Element of the month – Under sulfur’s spell

In this month’s ‘in your element’ article (subscription required), Thomas Rauchfuss from Illinois points out curious trends in sulfur’s chemistry.

As it turns out, sulfur is a little difficult to describe in a concise manner: although in its elemental form it mostly adopts a crown-shaped 8-membered ring structure, it also exists in 7-membered rings (those are the bright yellow ones) and even traces of smaller rings; and it happily converts to a one-dimensional elastomer when heated. Its anions also like to form chains, which can be extended or reduced, and easily catenated, through redox chemistry.

Similarly, its reactivity can be puzzling, and in particular its catalytic activity. Even though sulfur is well-known to poison industrial catalysts, it actually acts as a catalyst in biological systems — among many other roles. Metal sulfide clusters can quickly transfer electrons, a very desirable property for catalytic functions, and are widespread in biology. Take methanogens, for example, those microbes that produce methane under anaerobic conditions, thus contributing to global warming. Although the precise mechanism continues to intrigue chemists, at least one step involves breaking a methyl–sulfur bond. A reverse reaction, catalyzed by nickel, is now also attracting attention. Another example is the microorganisms that also use metalloenzymes with iron–sulfide sites to convert CO2 to CO or N2 to NH3. Check out the article to find out other sulfur roles.

Even its spelling is a little controversial, with both ‘sulfur’ and ‘sulphur’ widespread in the literature — have a look at our editorial (free but you have to be (freely) registered on nature.com) to find out why we’ve adopted ‘sulfur’ (and nope, this time it’s not simply the Oxford English vs American English spelling, the arguments are more etymologic).

Anne

Anne Pichon (Associate Editor, Nature Chemistry)

Reactions – Guru Row

Guru Row is in Solid State and Structural Chemistry Unit at Indian Institute of Science, Bangalore, India and works on aspects related to chemical crystallography and materials design which include topics like charge density analysis in molecular crystals, in situ cryo-crystallography, polymorphism and co-crystals in pharmaceuticals.

1. What made you want to be a chemist?

Well it is an interesting story. I started as a physicist, did my masters in solid state physics and appeared for interview in the physics department at the Indian Institute of Science. I was elected to work with Professor K. Venkatesan (who worked with Professor Dorothy Hodgkins as a post-doctoral fellow and was involved in the structure determination of Vitamin B12), who has just moved from University of Madras and had joined the department of organic chemistry as a crystallographer. So, I ended up getting my PhD degree in organic chemistry and then on became a chemist!

2. If you weren’t a chemist and could do any other job, what would it be – and why?

I would have been a student of physics and maybe I would have ended up as a macromolecular crystallographer rather than a chemical crystallographer.

3. What are you working on now, and where do you hope it will lead?

Currently, I am working on the evaluation and importance of intermolecular interactions in molecular crystals by charge density analysis. Professor Gautam Desiraju and myself with our students have developed a new methodology (SBFA) which allows for the transfer of charge densities of fragments called synthons from one molecule to the other. We believe that this work will have a major impact in understanding mechanistics of binding of drugs in macromolecules.

4. Which historical figure would you most like to have dinner with – and why?

Of course with Professor Albert Einstein, both of us are vegeterians.

5. When was the last time you did an experiment in the lab – and what was it?

This was a couple of weeks ago when one of my students had a difficulty in mounting a hygroscopic crystal in a Lindemann capillary. I will be regularly helping my students when they have difficulties in solving or refining crystal structures.

6. If exiled on a desert island, what one book and one music album would you take with you?

I always like to have and read and reread Alice in Wonderland, every time I read it, I come up with new thoughts. I am not a music fan, however I like to listen to old Hindi movie songs.

7. Which chemist would you like to see interviewed on Reactions – and why?

No one in particular, I believe every chemist would have interesting stories to tell as they work in the laboratory with chemicals and interesting students.

Reactions – John Spevacek

John Spevacek is at Aspen Research, and works on thiol-ene polymerization, mostly with UV initiation.

1. What made you want to be a chemist?

In grade school, I wanted to grow up and become a mad scientist, blowing up the lab everyday just for the devious fun of it. While I did become a chemist, I have scaled back on the rest of that dream somewhat (no explosions yet, just a few very small fires).

2. If you weren’t a chemist and could do any other job, what would it be – and why?

A professional bicycle racer. Not as a Tour de France rider, but a one-day-race rider, competing in Paris-Roubaix or Fleche Wallone. Anytime I ride my bike, I feel young.

3. What are you working on now, and where do you hope it will lead?

We are looking to incorporate more non-petroleum based chemicals and materials into our products. Petrochemicals will be around far longer than most of the doomsday predictions we hear, but they will become increasingly expensive. This will make it easier to economically justify alternatives, and if the economics aren’t there, large-scale production just won’t occur. I’m also excited that these new sources of materials (microbes, algae…) will give me access to monomers that are otherwise too difficult and expensive to produce from petroleum resources.

4. Which historical figure would you most like to have dinner with – and why?

Benjamin Franklin would be wonderful as he was involved in so many areas of science, government and diplomacy. Plus I could rib him about getting the direction for flow of electrons wrong, while Emil Fischer, a chemist, got the stereochemistry of sugars correct.

5. When was the last time you did an experiment in the lab – and what was it?

As my company doesn’t employ many technicians, I am constantly in the lab. Don’t considered that a complaint. Being in the lab is the other activity that makes me feel young. I am always trying different combinations of monomers and photoinitiators in order to change the properties of the final polymer. The latest effort is to use a bio-based material as a chemical feedstock, not just as a filler or a reinforcing agent. The challenge is that the material is not pure and has multiple reaction sites. Finding the appropriate reaction conditions is far more challenging than when you get your chemicals in labelled bottles.

6. If exiled on a desert island, what one book and one music album would you take with you?

Choosing the book would be difficult. There are so few that I would like to reread, and I wouldn’t want to take a chance on an unread book. The collected plays of Shakespeare would be a safe bet, and “The Tempest” would be the most appropriate, wouldn’t it?

As for the album, that’s a much easier choice: Rachmaninoff’s 2nd Piano Concerto, recorded by Jean-Ives Thibaudet, classical music that I didn’t know about until my wife introduced me to it.

7. Which chemist would you like to see interviewed on Reactions – and why?

Professor Robert Bryant of the University of Virginia. He taught my freshman chemistry class at the University of Minnesota in 1980-81, a class for which my high school had left me woefully underprepared. With his help, I survived quite well and have had an enjoyable career, so I’m curious as to what his answers would be.

Reactions – Loh Kian Ping

Loh Kian Ping is at the Department of Chemistry, National University of Singapore, and works on the synthesis and modification of functional carbon materials for advanced technological applications.

1. What made you want to be a chemist?

First of all, the study of chemistry as a subject interests me because it is immediately relevant in many ways. There seems to be a set of intuitively easy to understand rules behind the game that chemists play. Chemists explain how the universe operates in a language that is appealing to the pragmatic mind. I believe if the human civilization is destroyed by some natural disasters and need to be rebuilt, the chemists will be the most needed group of people to put the basic infrastructure of human civilization back to place, which is why the first scientist or magician on earth is the alchemist.

I am also inspired by the positive image of the creator in the chemist. A chemist is basically a creator, a cook, an artist and a crafsman combined into one. He can create new molecules from simple building blocks, and some of these molecules can reduce pain and save life, others can be transformed into useful things like plastics and clothings.

2. If you weren’t a chemist and could do any other job, what would it be – and why?

I would be a lawyer. I think I can be persuasive, since the same set of presentation skills and indirect thinking is needed. As a lawyer I probably would make more money than I make now, too.

3. What are you working on now, and where do you hope it will lead?

I am working on how to create geometrically well-defined nanostructures on an atomically-thin sheet of carbon. An atomically-thin sheet of carbon, called graphene, is a two-dimensional material. My team is working on how to create nanoscale periodic corrugations on this material. This has implication for changing the energy gap of graphene as well as increasing its surface area when used as a charge collection platform.

4. Which historical figure would you most like to have dinner with – and why?

I like to have dinner with Dmitri Mendeleev who wrote the volume “Principles of Chemistry” and who was credited with the discovery of periodic table. I am curious what is the thinking process going on in his mind that led him to the discovery, given the very limited information available at that time.

5. When was the last time you did an experiment in the lab – and what was it?

I have to confess that now I am a laptop or PC chemist, directing the reactions from a computer. The last time I did an experiment in the laboratory was one year ago when I helped my postdoctoral fellow fix up a furnace needed for the chemical vapor deposition of graphene.

6. If exiled on a desert island, what one book and one music album would you take with you?

I would take with me my diary to write my thoughts down and to record what I have for dinner on that deserted island – like grilled gecko or crab carpacio. For the music album, that would be my favourite oldies like the Carpenters.

7. Which chemist would you like to see interviewed on Reactions – and why?

I would recommend Professor Klaus Mullen, for his wonderful work on the bottom-up synthesis of graphene from designer molecules. This is a good example of the ingenuity of the chemists because they can make almost anything and everything using bottom-up strategy.

Reactions – Ed Constable

Edwin (Ed) Constable works in the Department of Chemistry at the University of Basel, and works on applied coordination and supramolecular chemistry.

1. What made you want to be a chemist?

Honestly, it was the gift of a chemistry set when I was 14. Although I had inspirational teachers, chemistry had never clicked with me until I could play with chemicals on my own. Almost certainly not an aproved strategy today! I went from the bottom of the class to the top in the space of one term. Before that, I wanted to be a writer or a historian.

2. If you weren’t a chemist and could do any other job, what would it be – and why?

Probably a wildlife photographer or science journalist. I have always felt that communication of what we are doing, why we are doing it and why it is important is an essential and often underrated part of our job. And wildlife photography? Because it is fun.

3. What are you working on now, and where do you hope it will lead?

Our primary work at present concentrates upon the major problem facing mankind in the upcoming hundred years – namely the development of sustainable and environmentally acceptable energy policies. We have large programmes in the development of photovoltaic cells, specifically dye sensitzed solar cells and OLED and light emitting electrochemical cells for efficient next generation lighting. Our aim is to replace scarce and expensive elements such as ruthenium and iridium by earth-abundant first row transition metals.

4. Which historical figure would you most like to have dinner with – and why?

Another good question. I thought long and hard about this and finally decided on Paracelsus (Philippus Aureolus Theophrastus Bombastus von Hohenheim). Not only was he a predecessor of mine at the University of Basel, but he was active at the cusp between alchemy, magic and science. He is arguably one of the first medicinal chemists and I would like to know what drove him. He was also apparently a very difficult person, so it would be an interesting dinner.

5. When was the last time you did an experiment in the lab – and what was it?

A very quick and dirty preparation of [Ru(dmso)4Cl2] about six months ago. Simply heating RuCl3.3H2O in dmso and collecting the crystals!

6. If exiled on a desert island, what one book and one music album would you take with you?

Oh dear, I never was one for Desert Island Disks! The book would need to be one that I could read repeatedly and always find something new. Disregarding the Bible and Shakespeare which are always present on desert islands according to my sources, I would chose the complete works of “Saki” ( H.H. Munro). He is a wickedly funny and often cruel writer of short stories from the Edwardian period who was one of the many talents lost in the global conflict 1914-1918. For music, it is much more difficult. Certainly nothing classical. I guess I am not allowed my iPod, so the choice ends up between Leonard Cohen, Dory Previn, Al Stewart, The Smiths and Pink Floyd. Very difficult to decide, but on balance it would be Pink Floyd “The Wall”.

7. Which chemist would you like to see interviewed on Reactions – and why?

Achim Mueller. I know Achim well and suspect that his answers would provide a unique insight to a unique mind!

Element of the month: Selenium stories

It was while making sulfuric acid that Jöns Jacob Berzelius — ‘the father of Swedish chemistry’ — noticed a red residue which he first took for tellurium, as Russell Boyd from Dalhousie University notes in this month’s ‘in your element’ article (subscription required). A more meticulous investigation, however, revealed that the residue displayed different properties, resembling those of sulfur. The new element fell into place between tellurium and sulfur in the chalcogen family of the periodic table, and Berzelius named it selenium (after the Greek word for Moon) owing to its similarity with tellurium (named after the Latin word for Earth).

Although often eclipsed by sulfur in textbooks, selenium has a reactivity of its own. I particularly like the fact that its grey allotrope, the most stable form, conducts electricity better in the light than in the dark, and converts electric current from AC to DC — properties which have not gone unnoticed in the fabrication of photovoltaic cells and rectifiers, respectively. Its red tint also went on to account for a worldwide application: selenium dioxide (which adopts a one-dimensional chain structure) imparts vibrant reds and pinks to glass.

It was only much, much later (140 years after its discovery) that the role of selenium in biological systems was identified. It replaces sulfur in some proteins, which in recent years have been shown to help the prevention of cancer, by hindering radical attacks on cells or possibly also by slowing tumour growth. It is introduced in the body by ingestion — dietary recommendations however follow a fine line between too little and too much, both with potentially very serious consequences. While ingesting too little can lead to a weakened immune system or heart problems, selenium poisoning comes with unpleasant skin or breath odour side effects, can affect mental awareness, and can even be life-threatening at high doses. Around 55 micrograms per day sounds just right — I was very surprised to read that it is contained in a single dried Brazil nut!

Have a look at the article to find out more, but I wouldn’t recommend daily Brazil nut fests.

Anne

Anne Pichon (Associate Editor, Nature Chemistry)

Reactions – Panče Naumov

Panče Naumov is at the Department of Material and Life Science at Osaka University, Japan, holds a position from the external staff of Ss Cyril and Methodius University in Macedonia, works on solid-state chemistry and photochemistry, and is particularly interested in unstable and “exotic” molecular species.

1. What made you want to be a chemist?

More than anything else, it was pure and simple curiosity that initially led me to chemistry. As a nerdy kid, this raw drive to find out about things compelled me to spend countless hours in a makeshift lab that I created out of my family’s storehouse. And throughout my entire career, my curiosity has never really waned. It grew stronger during my school days, when I managed the school lab, and remains just as strong even to this day in my very own laboratory. One particular quote by E. Einstein has always resonated with me ― “Curiosity has its own reason for existing.” To that I would add, “…and it will never cease to exist.”

2. If you weren’t a chemist and could do any other job, what would it be – and why?

I would most likely be an astronomer. As broad as the fields of biology, chemistry, and physics are, we can only begin to explore one side of the spectrum of infinity. We examine organisms, cells, tissues, molecules, atoms, quarks, and even tinier “particles”. However, there is a whole other side that is equally exciting and technically challenging. If I were an astronomer, the possibilities to study planets, stars, galaxies, galaxy clusters, and certainly much more beyond that would quite literally be endless.

3. What are you working on now, and where do you hope it will lead?

Throughout history, the problems that our world has had to deal with have been numerous and varied. However, it has become increasingly clear that our society today is faced with these three major problems: security, the environment, and energy. In my research group, we are interested in the molecular mechanisms underlying the processes of conversion among the light, chemical, thermal, and mechanical energies in the solid state. By elucidating the details of these mechanisms, we hope to arrive at a deeper understanding of the structural factors that govern energy transformation and improve its efficacy in the future.

4. Which historical figure would you most like to have dinner with – and why?

Actually, I would love to break bread with two historical figures. Having both Alexander the Great and Nikola Tesla at the dinner table would make for an exciting and incredibly stimulating evening. At the mere age of 30, Alexander the Great succeeded in uniting most of the known world at that time with his visionary approach. The wisdom that he displayed beyond his years and beyond his time has made our Macedonian nation very proud. In my view, Alexander the Great’s strategy of “conquer and unite” instead of “divide and conquer” was really a progressive concept not unlike the ones seen in contemporary unions such as the United States and the European Union. Perhaps along with Thomas Edison, Nikola Tesla should have been awarded the Nobel Prize. If in 1893 Tesla could demonstrate a wireless energy transfer, there is no doubt in my mind that he would be able to make a profound contribution to our society’s endeavors today and even to our future undertakings, such as teleportation. He could change the world as we know it. I’d love to ask him how.

5. When was the last time you did an experiment in the lab – and what was it?

A couple of months ago, I was trying to crystallize an important antiviral compound. Unfortunately, being a group leader has prevented me from dedicating the time necessary to be directly involved in experiments of late.

6. If exiled on a desert island, what one book and one music album would you take with you?

I would undoubtedly take “The Little Prince,” a book that amazes me with its simplicity of narration. I love it now, but I haven’t always held it in such high esteem. When I was 7, I hated it. At 14, I still considered it a very ho-hum read. Then, at 21, something clicked and it became my favorite book. Eventually, at 28, I made sure most of my friends had a copy. If you don’t already have one, I highly recommend it.

As far as music is concerned, I would need something to soothe the soul. The Best of Nina Simone would probably do the trick with her “blue” moments under the “blue” skies. But, how would I play it on a deserted island? I guess the album could double as a fan or placemat!

7. Which chemist would you like to see interviewed on Reactions – and why?

Bart E. Kahr from New York University in New York would make an excellent choice for the innovative methods he uses in furthering our knowledge of solid state chemistry and supramolecular chemistry. I find his work enlightening and timeless.

Reactions – Wilhelm Huck

Wilhelm Huck is at the Institute for Molecules and Materials at the Radboud University Nijmegen in the Netherlands and works on picoliter droplets that can be used as artificial cells to study the influence that the crowded environment commonly found in living cells has on the ‘chemistry of life’.

1. What made you want to be a chemist?

I was fascinated by the way chemistry could present a molecular picture of how our body works. At the same time, I grew up next to one of the largest chemical sites in the Netherlands (DSM) and saw that this molecular picture can also be applied to the synthetic world around us.

2. If you weren’t a chemist and could do any other job, what would it be – and why?

Perhaps it would be fun to be a banker for a while. It can’t be that difficult, and if I turn out to be any good, I could go back to chemistry and wouldn’t have to write any grant proposals any more.

3. What are you working on now, and where do you hope it will lead?

I just started on a very new topic in my new lab at the Radboud University Nijmegen. I think that at a fundamental level, we don’t understand how a cell functions as a chemical reactor. We might have a complete ‘parts list’ and know where everything goes, but we don’t know much about how coupled chemical reactions behave in the crowded, stochastic environment in the interior of the cell. Using living cells is extremely fruitful, but will not allow us to retrieve kinetic and thermodynamic data because we can’t dilute or heat the cells. Therefore, I want to use picoliter droplets in microfluidic devices as artificial cells that can contain the machinery required to transcribe and translate DNA into RNA into proteins, and follow these processes with physical organic chemistry techniques.

4. Which historical figure would you most like to have dinner with – and why?

Fred Sanger. I would like to know how he conceived his strategies to tackle the daunting projects he worked on. In many cases, his chemistry is so deceivingly simple but works so amazingly well. He must be the most naturally gifted chemist ever.

5. When was the last time you did an experiment in the lab – and what was it?

I generally need someone to help me…. but we are currently building a new set-up to sort single cells in droplets and occasionally I help aligning the lasers…

6. If exiled on a desert island, what one book and one music album would you take with you?

Difficult question. Assuming I will be marooned for a long time, would I really like to read that one book over and over again? Perhaps it will give me time to finally read the Molecular Biology of the Cell. It is a gripping read!

As for the music: I can’t concentrate when listening to music. The background noise of the ocean will be fine.

7. Which chemist would you like to see interviewed on Reactions – and why?

Bartosz Grzybowski. He is working on some really clever chemistry, but most importantly, I would like to read what historical figure he would like to have dinner with.

Reactions – Karl Gademann

Karl Gademann is a professor of organic chemistry at the University of Basel. His research interests include the synthesis and biological properties of natural products.

1. What made you want to be a chemist?

There are two aspects: for one, I have always been fascinated by the power of chemical compounds, and of natural products in particular, to interfere with biological systems. For example the way how cats react to catnip in such an enthusiastic manner, all mediated by one small terpene! The other aspect that remains truly fascinating is the creative act of synthesis — of ‘making something new’ — that continues to captivate me.

2. If you weren’t a chemist and could do any other job, what would it be – and why?

I would have studied German literature. But my German teacher advised my to go for chemistry, as literature can be read as a pastime, whereas doing chemistry is more difficult.

3. What are you working on now, and where do you hope it will lead?

We are interested in natural products that induce neuritogenesis and hope to learn something about their mechanism of action and this fascinating biological phenomenon in a larger context.

4. Which historical figure would you most like to have dinner with – and why?

It would be interesting to have Mozart in my car, and listening and talking about the music of the last 200 years while driving fast on a German highway.

5. When was the last time you did an experiment in the lab – and what was it?

I studied the mechanism of action of nosocarboline, in particular whether it can inhibit heme polymerization, by an in vitro assay.

6. If exiled on a desert island, what one book and one music album would you take with you?

The bible and ‘highway to hell’ from AC/DC would be suited for being lost on a desert island.

7. Which chemist would you like to see interviewed on Reactions – and why?

It would be interesting to hear answers from prominent chemists that have left chemistry, such as Margaret Thatcher or Bernie Ecclestone.

Reactions – Shuli You

Shuli You is a Professor of Organic Chemistry in the State Key Laboratory of Organometallic Chemistry, Shanghai Institute of Organic Chemistry, Chinese Academy of Sciences, and works on methodology development, total synthesis, and medicinal chemistry.

1. What made you want to be a chemist?

I was good at chemistry in high school and then chose chemistry as major in university. Now I really enjoy being a chemist by developing new tools that allow the facile access to novel molecules with interests.

2. If you weren’t a chemist and could do any other job, what would it be – and why?

In reality, if I did not get the chance to study in the college, I would be a farmer now carrying on my parents’ job. However, if I can choose, I would like to be an editor for a scientific journal. In that way, I want to try my best to make sure that every submission is fairly treated.

3. What are you working on now, and where do you hope it will lead?

We are working on the new methodology development based on C–H bond direct functionalization and asymmetric dearomatization. I hope that eventually our methodologies can be used by every chemist to produce the molecules they are interested in.

4. Which historical figure would you most like to have dinner with – and why?

Fredrick G. Banting, who won the 1923 Nobel Prize for his discovery of insulin. I was so intrigued by the story on the discovery of insulin, and I have so many questions to ask.

5. When was the last time you did an experiment in the lab – and what was it?

This reminds that I have not done lab work for quite a while. Last time I did something on asymmetric Friedel-Crafts reaction was about one year ago. Now I really miss the very beginning of my independent career during when I had a lot of time to do experiments.

6. If exiled on a desert island, what one book and one music album would you take with you?

It is definitely not a book on chemistry. It is a hard choice, and I probably will take “The Da Vinci Code” by Dan Brown and then a music collection of late pop singer Teresa Teng.

7. Which chemist would you like to see interviewed on Reactions – and why?

Professor Lixin Dai from our department. Professor Dai is a noble man, great chemist, and a person with unique character.