfleet Academy, seems to have been largely cast (BBC; imdb)
State and federal biologists, who are smarting from research showing that they may have been protecting the wrong fish the past 20 years, are regrouping in their efforts to restore the rare greenback cutthroat trout to Colorado waters (NY Times).
Amateur stargazers map a 'lopsided' universe (Telegraph)

The Great Beyond will be back on Monday.

Bookmark in Connotea

Sea change brings coast guard to Arctic - October 19, 2007

In the wake of melting arctic ice and the opening of the northwest passage, the US Coast Guard is planning its first Arctic operating base, to deal with cruise ships, tankers, and whatever other boats start to ply their way through clearer northern waters (NY Times). It would probably be near Barrow, they say, with just a helicopter and a few boats to start. This will help increase search and rescue capacity, and environmental protection. It also wouldn’t hurt in terms of protecting any new mineral resources found in the arctic seabed, the NY Times hints.

They don’t say, but this is surely part of the new national maritime strategy announced jointly by the Navy, Marine Corps and Coast Guard on Wednesday (press release). This “addresses politically sensitive issues, such as global warming and the emerging dispute over access to the previously ice-bound Arctic seas”, according to the Government Executive. Many stories emphasize that the strategy marks a new emphasis on humanitarian roles for the navy (see for example: LA Times).

For local news angles, you may want to keep an eye on the Alaskan paper the Arctic Sounder, due out later today (in the meantime check out last week's issue for an amazing snap of beached walruses and other climate change news).

Bookmark in Connotea

Watson apologises; suspended from Cold Spring Harbor - October 19, 2007

SEE ALSO: 'I have been much blessed' - Watson retires

After DNA Nobel Prize winner James Watson stirred up a fuss with his comments to the Sunday Times Magazine earlier this week (see Great Beyond post), he has apologised for and clarified his statements; but the eminant eminent genetics institute Cold Spring Harbor Lab (where Watson has been director, president and chancellor and now has 'administrative duties') has suspended him until further notice (statement). The London Science Museum also cancelled a sold-out lecture Watson was scheduled to make today.

Watson told the Associated Press:
"I cannot understand how I could have said what I am quoted as having said. To all those who have drawn the inference from my words that Africa, as a continent, is somehow genetically inferior, I can only apologize unreservedly. That is not what I meant. More importantly from my point of view, there is no scientific basis for such a belief."

The Sunday Times has said that they have their original interview with Watson on tape (AP).

October 18, 2007

Bookmark in Connotea

X-ray sat laid to rest - October 18, 2007

fuse.JPG
There's been some coverage(AP; Discovery) around on the end of NASA's Far-Ultraviolet Spectroscopic Explorer (FUSE) mission.

FUSE was launched in 1999 and initially had a three year mission lifetime, so the shutdown comes as no great surprise. Still, X-ray astronomers will no doubt miss the satellite, which led to more than 1,200 papers. It's discoveries include a hot bubble of gas around our Milky Way and the discovery of molecular nitrogen in interstellar space.

But astronomers aren't done with FUSE just yet. The team plans to spend a year wrapping up operations, including cataloging some 130 million seconds of scientific data. There's no doubt that some yet-to-be-made discoveries lie within that archive.
Credit: NASA

Bookmark in Connotea

An early taste for seafood - October 18, 2007

It looks like Homo sapiens headed to the beach and engaged in ‘modern behaviours’ such as eating seafood, making delicate knives, and grinding up shells to make paints some 40,000 years earlier than previously known (there’s a host of stories on this today, see for example the New York Times and BBC).

The earliest previous evidence for human use of marine resources was dated to around 125,000 years ago (followed by evidence of Neanderthals cooking shellfish in Italy about 110,000 years ago). Now Curtis Marean and colleagues report in Nature findings from a sea cave in South Africa suggesting people were living on the coast there around 164,000 years ago (Nature paper subscription needed; press release). The authors propose these coast-dwellers may have been driven to seafood to survive a cool, dry spell that turned most of Africa to desert.

I have always thought that coastal living was one of the easier ways of life – with plentiful food, water, and a more moderate climate – so had assumed that early peoples would have flocked to the shore. But apparently the prevailing wisdom is that the earliest modern humans (some 150,000 to 200,000 years ago) preferred hunting inland game. “Shellfish was one of the last additions to the human diet before domesticated plants and animals were introduced,” team leader Marean (sadly pronounced 'mar-e-an' rather than ‘marine’) told the NY Times.

The African press doesn’t seem to have done much with the story, though Reuters Africa reports: For early humans, a beach party and clam bake in S.Africa.

October 17, 2007

Bookmark in Connotea

Ice surveyors will walk to pole - October 17, 2007

Hot on the heels of French explorer Jean-Louis Etienne, another hardy bunch is setting out to measure arctic ice. But unlike recent Great Beyond star Etienne, who will float serenely above the ice in his airship, this latest team will be going on foot. Pen Hadow and his team will haul a sled-mounded radar 2,000 kilometres from Alaska to the North Pole next year, swimming where necessary (AP, Reuters, AFP, BBC, official website).

vancoarctic.jpg
“The only way to accurately gauge the current thickness of the polar ice cap is to physically go out there and measure it on the surface to supply crucial data that can't be recorded by submarine or satellite,” according to Hadow, pictured centre (press release pdf). Scientists from the University of Cambridge, University College London, NASA and the Met Office in the UK will be participating in the project. João Rodrigues, of Cambridge’s Polar Oceans Physics Group, is the survey’s head of science.

Over 10 million radar readings, along with ice-drilling, will allow researchers to analyse both the ice thickness and the overlying snow thickness – measurements that have often been rolled into one. Hadow and co will try to average 18 kilometres a day, meaning the journey will take them a little over 100 days. “I feel like a bit of a donkey to be honest. All I’m really going to be doing is pulling this hugely heavy sledge with this incredibly hi-tech gadgetry which can measure the exact thickness of the icecap,” Hadow told the BBC.

Image: survey team show off their kit / © Martin Hartley

Bookmark in Connotea

James Watson’s race row - October 17, 2007

dnagreygetty.jpgDNA pioneer James Watson has been busily lighting fires while touring to promote his latest book. So far he had ignited conflagrations over race, sex, and fellow scientists, to name but a few.

It is the race aspect of his comments in interviews that has so far generated most heat. Regarding Africa he said “all our social policies are based on the fact that their intelligence is the same as ours - whereas all the testing says not really” (The Times, Daily Mail, Independent). The UK’s Equality and Human Rights Commission, which has wide powers to combat racism, is now studying Watson’s remarks. As far as we know Watson has not publicly responded to this.

Watson has previously courted controversy with his views on women and his musing on the fact it might be possible to abort homosexual babies. In a recent interview with the Guardian, where he also makes unflattering remarks about fellow DNA-scientist Rosalind Franklin, he said “Unfair discrimination exists whether we like it or not; I wouldn't have married a gum-chewing vegetarian. Ultimately, we'll help the people we discriminate against if we try to understand more about them; genetics will lead to a world where there is a sympathy for the underdog.”

Watson’s former ‘protégé’ Charlotte Hunt-Grubbe has written an extended essay on the man she calls an “immensely powerful and revered force in science”. It’s well worth a read.

Image: Getty

UPDATE: Watson has apologised for and clarified his statement: see Great Beyond entry
SEE ALSO: 'I have been much blessed' - Watson retires

Bookmark in Connotea

A feast of fossil footprints - October 17, 2007

fossilfootprints.JPG
Reptiles have been around a little longer than we thought, a stunning fossil find reveals. Footprints found in New Brunswick, Canada push back the date of the first reptiles, which evolved around 315 million years ago. “The evolution of reptiles was one of the most important events in the whole history of life,” said the fossil’s finder Dr Howard Falcon-Lang, a paelontologist at the University of Bristol (BBC, Times).

Previously the oldest evidence of reptiles was fossils found in 1859. The new footprints were found in the same region as the previous fossils but about a kilometre lower in the rock strata, meaning they are between one and three million years older. The findings are reported in the Journal of the Geological Society. “There were only a few species capable of making prints like this around at the time so we came up with a short-list of suspects. However, the prints showed that the hands had five fingers and scales, sure evidence they were made by reptiles and not amphibians,” said one of Falcon-Lang’s co-authors on the paper Mike Benton (press release).

In a strangely similar story researchers working in Germany are claiming to have found the oldest footprints positively identified, after fossils of two ‘reptile-like’ animals from 290 million years ago were matched to fossil tracks (Live Science). Their results are published in the Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology.

Image: Howard Falcon-Lang

October 16, 2007

Bookmark in Connotea

Dinosaur of the day - October 16, 2007

A massive new dinosaur has been unveiled by South American scientists. Futalognkosaurus dukei, a type of titanosaur, is estimated by its discoverers to be between 32 and 34 metres in length. “This is one of the biggest in the world and one of the most complete of these giants [the titanosaurs] that exist,” Jorge Calvo, director of the palaeontology centre at the National University of Comahue in Argentina, told reporters (AP, AP again, AFP). This particular herbivore’s size doesn’t appear to have helped it survive though – there are signs the giant had been eaten by predators (BBC).

Around 70% of the skeleton has been recovered. Jeff Wilson, palaeontologist at the University of Michigan, reviewed the findings. “I should really try to underscore how incredible it is to have partial skeleton of something this size. With these kind of bones you can’t study them by moving them around on the table; you have to move around them yourself,” he told AP.

In the latest issue of the Annals of the Brazilian Academy of Sciences, Calvo and colleagues describe their findings at a site in the north of Patagonia (full text, PDF). In half a metre of one quarry they not only found Futalognkosaurus but also located other dinosaurs, fish, flying dinosaurs called pterosaurs and prehistoric crocodiles.

However it is the monstrous Titanosaur that is getting all the attention. Its name is a combination of the Mapuche indigenous language words Futa (giant) and lognko (chief), the Greek saurus (lizard), and dukei after the company that sponsored the research, Duke Energy Argentina. So the name means something like Giant Chief of the Lizards and CEO of Duke Energy.

Bookmark in Connotea

Gossip beats facts any day - October 16, 2007

whisperingpunchstock.jpgEven when we know the truth, gossip still seems to influence us, according to a study in PNAS. Researchers from Germany and Austria set students a game in which they had choose whether or not to pass money between each other. To do this they were given true information on other players’ past ‘gifts’ but also gossip on their generosity or lack of it. Crucially, some of this gossip was fake.

Even when the students had access to the raw data on fellow players’ past decisions, gossip still seemed to influence them. “People only saw the gossip, not the past decisions. People really reacted on it,” study author Ralf Sommerfeld, of the Max-Planck Institute for Evolutionary Biology told Reuters. They gave less money to those described as ‘nasty misers’ than they did to those described as ‘generous players’, for example.

This is slightly confusing. “If you know you already have the full information about someone rationally you shouldn’t care so much what someone else says,” says Sommerfeld (NY Times). An explanation is that we may be predisposed to believe people as we can never normally access the full set of facts on anything – we are likely to have missed some information, and it may have been crucial. (Telegraph)

Continue reading "Gossip beats facts any day" »

Bookmark in Connotea

Chimps exposed as liars - October 16, 2007

chimpanzee-face.bmpChimpanzees have been exposed as big cry-babies by researchers from Scotland. When chimps are attacked they scream based on the severity of the attack. However Katie Slocombe and Klaus Zuberbuhler found that some of the sneaky animals lie about how bad the attacks actually are.

“If no-one is there to help them then the screams are normal but if someone is about then they make it sound even worse than it is. This shows there is more flexibility in their vocal communication than previously thought,” Slocombe says (BBC).

In their PNAS paper the researchers identify four types of aggression, ranging from threatening behaviour to outright beating. Victims of aggression changed the acoustic structure of their screams depending on which type of aggression they experienced. Higher aggression brought forth longer, higher frequency screams. A kind of “Get your hands off of me, you damned dirty ape.”

Slocombe and Zuberbuhler say their data provide “the first systematic empirical evidence to show that nonhuman primates are able to exaggerate distress to manipulate other group members”.

Image: Getty

October 15, 2007

Bookmark in Connotea

South China Tiger spotted - October 15, 2007

TigerUSFWS.jpgSee also: Tiger tales triple bill

Chinese news sources are reporting that the highly endangered South China Tiger has been seen in the wild for the first time in years (Xinhua, Huash). Nearly all the remaining tigers of this species are in captive breeding facilities and experts put the number of wild individuals at around 25 at most (BBC). Now photographs taken by a farmer appear to catch one of these on film, the first confirmed sighting in 30 years.

The Chinese news channels have a pretty impressive picture of the animal in question. Although there don’t appear to be official English versions of these stories there is a translation available. This says the tiger was snapped by Zhenglong Zhou, a villager from Zhenping County in Ankang City, Shaanxi Province.

This sighting is much more convincing than a photo of the Yangtze dolphin that was wheeled out after reports of that creature’s demise. Still, it is going to take more than this to convince that the tiger is out of the woods. On its own, one tiger is not very much use.

Image: USFWS

Bookmark in Connotea

Florida stops burying tortoises alive (soon) - October 15, 2007

gophertortoiseBobSavannah.jpgAuthorities in Florida are finally banning the burying alive of cute burrowing tortoises. State officials have previously granted permits to builders, allowing them to build over the burrows of gopher tortoises and callously ‘entomb’ them under concrete in their extensive lairs. No more! The state is no longer issuing permits allowing ‘entombment’ (Washington Post).

The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission last month approved a new conservation plan, requiring that the threatened species be moved away from construction areas (press release). However, scores of permits already issued are to be honoured, according to the Post. “I don’t think anyone wanted to entomb tortoises. But we can’t stop development, and this was the best option at the time,” commission spokeswoman Joy Hill told the paper.

According to previous reporting of the topic, entombment has buried more than 94,000 tortoises since 1991, if state estimates are to be believed. Other estimates put the number as up to 900,000.

More on the animals
FWC ‘Species Spotlight’
Gopher Tortoise Council
National Geographic on entombing.

Drawing: U S Fish and Wildlife Service/Bob Savannah

Bookmark in Connotea

Fear gets seen faster - October 15, 2007

scaredGetty.jpgOur brains respond faster to fear than to smiles, according to researchers in the United States. David Zald and colleagues found if they slowed down facial recognition, there was a noticeable difference in the time it took to perceive happy faces and the time it took to perceive scared faces. This probably all evolved as a ‘threat radar’ millions of years ago (see for example the Times).

“We think what is happening with fear is that this is a critical threat signal for us. Fear tells you something is wrong and you need to pay attention,” said Zald, a psychologist at Vanderbilt University in Tennessee (Reuters).

Zald and co used a neat trick of perception to slow down recognition enough to detect the differences. Study subjects looked at faces with one eye while the other eye was presented with a rapidly changing pattern. The brain focuses on working out what is going on with the pattern, slowing the recognition of the face (and its temperament). The paper should appear in the journal Emotion shortly.

Spoiling the party: Bahador Bahrami, a neuroscience researcher at University College London, said the discovery was not unexpected. “It’s quite well accepted that fearful faces have a special significance. And other imaging studies have shown the brain responds more strongly to fear, so this is consistent with that finding,” he told the BBC.

According to his website Zald is one of only a handful of musicians who have mastered a strange 10-string instrument played by tapping the strings to the frets. Have a listen.

Image: Getty

Bookmark in Connotea

New crew aboard ISS - October 15, 2007

spacestationNASA.jpgThe International Space Station’s new crew arrived on Friday aboard a Russian Soyuz spaceship (Reuters, BBC, TASS). Along with cosmonaut Yuri Malenchenko was the woman who will be the station’s first female commander, Peggy Whitson. Also aboard was Muszaphar Shukor from Malaysia, whose flight generated the much discussed guidelines for Muslims in space.

Perhaps unfairly, Reuters refers to Shukor as a tourist – his flight was part of a jet fighter deal between Malaysia and Russia. However Malaysia’s prime minister Datuk Seri Abdullah Ahmad Badawi said the science experiments Shukor was to undertake were key. “I wanted to ask him if he had started the experiments. He is not in space to enjoy the view of Earth below but has duties to fulfil while at the International Space Station,” Abdullah said (Malaysia’s New Straits Times).

Already aboard the station are Fyodor Yurchikhin, Oleg Kotov and Clayton Anderson. “The fun is just about to begin,” Yurchikhin said upon the new crew’s arrival (AP). As Space.com notes both Whitson and Malenchenko have spent some days aboard the ISS in the past. “When you are so familiar with the layout of the station, you know what is kept where and so it feels like you are at home when everything around you is so familiar,” Malenchenko said.

Image: NASA

October 12, 2007

Bookmark in Connotea

Weekly round up - October 12, 2007

What’s been on The Great Beyond this week and a few extras...

Friday October 12
‘Evolutionary scandal’ of sexless bug solved / Al Gore and IPCC share peace prize

Thursday October 11
Nine slaps on the wrist for Al Gore / Allen array online / New Horizons visits Jupiter / Nature’s history online

Wednesday October 10
Chemistry Nobel announced / Aphids’ dangerous liaison / T. Rex reigned in Hell Valley

Tuesday October 09
Physics Nobel announced / Dinosaur of the day / Making elephants bee-hive / The only way to fly

Monday October 08
Medicine Nobel announced / ‘Space currency’ nonsense / International Cephalopod Awareness Day / Artificial life, again / Ig Nobels and science journalism

Other Nature blog posts you may have missed
Action Potential: our new neuroscience podcast
Nascent: science (and ex-Nature staff) in video games
The Sceptical Chymist: a tenuous link between nanotechnology and football

Ones that got away
DNA testing may clear up Christopher Columbus controversy, in the NY Times
End of the road for walrus satellite tag, from the BBC
Mongolia’s grasslands are turning to sand, from Reuters

The Great Beyond will be back on Monday.

Bookmark in Connotea

Al Gore and IPCC share peace prize - October 12, 2007

Al Gore will share this year’s Nobel Peace Prize with the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. They were awarded the prize for “for their efforts to build up and disseminate greater knowledge about man-made climate change, and to lay the foundations for the measures that are needed to counteract such change”.

The prize committee declared Al Gore “one of the world's leading environmentalist politicians” and said the IPCC had “created an ever-broader informed consensus about the connection between human activities and global warming”.

“Action is necessary now, before climate change moves beyond man’s control,” says the committee (press release).

This may take some of the sting out of the UK court ruling Al Gore’s An Inconvenient Truth movie will have to carry caveats when shown in schools – a ruling based in part on perceived differences between Gore’s stance and the scientific consensus outlined by ... the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. (see the updated bog posting on the ruling)

This is not the first time a prize has been won by an institution. In 2005 the International Atomic Energy Agency took half a prize, and other winners include the UN in 2001 and Médecins Sans Frontières in 1999. The real question is who will get the money at the IPCC?

The question for Gore is slightly different. The impressive Fiona Harvey at the FT has a very good piece up already, noting that the prize was perhaps unsurprising but "reinforced his reputation as the world’s foremost champion of environmental issues." It “also added to speculation that Mr Gore would be persuaded to have another attempt at the US presidency”.

UPDATE
“It’s every scientist's dream to win a Nobel Prize, so this is great for myself and the hundreds that worked on their reports over the years. It is perhaps a little deflating though - that one man and his PowerPoint show has as much influence as the decades of dedicated work by so many scientists,” said Piers Forster, of the University of Leeds School of Earth and Environment (via the Science Media Centre).

According to the NY Times Gore will donate his prize money to the Alliance for Climate Protection. “We face a true planetary emergency. The climate crisis is not a political issue, it is a moral and spiritual challenge to all of humanity,” he said.

Gore will not be joining George Bernard Shaw, who is the only person to have won both a Nobel and an Oscar. Shaw won the 1925 Nobel for literature and a 1938 Oscar for his Pygmalion screenplay. While Gore now has a Nobel, the Oscar awarded for An Inconvenient Truth is listed for best documentary under the name of Davis Guggenheim, its director.

Gore says:

I am deeply honored to receive the Nobel Peace Prize. This award is even more meaningful because I have the honor of sharing it with the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change -- the world's pre-eminent scientific body devoted to improving our understanding of the climate crisis -- a group whose members have worked tirelessly and selflessly for many years. We face a true planetary emergency.

Controversial economist and ‘skeptical environmentalist’ Bjorn Lomborg has also weighed in: “The IPCC engages in meticulous research where facts rule over everything else. Gore has a very different approach.”

Bookmark in Connotea

‘Evolutionary scandal’ of sexless bug solved - October 12, 2007

bdelloidrotifer.JPGReproducing asexually means losing much of the ability to adapt to environmental changes that comes from combining the genes of two parents. So it had been thought that asexual animals would be disadvantaged over serious timescales. However the hard-to pronounce bdelloid rotifer has been around for 80 million years and Cambridge scientists say that its sex-free life is part of its robustness (BBC, Telegraph, The Scientist, and Reuters – which says 40 not 80m years).

The water-dwelling invertebrate has the neat trick of drying out when there is a lack of liquid and surviving in this desiccated state for years, until the rains or some other sort of water comes along. Dr Alan Tunnacliffe, from University of Cambridge, discovered that the beasties have a gene where the two copies can do totally different jobs: one prevents proteins from clumping together and the other helps to maintain cell membranes. This differs from organisms that reproduce sexually where the two copies have the same job.

“Evolution of gene function in this way can’t happen in sexual organisms, which means there could be some benefit to millions of years without sex after all,” he said (press release). He expanded on this point to Reuters: “It is like having a bigger tool kit. You can do the same job but better.”

The Telegraph thinks Tunnacliffe has solved one of evolutionary science’s biggest problems. “[T]his pond life has been the one ugly fact undermining the beauty of sex: the translucent organisms abandoned sex such a long time ago that they were once denounced as an ‘evolutionary scandal’ by the late and great biologist Prof John Maynard Smith.”

The research is published in Science.

Image: Bdelloid rotifer by N. N. Pouchkina-Stantcheva

October 11, 2007

Bookmark in Connotea

Nature’s history online - October 11, 2007

This week we launched a new section of the Nature website detailing the journal’s history. It’s got some great timelines, videos, copies of the most important papers ever published, stories about the magazine’s fortunes and a whole lot more. You can also vote for the best thing that’s ever appeared in the magazine or online – currently winning is the initial sequencing and analysis of the human genome.

Bookmark in Connotea

New Horizons visits Jupiter - October 11, 2007

newhorzjupNASA.jpgLightning, ammonia clouds, volcanic moons – there’s enough to see at Jupiter that you’d think a long stay was called for, not a flying visit. However a flying visit was all that was on the cards for NASA’s New Horizons probe as it used the planet’s gravity to throw itself off towards its ultimate destination, Pluto and ithe icy wastes beyond. Still, the brief encounter was worth it, according to those involved.

“The Jupiter encounter was successful beyond our wildest dreams,” said Alan Stern, the probe’s principal investigator, and NASA’s chief scientist (press release). “Not only did it prove out our spacecraft and put it on course to reach Pluto in 2015, it was a chance for us to take sophisticated instruments to places in the Jovian system where other spacecraft couldn’t go, and to return important data that adds tremendously to our understanding of the solar system’s largest planet and its moons, rings and atmosphere.”

NASA says that a “combination of trajectory, timing and technology” allowed the probe to peek into regions not before seen. Stern and his team presented results of data from the fly by at an American Astronomical Society meeting in Orlando earlier this week. A whole host of papers should appear tomorrow in Science.

AFP is most impressed by the lightning, noting that some strikes were ten times more powerful than anything recorded on Earth. National Geographic reports on the fact that ‘moonlets’ scientists were expecting to find whizzing round in Jupiter’s rings were mysteriously absent. They did however find in the rings two lumps of ‘moon-like’ material, whatever that is (BBC). As Wired notes, some of the results from this fly by were released earlier this year, and reported at the time in Nature. Pretty pictures galore are on the New Horizons picture gallery.

UPDATE
Nature’s coverage of this is now online too, noting that plans to study Jupiter’s “famously tempestuous weather” were kyboshed by good weather. “We get there, and we were faked out. It was completely clear,” says Kevin Baines, a planetary scientist at the Jet Propulsion Laboratory in Pasadena, California

Image: Jupiter-Io Montage / NASA

Bookmark in Connotea

Allen array online  - October 11, 2007

Allenarray.jpgIf there is anyone out there astronomers are one step closer to finding them. A new array of 42 radio dishes designed to search for ETs has been unveiled. Eventually the Allen Telescope Array will boast a whopping 350 dishes.

Half of the $50 million tab for the new alien finder has been picked up by Microsoft founder Paul Allen. “It’s the longshot of longshots, but if we did hear a signal from another civilization, that would be world-changing,” said the deep-pocketed philanthropist (Seattle Times). It’s nice to see it the array has progressed since last year’s funding row, when Allen held back millions because other donors had not been found (Nature – subscription required).

This is apparently the first time a radio telescope has been put together with the express purpose of finding aliens, be they green or otherwise. “It’s like cutting the ribbon on the Nina, the Pinta and the Santa Maria,” astronomer Seth Shostak of the SETI Institute told the NY Times. However the Allen array will not just be looking for aliens, it will also help out understanding of supernovas, black holes and “exotic astronomical objects that are predicted but not yet observed”, according to UC Berkeley, which is running the array along with the SETI Institute (press release, video of dishes).

The multi-dish array represents the future of radio astronomy, stepping away from visually impressive but quickly outdated massive dishes such as the threatened Arecibo dish in Puerto Rico (which may just have been thrown a lifeline).

Perhaps rashly Shostak has predicted that signals from intelligent civilizations will be found by 2025. We’ll bring you an update then.

Image: Seth Shostak / SETI Institute

Bookmark in Connotea

Nine slaps on the wrist for Al Gore - UPDATED - October 11, 2007

earthnasa.jpgSchools in the UK should be allowed to show Al Gore’s climate change movie, but only if they give balancing information to pupils, a High Court judge has ruled. The case was brought to court by school governor Stewart Dimmock, who objected to government plans to send copies of An Inconvenient Truth to schools across the country. The judge, Sir Michael Burton, ruled there were nine scientific inaccuracies in the film, which he said had moments of “alarmism and exaggeration” (Guardian, BBC, AFP, Independent).

Errors included claiming that polar bears were drowning as they had to swim further and further to find ice and that sea levels would rise 20 feet as a result of melting Greenland ice in the near future. The Times runs down the nine. Some parts of the blogosphere are reporting eleven errors, taking them from Dimmock’s early statement.

Dimmock, a member of the minor political group the New Party, called the judgement a resounding victory (press release). But he added: “However, as a parent, I find it perplexing that, despite agreeing that that the film was riddled with errors and exaggerations, the Court failed to issue an outright ban on its use in the classroom. Perhaps the Government will now do the honourable thing and bin it.”

This does not seem likely. Children’s Minister Kevin Brennan is on record as saying that the “central argument” of An Inconvenient Truth is supported by the scientific community (BBC). “Nothing in the judge's comments today detract from that.”

Plans to distribute the film to schools in America ran into different problems last year: Keith Vranes had the story.

UPDATE - 12/10/07
Over at the Deltoid blog Tim Lambert (who pops up in the comments section here) is taking a number of journalists to task, including me. "There were nine points where Burton decided that AIT differed from the IPCC and that this should be addressed in the Guidance Notes for teachers to be sent out with the movie. Unfortunately a gaggle of useless journalists have misreported this decision as one that AIT contained nine scientific errors," he says.

When he talks of errors, Tim points out, the judge is

just referring to the things that Downes alleged were errors. Burton puts quote marks around 'error' 17 more times in his judgement….Burton is not even trying to decide whether they are errors or not. So what is Burton assessing in his judgement? Well, [the relevant law] says that where political issues are involved there should be "a balanced presentation of opposing views" so Burton states that the government should make it clear when "there is a view to the contrary, i.e. (at least) the mainstream view". Burton calls these "errors or departures from the mainstream".

Burton’s point is thus that the “errors” are not necessarily incorrect, just that their distance from the mainstream requires that they should be balanced in the context of the applicable law. Happy to clear that up.

Tim then takes issue with the various points.

UPDATE - 16/10/07
Real Climate has weighed in on this as well now: “Overall, our verdict is that the 9 points are not "errors" at all (with possibly one unwise choice of tense on the island evacuation point). But behind each of these issues lies some fascinating, and in some cases worrying, scientific findings and we can only applaud the prospect that more classroom discussions of these subjects may occur because of this court case.”

Image: NASA

October 10, 2007

Bookmark in Connotea

T. Rex reigned in Hell Valley - October 10, 2007

t-rexalamy.jpgAn ultra-rare T. Rex footprint may have been found in the Badlands of Montana. Phil Manning, from the Manchester Museum, University of Manchester, claims a metre-square track he found in rocks called the Hell Creek Formation was left by that most iconic of dinosaurs around 65 million years ago. “It could only be made by one of the two species known from Hell Creek - either the Nanotyrannus or its bigger relative, Tyrannosaurus rex. The size of the footprint at 76cm in length suggests it is more likely to be the latter,” he told a BBC documentary.

There is one previous claimed T. Rex footprint, discovered in New Mexico in 1983 and published 11 years later (see USGS). A number of news sources however are reporting this as the first ever found (PA, Daily Mail). A report on the fossil has apparently been submitted for peer review. Whether or not this is truly a T. Rex footprint will probably never be known. As Manning says: “Unless you come across an animal dead in its tracks you can't say for definite what left them.”

A reportage piece on the hunt for the footprint is already up on the BBC website, and there is a video clip of the footprint on YouTube.

Image: Alamy

Bookmark in Connotea

Aphids’ dangerous liaison - October 10, 2007

antaphid.jpgThe strange and slightly disturbing symbiotic relationship between ants and aphids has been made even more unsettling by a new discovery. It has previously been shown that the ants – which ‘milk’ the aphids for a sugary liquid – will chew off and chemically retard development of aphid wings to keep them nearby. Now it seems that they also dope them up so even if they try to run away they don’t get far (The Daily Telegraph).

“Although both parties benefit from the interaction, this research shows is that all is not well in the world of aphids and ants. The aphids are manipulated to their disadvantage: for aphids the ants are a dangerous liaison,” says Vincent Jansen of Royal Holloway university (Press release)

The researchers found that aphids walking on filter paper travelled much slower when the paper had previously been walked on by ants than they did on plain paper. And when placed on dead leaves – which they should try to leave in search of food – having ants around significantly slowed aphid departure. “We believe that ants could use the tranquillizing chemicals in their footprints to maintain a populous ‘farm’ of aphids close to their colony, to provide honeydew on tap. Ants have even been known to occasionally eat some of the aphids themselves, so subduing them in this way is obviously a great way to keep renewable honeydew and prey easily available,” says Tom Oliver, of Imperial College London (press release).

The paper doesn’t seem to be online yet but should eventually appear here.

Image: A digital camera was used to capture the walking speed of aphids / Imperial

Bookmark in Connotea

Chemistry Nobel announced - October 10, 2007

And the Nobel goes to Gerhard Ertl of the Max Planck Society's Fritz-Habert Institute for his studies of chemical processes on solid surfaces (announcement). On his birthday, too!

According to the press release

Ertl was one of the first to see the potential of new techniques [developed in the semiconductor industry]. Step by step he has created a methodology for surface chemistry by demonstrating how different experimental procedures can be used to provide a complete picture of a surface reaction. This science requires advanced high-vacuum experimental equipment as the aim is to observe how individual layers of atoms and molecules behave on the extremely pure surface of a metal, for instance. It must therefore be possible to determine exactly which element is admitted to the system. Contamination could jeopardize all the measurements. Acquiring a complete picture of the reaction requires great precision and a combination of many different experimental techniques.
Here's his lab's website.

Chemists will presumably be happy that this year's prize goes to one of their own -- there have been dark murmurs about chemistry prizes going to biologists in recent years. Anyone with a bet on the prize at the Chembark blog can expect a 15 to 1 payoff.

See below the fold for more coverage as it happens.

For coverage of yesterday's Nobel for Physics, awarded to Albert Fert and Peter Grünberg of the Jülich Research Centre for the discovery of giant magnetoresistance, see this post.

For coverage of Monday's Nobel for Physiology or Medicine, awarded to Mario Capecchi, Martin Evans and Oliver Smithies for knockout mice, see this post.

Continue reading "Chemistry Nobel announced" »

October 09, 2007

Bookmark in Connotea

The only way to fly - October 09, 2007

airship.JPGOK, I was hoping the last post on Arctic ice would wrap things up for the season. There’s one more though that is too good to pass up. Like a latter-day Jules Verne hero, French explorer Jean-Louis Etienne is setting off to measure ice thickness in an airship, newly delivered from Russia. The vessel is 55 m long, 17 m high, contains 5,000 square metres [as William points out in the comments below this should clearly have been m3, apologies] of helium and can carry a payload of 1.5 tons. Etienne says he is working on a larger airship for Earth observation, with a 30 ton payload and an 8,000 km range.

Using a device called the EM bird the airship will fly over the Arctic recording the ice thickness. The EM bird emits a laser beam to map the surface of the ice and a low-frequency electromagnetic beam to probe the bottom surface, both together yield the thickness (View image). A photo gallery of the airship’s assembly is also online. She’s a lot prettier than your average ice breaker.

This is far from the first time airships have been used in this region. Here’s Nature from 1907: Mr. Walter Wellman, who proposes to make another attempt to reach the North Pole by means of his airship America, has left for Norway, on the way to Spitsbergen, where the balloon will be inflated.

Image: artist’s impression of airship

Bookmark in Connotea

Making elephants bee-hive - October 09, 2007

elephant.jpgYou might think a 10 ton elephant wouldn’t give a second thought to a tiny bee. You’d be wrong. To the glee of headline writers, researchers from Kenya and the UK have found that playing the sound of angry bees to African elephants makes them scarper, and fast.

“We weren’t surprised that they responded to the threatening sound of disturbed bees, as elephants are intelligent animals that are intimately aware of their surroundings, but we were surprised at how quickly they responded to the sounds by running away. Almost half of our study herds started to move away within 10 seconds of the bee playback,” said Lucy King of the University of Oxford (press release).

All this has triggered a slew of stories including riffs on how it’s not really mice elephants are afraid of, ‘buzzing off’, and a pun almost as bad as my headline about the ‘fright of the humble bee’ (Daily Mail, BBC, Guardian respectively).

There is a serious side to this though. In the latest issue of the Current Biology journal King an colleagues propose that the noise of bees could be used to deter elephants from areas where they will come into conflict with humans. This could be hugely important for the cowardly animals’ conservation.

Image: Punch Stock

Bookmark in Connotea

Dinosaur of the day - October 09, 2007

suzy.bmpThose who enjoyed Nature’s recent feature on the Walking With Dinosaurs live experience currently touring America may be interested to know that a team including the palaeontologist featured in that article, Ken Lacovara of Drexel University, has just announced the discovery of a fearsome looking but apparently plant eating new dinosaur Suzhousaurus megatherioides. The team was led by Dr Hai-Lu You of the Chinese Academy of Geological Science and the research is published in Acta Geologica Sinica. In a press release, Lacovara describes the therizinosaurs, of which this is one, as being “characterized by feathered bodies, turkey-like heads, Edward Scissorhands-like claws, and plump pot-bellies.”

There’s been some media pick up in Live Science and in the Pittsbugh papers, reflecting the local affiliation of another team member, Matt Lamanna of Carnegie Museum of Natural History. The Philadelphia Inquirer, though, seems to have passed on it. Meanwhile Fox News cuts to the chase with a classic headline over the Live Science piece: Funny-looking dinosaur found in China.

What’s more, Ken and his wife have just had a son. Congratulations!

By Oliver Morton.

Illustration: Mark A. Klingler, Carnegie Museum of Natural History.

Bookmark in Connotea

Physics Nobel announced - October 09, 2007

And the Nobel goes to Albert Fert of the University of Paris-Sud and Peter Grünberg of the Jülich Research Centre for the discovery of giant magnetoresistance (announcement). It's their second big prize of the year -- they took a share of the Japan Prize this spring (press release)

For updates see the full post.

For coverage of yesterday's Nobel for Physiology or Medicine, awarded to Mario Capecchi, Martin Evans and Oliver Smithies, see this post

Continue reading "Physics Nobel announced" »

October 08, 2007

Bookmark in Connotea

Ig Nobels and science journalism - October 08, 2007

shredded_paper.jpgLast week saw the welcome return of the Ig Nobels – the annual prizes for silly sounding, salacious or just plain strange science. The official website is still suffering problems with traffic but you can read Nature’s personal account instead. The Guardian is running a slide show of the awards.

This year’s prizes give us an opportunity to settle a long running debate in the Nature office: who covers the most silly science. Using some highly arbitrary search terms and the giant LexisNexis database of news reports we have complied a list of which newspapers gave most coverage to ignoble research before it was officially Ig Nobel*.

Way out in front is the UK’s Express – self styled ‘world’s greatest newspaper’ – with eleven stories. In second place is another UK paper, The Guardian, with eight stories. North American sources pop up in a tied third place – with the US McClatchy-Tribune service and Canada’s National Post both showing six stories. Finally, a tied fifth place with an appropriate five stories each goes to 24 Hours and the Calgary Herald.

A strong showing for Canada, the UK firmly on top and our more serious / higher standard US colleagues left in the dust.

*Caveat: This research was done in a short time period using highly unscientific methods and would never be accepted in a peer reviewed journal of any standard. It would be foolish to assume this picked up every story written, however we think we are likely to have missed stories across the board, hence evening things out.

Image: Getty

Bookmark in Connotea

Artificial life, again - October 08, 2007

dnagreygetty.jpgCraig Venter has been at it again. This time he’s cited in the Guardian claiming to have created a synthetic chromosome and to be nearly ready to announce the first creation of artificial life. A rather breathless write-up of these claims by the paper says, as Venter has been known to, that this could even combat global warming.

Venter’s opening the meeting his institutes hold every year today, and there’s rampant speculation, including in the Guardian, that he may announce his ‘artificial life’ there. The Guardian says a team of scientists assembled by Venter and led by his long-term collaborator the Nobel laureate Hamilton Smith has used “lab-made chemicals” (presumably oligonucleotides) to build a 381-gene chromosome 580,000 base-pairs long. They plan to put this chromosome into a living cell and “it is expected to take control of the cell and in effect become a new life form”, says the paper.

In a profile piece in the paper, which is also carrying an extract from his autobiography, Venter clarifies: “It’s not like baking a cake, mixing all the ingredients and putting it in the oven, and hey presto, there's new life. We’re not creating life, we are creating new life forms from existing ones.”

A patent on this ‘synthetic life-form’ was filed last year (detailed by Nature columnist Philip Ball).

The story is getting wide pick up, although not many people seem to know what to make of it. Venter spokeswoman (and fiancée) Heather Kowalski told AFP, “The Guardian is ahead of themselves on this. We have not achieved what some have speculated we have in synthetic life. When we do so there will be a scientific publication and we are likely months away from that.”

UPDATE 10/10/07
University of Cambridge biochemist Dr Nick Gay is not impressed with Venter’s claims (The Guardian). “On the face of it this seems to be a spectacular advance. Unfortunately the truth is rather different.”

Image: Getty

Bookmark in Connotea

International Cephalopod Awareness Day - October 08, 2007

octopuspunchstock.jpgEvery day is something’s day. However the Great Beyond cannot resist noting that today is the unofficial International Cephalopod Awareness Day, celebrating squid, cuttlefish and the only animal I ever feel guilty about eating, the octopus. To celebrate the Cephalopodcast has a video of Vintage Octopus Wrestling and over on Pharyngula PZ Myers is getting very excited.

Octopus have eight arms, and today is the eighth, while squid have eight arms and two tentacles, and this is the tenth month. Devotees of Bruce Schneier though will be surprised that International Cephalopod Awareness Day does not fall on a Friday, by statute.

Image: Punch Stock

Bookmark in Connotea

‘Space currency’ nonsense - October 08, 2007

quid.jpgAccording to some journalists who must have been particularly bored “scientists” have invented a new currency for “inter-planetary travelers” (BBC). In order to generate some free publicity, a firm which I’m deliberately not going to mention has come up with a poker chip with nice rounded edges “to avoid damaging people and equipment if accidentally allowed to float free in zero gravity”. In a master stroke of wit they’re calling it a Quasi Universal Intergalactic Denomination or QUID, which would only be funny to British citizens, if it were funny at all (press release).

Professor George Fraser from the University of Leicester is quoted as saying “Anything with sharp edges, like coins, would be a risk to astronauts while the chips and magnetic strips used in our cards on Earth would be damaged beyond repair by cosmic radiation.” I would have thought if you’re a space tourist and there’s enough cosmic radiation around to fry your credit card you’ve got bigger problems.

How on earth this made it onto the science section of a reputable website is beyond me. Wired seems to take a similar view. Apparently the going rate for a QUID is £6.25, although I’ll be surprised if anyone can actually find one to buy.

Bookmark in Connotea

Medicine Nobel announced - October 08, 2007

This year’s Nobel prize season has kicked off. The first winners were announced this morning: Mario Capecchi, Martin Evans and Oliver Smithies share the Physiology or Medicine prize “for their discoveries of principles for introducing specific gene modifications in mice by the use of embryonic stem cells”. This is effectively a re-run of the 2001 Lasker Award, which was given to the same trio for the same work on ‘knockout mice’ (Nature). Smithies wrote about the award of this prize in Nature Medicine at the time.

Toolmakers—and I suspect that the three of us being honored by the Lasker Foundation fit into this category—are fortunate people. They see problems, invent tools to solve them and enjoy the solutions, which often demonstrate new principles that were not part of the original thought. As a bonus, they also enjoy the vicarious pleasure of seeing other people use the same tools to solve very different problems. Yet the invention of an effective scientific tool is rarely an isolated event; there are often many prior experiences that trigger the inventive thought, and there may be various unexpected additional problems to solve before the toolmaker can bring a nascent idea into practice.

Capecchi’s amazing life story was detailed in a Nature feature in 2004. There’s a relevant extract below the fold:

Continue reading "Medicine Nobel announced" »

October 05, 2007

Bookmark in Connotea

Weekly round up  - October 05, 2007

What’s been on The Great Beyond this week and a few extras...

Friday October 05
Cycads’ complicated love life / Europe and creationism - UPDATE / California geologists rock the party / ‘Saint Pete’ to step down

Thursday October 04
Tasmanian Devils face extinction / A duck-billed plant pulveriser / New space war threatened

Wednesday October 03
The new face of Nature News / Pretty pictures from Hubble / Lab lapses spark safety fears / Self tuning guitar hits bum note

Tuesday October 02
Arctic ice on the rocks / Centre fined over macaque death / CSI Llullaillaco’s grisly discovery

Monday October 01
Israel boycott ‘would be illegal’ / Bush’s climate change ‘charade’ / Next stop: the ocean

Other Nature blog posts you may have missed
Climate Feedback: the difficult life of a US state climatologist
Nascent: Second Nature Event - Bluetongue disease special
Spoonful of Medicine: lay off DDT?

Ones that got away
Why paintings can improve climate science, in The Guardian
People in the UK no longer need licences for their sloths, in the Times
How to make a jellyfish cocktail, in NPR

The Great Beyond will be back on Monday.

Bookmark in Connotea

Cycads’ complicated love life - October 05, 2007

cycad.jpgLike an uncouth lothario, plants have been found to attract pollinating insects with perfume and then kick them out when they’ve had their way with them (AP, Reuters, AFP). Tiny insects called thrips are driven off Australian cycads as the plants heat up their male cones and emit a noxious odour. Later cycads attract the same, pollen-laden thrips back to their female cones with attractive perfumes (Science abstract).

“People think of plants as just sitting there and looking pretty and sending out some odors to attract pollinators, but these cycads have a specific sexual behavior tuned to repel, attract and deceive the thrips that pollinate them,” according to Irene Terry from the University of Utah (press release).

Low-levels of a chemical emitted by the plants – beta-myrcene – are attractive to thrips. To drive them away the cycads ramp up production and raise the heat of their male cones by up to 12°C above their surroundings. “These cycads heat up, and associated with that heating is a huge increase in volatile fragrances emitted by the cone. It takes your breath away. It’s a harsh, overwhelming odor like nothing you ever smelled before,” says Terry.

Image: Thrips trying to enter cone of a male cycad plant before the cone opens / Irene Terry

Bookmark in Connotea

Europe and creationism - UPDATE - October 05, 2007

Last week we told you how the Council of Europe was considering issuing a harsh condemnation of creationism. Well, they’ve gone and done it. Members of the council’s parliament voted 48 to 25 for a motion declaring, “If we are not careful, creationism could become a threat to human rights” (press release). The best coverage is probably from International Herald Tribune.

The council, which boasts 47 nations as members, has its work cut out for it – at the same time that it was busy condemning creationism others were telling science teachers to respect those who wished to believe it (AP, BBC). “The days have long gone when science teachers could ignore creationism when teaching about origins,” said Michael Reiss, from the University of London. You’ll have to read half way down the BBC and AP stories before discovering he’s an Anglican priest.

Council's adopted resolution
Voting results

Bookmark in Connotea

California geologists rock the party - October 05, 2007

san andrea fault line_california.jpgIntact rock samples pulled from two miles below the surface of the San Andreas Fault could answer fundamental questions about the zone. “Now we can hold the San Andreas Fault in our hands. We know what it's made of. We can study how it works,” said Mark Zoback of Stanford, one of the principal investigators on the San Andreas Fault Observatory at Depth project.

Zoback and colleagues drilled a ton of rock from the active fault, in cores 4 inches wide totalling 135 feet in length. Serpentine contained in the rock could explain why the fault slides relatively easily, this mineral forms talc in certain conditions. Previous drilling by SAFOD detected talc (reported at the time in Nature, with an accompanying news and views) and the new cores could provide more details.

The best part of the press release has been picked up by the LA Times: “The scientists will hold a ‘sample party’ in December to show the cores to experts from around the world and invite them to propose research projects.” The new samples will help determine the exact make up of the fault as well as what happens when stress builds up, according to AP. Sadly, as PA notes, the cores will not help actually predict earthquakes. “That goal is still out of reach, despite a century of research into earthquake physics.”

Image: San Andreas fault / Punch Stock

Bookmark in Connotea

‘Saint Pete’ to step down - October 05, 2007

domenici.jpgFrom our Washington office...

US Senator Pete Domenici, a long-time protector of the national labs and perhaps the biggest congressional advocate of nuclear power, has announced he will retire at the end of his term next year (AP, CNN). Domenici has reportedly been diagnosed with a degenerative brain disease (CNN).

News reports have focused on the New Mexico Republican’s departure as the latest sign of a crumbling Republican party (Washington Post, CNN). He is one of several Republican Senators who will be stepping down next year, making an already difficult election even harder. But his departure will spark particular interest within Energy Department laboratories. Known alternatively as an old budgetary hawk and a master of political pork [Funds distributed to curry favour – ed.], Domenici has spent the past 35 years ensuring that Los Alamos and Sandia, in particular, get the money they need – if not a little more. These talents have earned him the moniker “Saint Pete”, frequently employed by critics and supporters alike.

Although his influence will surely be missed among many in the Land of Enchantment, it’s unlikely that New Mexico would elect a successor who is openly hostile toward the national laboratories, which bring several billion dollars into the state each year. On the other hand, Domenici has been the biggest backer of a controversial Energy Department proposal to revive nuclear reprocessing in support of a global expansion of nuclear power. It is unclear who will carry the torch on Capitol Hill in his absence.

Jeff Tollefson, Reporter, Washington bureau

October 04, 2007

Bookmark in Connotea

Tasmanian Devils face extinction - October 04, 2007

tasmanian-devil.jpgThey may not be as cute as koala, as iconic as kangaroos, or as just-plain-weird as the platypus but Australia would still be a poorer place without the Tasmanian Devil. Sadly the devil is headed for extinction within five years, decimated by a deadly, infectious facial tumour (The Age, ABC, AAP, Tasmania’s Mercury). Research has now uncovered why the animals have no immune response at all to the tumours – genetic diversity in a key set of genes is so low that the devils’ immune systems do not recognise the tumours as foreign.

The research, published online in PNAS, shows that the tumours are actually clonal cell lines – a tissue graft being passed from one animal to another when they bite each other in fights or during mating (abstract, pdf). “We found that the Devils do not mount an immune response against the tumour,” says author Katherine Belov from Sydney University's School of Veterinary Science (press release).

“This was due to a loss of genetic diversity in the most important immune gene region of the genome: the Major Histocompatibility Complex (MHC). Matching of MHC genes is the key to successful tissue or organ transplants. In the case of the devil, genetic diversity at MHC genes is so low, and the MHC type of the tumour and host are so alike, that the host does not see the tumour as ‘non-self’.”

On the plus side isolated populations of devils might have different MHC genes, and be able to fight the tumour (Mercury). The finding might help stop the spread of the disease, but it’s bad news for those already infected. “Essentially, there are no natural barriers to the spread of the disease, so affected individuals must be removed from populations to stop disease transmission,” said Belov (press release).

The Sidney Morning Herald last month noted that a set of healthy animals has been sent to zoos and sanctuaries on the mainland under the auspices of the imaginatively titled ‘Project Ark’. The UK’s Independent has picked up on this and provides a remarkable example of how similarly journalists think noting: “Less cuddly than the koala, less quirky than the kangaroo, the Tasmanian devil is not everyone's cup of tea.” But you’ll miss them when they’re gone...

See also: Nature’s feature from last year.

Image: Getty

Bookmark in Connotea

A duck-billed plant pulveriser - October 04, 2007

duckosaur.jpgA “monster” dinosaur has been unveiled by Utah scientists. However, although its duck bill contained 300 teeth ready to chew and another 500 in reserve, Gryposaurus monumentensis was a confirmed herbivore (Daily Utah Chronicle, Deseret Morning News). “What you're looking at with Gryposaurus monumentensis is basically the Cretaceous version of a weed whacker,” said Terry Gates, a Utah Museum of Natural History and University of Utah palaeontologist (Reuters).

The latter part of its name comes not from the beast’s huge size, but from the area where it was found – the Kaiparowits Formation in the Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monument. Roaming the area 75 million years ago, it would have been the largest dinosaur in the Kaiparowits fossil ecosystem, according to Alan Titus, paleontologist for the national monument (press release, research abstract). It was, says Scott Sampson, curator of the Utah Museum of Natural History, “like the Arnold Schwarzenegger of dinosaurs — it's all pumped up” (various, including AP).

Image: Utah Museum of Natural History

Bookmark in Connotea

New space war threatened - October 04, 2007

sputnik.jpgWhat better way to mark Sputnik’s 50th birthday than to warn of a new space arms race? “We do not want to fight in space, but on the other hand, we will not allow any other country to [be the] boss in space,” Colonel-General Vladimir Popovkin, Russia’s Space Forces Commander, apparently said (Interfax). Novosti has the slightly different translation: “We do not want to fight in space, and we do not want to call the shots there either, but we will not permit any other country to do so.”

It would be a tad unfair to cite this as Russian sabre rattling. Popovkin also said “Today space is the only area free of arms and the situation should be legalized in international legal documents.” China has already successfully tested an anti-satellite weapon but Popovkin’s statements are being seen more as aimed at the west, particularly America’s anti-missile programme (Reuters, AFP).

Anyway, NASA’s head honcho Michael Griffin thinks China is a bigger space threat than Russia for now. “I personally believe that China will be back on the moon before we are” he said (AP). “I think when that happens, Americans will not like it. But they will just have to not like it.”

It’s not all doom and gloom in space though – Russia and America have signed an agreement to cooperate on a search for water on the moon (AP). So at least we can find out if there’s something there worth fighting over before we start fighting.

READ NATURE’S COVERAGE OF SPUTNIK’S 50TH AND RUSSIAN SCIENCE HERE.

Image: NASA

October 03, 2007

Bookmark in Connotea

The new face of Nature News - October 03, 2007

Our news site has been redesigned to make the stories even more timely, easier to find, and open to comment and conversation from our readers. Check out our homepage to see what has changed and get all the latest news.

Here are some highlights of the new site:

NEW BLOGS
The Great Beyond rounds up the world of science news as reported elsewhere, letting you know what’s hot, and who’s got the best scoop.
In the Field delivers diary reports from our reporters as they trawl conference floors or attend exciting science events.

COMMENTING
Have an opinion on our news stories or columns? Now you can post your comments straight onto any story on www.nature.com/news. Join the conversation!

OPINON
Our opinion page collects the columns, editorials and commentaries from Nature – find out what we think about contentious (or whimsical) issues in science.

SEARCH
Only interested in one thing? Use the ‘archive / view by subject’ tab to find stories in one field only, or click on the ‘keywords’ to the left of any story to see what else we have written on that subject.
Only interested in what’s hot? Use the tab in the upper right hand corner of the site to find the stories most commented upon, or most blogged in the blogosphere.

More than half of our daily online content is free for 4 days from publication. To get full access, check out our subscriptions. To get a full tour of all the site’s features, check out ‘about this site’.

We are aware that there may be some glitches and teething problems with the new design, and we want you to tell us about them. If you find a broken link, get annoyed or frustrated by the navigation, or simply can’t find something, write to us on redesign@nature.com.

Sincerely,
Nature News online editor
Nicola Jones.

Bookmark in Connotea

Pretty pictures from Hubble - October 03, 2007

The Hubble Telescope has snapped another image to get photo editors slavering (Wired, National Geographic, Space.com, MSNBC, The Australian). This one is of NGC 3603, a giant nebula in the Milky Way that hosts young stars. Analysis of the nebula, which is 20,000 light-years away from Earth, should provide insights into star formation (press release 1, press release 2).

hubblepretty.jpg
Violent winds have carved a cavity in the dust and gas surrounding the cluster, revealing a panoply of hot, blue stars. The darkening in the lower left is due to extinction of starlight and interstellar reddening caused by dust clouds in the foreground. In the top right Bok globules - clouds of dust and gas with masses up to fifty times that of the Sun - are visible.

Annotated image
Movie

Image: NASA/ ESA/ STScI/Aura

Bookmark in Connotea

Lab lapses spark safety fears - October 03, 2007

lab.jpgYou can say “public was never at risk” till the cows come home, but if labs handling “the world’s deadliest germs and toxins” have suffered over 100 accidents and losses since 2003 people are going to worry. An investigation by the AP has found mishaps involving anthrax, bird flu, monkey pox and other unpleasant things at 44 labs in 24 US states. “It may be only a matter of time before our nation has a public health incident with potentially catastrophic results,” said Bart Stupak, who is heading up a forthcoming hearing into the issue for the House of Representatives (hearing pdf).

A new report from a congressional watchdog warns that little is known of goings on at research centres that don’t receive federal funds or don’t work with the 72 most dangerous substances that the government keeps a close eye on. The report – from the Government Accountability Office – isn’t yet released but AP seems to have seen a copy. It says it will state: “No single federal agency ... has the mission to track the overall number of these labs in the United States. Consequently, no agency is responsible for determining the risks associated with the proliferation of these labs.”

The report and hearing come on the heals of high profile problems at Texas A&M University earlier this year (see Nature). Biodefence work at the university was halted after workers were twice been exposed to pathogens. Subscribers to Science can read a major investigation into biosafety problems in this week’s issue. This raises the point that money has been pouring into biodefence work since the 2001 Anthrax attacks and asks “Are the nation’s ... labs safe enough?”

The LA Times has a similar story to AP and Science, leading on the Texas A&M problems. Nature covered some of the same ground in August when problems at a UK lab caused an outbreak of Foot and Mouth.

Bookmark in Connotea

Self tuning guitar hits bum note - October 03, 2007

sheet_music.jpgCall me old fashioned, but I’ve always thought live rock music should involve feedback, distortion, frequent changes of guitar and the opportunity for witty stage banter provided by the need for the lead guitarist to tune up. Not so axe manufacturer Gibson. Fresh from inventing a digital guitar to do away with distortion they’ve invented a self tuning guitar.

While helpful gadgets that will tell you if you’re out of tune have been around for a while, Gibson have stuck one on an instrument and rigged it up to tiny motors that will tighten or loosen the strings for you. This isn’t actually the first guitar with built in tuning, as Gibson are good enough to admit in the press release they put out on September 21st. Still, after a new write up in Technology Review this kit is getting some attention (Gizmodo, USA Today, Engadget).

While some are keen, others are decidedly not. “Look, I’m lazy, okay? But I'm not too lazy to tune my own goddamn guitar properly. You can spend $900 on this magic thing or you can spend $12 for a friggin’ tuner,” says one blogger.

Image: Punchstock

October 02, 2007

Bookmark in Connotea

Arctic ice on the rocks - October 02, 2007

arcticicecomposite.pngThis year's record lows in arctic sea ice have been matched by record highs in media coverage of things arctic. Records for ice area have been smashed then smashed again, fabled sea routes have opened, countries have started jockeying for rights to the sea floor, polar bears over swathes of the ice are under threat, and more. Now, though, the spate seems to be coming to its natural end as melt season comes to its close and stock is taken.

Researchers at the US the National Snow and Ice Data Center have analysed the season and found ice ended up 39% below the long-term average from 1979 to 2000 and 23% below the previous record set in 2005. Global warming is partly to blame for this but other factors such as unusually cloudless skies are also implicated (NSIDC press release).

The New York Times reports that experts are (still) worried, with one saying: “Our stock in trade seems to be going away.” This is basically the same story that has been being written for the last month – the 2005 records were actually broken in August and the ice continued to melt well into September. This hasn’t stopped Reuters and the Times revisiting the issue now and the latter has produced a rather snazzy graphic of the ice decline.

In other arctic news, lack of sea ice could have been a contributory factor in the break up of the giant Ayles Ice Island, says the BBC. The “Manhattan-sized berg” has split in two “far earlier than expected”. And there’s more bad news for the polar bears – an expert at the US Fish and Wildlife Service in another NY Times article says there are two paths open to them at the moment: a slow decline or a fast decline.

Image: composite satellite image taken September 15 and 16 / NSIDC

Bookmark in Connotea

Centre fined over macaque death - October 02, 2007

An animal research centre in the US has been slapped with a $15,000 fine for offences including inadequate care for a lab animal after the death of a macaque monkey. While accepting the fine, Yerkes National Primate Research Center has denied any wilful wrongdoing (AP). The centre, part of Emory University, was fined after two inspections found unsanitary conditions and inadequate staff training.

The US Department of Agriculture found rat droppings in research facilities and blamed equipment failures for the death of the monkey (according to the Emory Wheel, a student paper). USDA spokeswoman Jessica Miteer told the paper that the university had paid two previous fines, for water deprivation and enclosures of inadequate size. “We never say we’re perfect, and we’re always open to getting better,” said a university spokesperson.

Bookmark in Connotea

CSI Llullaillaco’s grisly discovery - October 02, 2007

andes.jpg
Analysis of child sacrifice victims found on an Andean volcano has shed new light on the selection and grooming of those chosen as offerings. Hairs from sacrifices found on the Llullaillaco volcano show marked changes in diet, suggesting victims were being prepared for their fate for at least a year before they were killed in an Inca ritual (Times, Daily Telegraph, AP, Reuters). Analysis of isotopes in hair from one victim – called the Llullaillaco Maiden – shows standard peasant vegetables of her diet being enriched with the ‘elite food’ maize and animal protein. These changes, states the research paper, “can be taken to indicate that the Maiden had been raised in status, presumably for the express purpose of making her an appropriate sacrifice” (abstract).

Study author Andrew Wilson, of the University of Bradford, said: “By examining hair samples from these unfortunate children, a chilling story has started to emerge of how the children were ‘fattened up’ for sacrifice. Given the surprising change in their diets and the symbolic cutting of their hair, it appears that various events were staged in which the status of the children was raised. In effect, their countdown to sacrifice had begun some considerable time prior to death.” (Press release.)

Taking each 10mm of hair as being one month and working backward from the point of death Wilson and colleagues analysed changes in the chemical isotopes present. Different types of plants use different types of photosynthesis and therefore end up with different ratios of the carbon 12 and carbon 13 isotopes – the latter being heavier as it has an extra neutron. This allowed the team to distinguish between plants such as roots and tubers and other plants such as maize. Other isotope variations can track changes in temperature and altitude and whether diets are marine or terrestrial in origin.

Image: Earth observation of Andes Mountains / NASA

October 01, 2007

Bookmark in Connotea

Israel boycott ‘would be illegal’ - October 01, 2007

In what may be the final chapter of a long-running tale, British academics were warned last week that an organised boycott of Israeli universities would be illegal (Guardian, Independent, AP, Ha'aretz, European Jewish Press). The University and College Union received legal advice that “It would be beyond the union's powers and unlawful for the union, directly or indirectly, to call for, or to implement, a boycott by the union and its members of any kind of Israeli universities and other academic institutions; and that the use of union funds directly or indirectly to further such a boycott would also be unlawful.” (Press release.)

British academics have long debated the merits of boycotting Israeli academics in solidarity with Palestine. In May union members continued their annual tradition of voting on a boycott. This time a planned pathway to severing ties with Israeli institutions was approved by 158 votes to 99 (Guardian). Ever-so-slightly-partisan coverage on Inside Higher Ed notes that, “For several years now, British faculty unions have been voting in various ways to encourage members to boycott Israeli academics and universities”.

The news has been welcomed in Israel where foreign ministry spokesman Mark Regev told AFP: “It’s important news for Israeli universities as it shows that joint efforts can counter cynical manoeuvres aimed at undermining the international legitimacy of Israel.” There are also reports that a planned tour of the UK by Palestinian officials has been cancelled following the legal advice.

Union heads seem relieved that they have finally been able to sidestep this issue. Sally Hunt, UCU general secretary, said: “I hope this decision will allow all to move forwards and focus on what is our primary objective, the representation of our members.” (Press release.)

Bookmark in Connotea

Bush’s climate change ‘charade’ - October 01, 2007

earthnasa.jpgHere in Europe, climate change watchers are annoyed by George Bush. However, in something of a change from the previous situation, they’re now annoyed at him because he thinks climate change is happening and will lead the world on the issue. A special summit called by President Bush last week saw him admit that climate change was real. However critics were not impressed by the suggestion it can be tackled with voluntary targets for emission reduction and for Bush’s call for "a new international approach on greenhouse gas emissions" (LA Times).

“It was a total charade and has been exposed as a charade. I have never heard a more humiliating speech by a major leader. He [Bush] was trying to present himself as a leader while showing no sign of leadership. It was a total failure,” one anonymous attending diplomat told the Guardian. Another anonymous diplomat with remarkably similar views told the BBC: “This is a total charade. ... It’s humiliating for him - a total humiliation.”

The crux of complaints is that Bush is still pushing a ‘technology will save us’ line instead of embracing the mandatory emission reduction targets favoured by other nations. To be fair it was known before the meeting that hard reduction targets were not on the agenda. Other critics have suggested the summit is an attempt to undermine a parallel UN meeting (detailed last week over on Nature proper).

Not everyone is so sure the meeting was a complete waste of time. The NY Times opines:

President Bush’s two-day summit on global warming this week was not, as some of the European delegates complained privately, a total bust. ... It displayed a more open-minded and somewhat chastened George Bush, now in legacy mode and no longer in deep denial about the existence of global warming or the fact that humans and fossil fuels are primarily responsible for it.

However the NYT goes on to pretty much agree with the widespread European view that, as it puts it, “positives pale in comparison to the negatives, chiefly Mr Bush’s failure to commit the United States to anything new or bold or inspiring”.

On climate change it seems poor Bush just can’t win.

Bookmark in Connotea

Next stop: the ocean - October 01, 2007

reef0090.jpgOver a thousand unwanted subway cars are being dumped into the ocean in the United States. But worry not environmentalists; these are going to form artificial reefs. Over at amNewYork there’s a video of carriages being dumped – sorry, recycled – into the sea and Robert Martore, of the South Carolina Department of Natural Resources, tells you “it’s not a means of waste disposal”. Perish the thought. In fact, says Martore, “they’re almost custom made to be fish houses”.

I guess fish love asbestos then – Newsday and others note that there is plenty of the carcinogen in the carriages. Removing it would have cost $27 million. “New Jersey’s artificial-reef program should only utilize the highest quality materials. There are unanswered questions about the integrity of the subway cars,” Tim Dillingham of the American Littoral Society says in the Asbury Park Press.

Subway cars are made of thinner steel than ships sunk for reefs and tend to degrade reasonably quickly. A 2005 report from New Jersey states that subways cars are prohibited for use in reef construction there, but authorised a pilot study using them. Now either the evidence has changed or the finances have. The Press of Atlantic City quotes numerous studies cited in justifying the decision. It also notes that subway cars are not an acceptable material for artificial reefs under current state guidelines and under the Army Corps of Engineers permits for the sites in that area. Those are now in the process of being changed.

Some artificial reefs appear to have been successful. Others less so. Earlier this year divers began dismantling a failed artificial reef made of tyres in Florida that had come loose and started damaging coral (Nature, subscription required). Doubts have also been aired about plans to leave oil rigs in place as artificial reefs after they become redundant (Nature, subscription required).

Image: Natural coral among artificial reef materialsby Dr James McVey / NOAA