« Paper trail: Tehran calling | Main | George Church on "Constructive Biology" »

Jim Crow Q&A

Gene Expression has 10 questions for Jim Crow (and answers). Here’s Crow, responding to a question about the difficulties in addressing hot-button issues such as possible intergroup genetic variation contributing to differences in brain development and/or intelligence:

I hope that such questions can be approached with the same objectivity as that when we study inheritance of bristle number in Drosophila, but I don't expect it soon. There are too many strongly held opinions. I thought Lahn had a clever idea in thinking that the normal alleles of head-reducing mutants might be responsible for evolution of larger heads in human ancestry. Likewise, I think that Cochran et al. are fully entitled to consider the reasons for Jewish intelligence and I found their arguments interesting. In my view it is wrong to say that research in this area -- assuming it is well done -- is out of order. I feel srongly that we should not discourage a line of research because someone might not like a possible outcome.

You can read the two most relevant papers by Lahn and colleagues here and here, as well as just-published criticisms of this work, and a response by Lahn and colleagues. As for the paper by Cochran et al. entitled “Natural History of Ashkenazi Intelligence”, a good summary has been written by Steven Pinker.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://blogs.nature.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-tb.cgi/878

Post a comment

Comments will be reviewed by the editors before being published. You can be as critical or controversial as you like, but please don't get personal or offensive. We strongly encourage you to use your real, full name. Email addresses are useful in case we need to discuss your comment with you privately, or notify you in case we decide not publish your comment. Email addresses will not be made public on the blog.


Please enter the numbers you see below - this helps us to cut down on spam. If you are having trouble with this system, you can instead e-mail a comment to 'a.packer at natureny dot com'.