US oceans and atmosphere agency releases scientific integrity policy

noaa_logo_small.pngIt has been a long time in the making, but the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) finally released its scientific integrity policy, which prohibits agency employees from distorting science and protects the rights of NOAA scientists to speak openly about their work and to report wrongdoing. The policy applies to thousands of NOAA employees who conduct research on climate, ocean oil spills, marine mammals, and other sometimes controversial topics.

Jane Lubchenco, who directs the agency, announced the policy on 7 Dec. at a meeting of the American Geophysical Union in San Francisco. She said the policy is designed to “protect scientific findings from being suppressed, distorted or altered, to strengthen science and to encourage a culture of transparency.”

When President Barack Obama took office in January 2009, he vowed to “restore science to its rightful place” and his administration moved to quickly develop scientific integrity policies for each agency, but the process stalled and the administration has published final policies for just a few agencies.

NOAA’s new policy gets high marks from Francesca Grifo, director of the scientific integrity program at the Union of Concerned Scientists, which has reviewed the draft policies issued by federal agencies. NOAA’s is “the best that I’ve seen,” says Grifo. One highlight is that NOAA has committed to publically release statistics regarding the number of allegations and investigations on scientific integrity issues, something that will allow watchdog groups to track how such problems are being handled.

She still has some concerns about the protections in place for NOAA employees, especially whistelblowers. Although the new NOAA policy prohibits managers or others from punishing whistleblowers, the policy on its own will not offer true protection because court cases have weakened federal protections for whistleblowers, she says. It will ultimately require broader action by Congress and the administration to get stronger protections in place, says Grifo.

The Dead (and departed) Sea

DeadSea-Bohranlage_01-300.jpgSediments pulled up from a drilling project in the Dead Sea suggest that the salty lake completely disappeared about 120,000 years ago, a finding that violates assumptions long held by scientists. The results, reported at a meeting of the American Geophysical Union in San Francisco on 5 December, raise questions about how the warming climate will affect the endangered sea, where water levels have been dropping rapidly in the past few decades.

The US $2.6 million international Dead Sea Deep Drilling Project bored a series of holes into the lake from November 2010 to March 2011 to study the climate and earthquake history in the region. Last month, the team finished opening up the sediment cores and discovered a layer of rounded pebbles 230 meters below the surface of the seafloor. The pebble layer represents an ancient beach that filled the lowest level of the basin as the lake was drying up completely or nearly so, the researchers propose. “There’s nothing else like it in the core,” says Steven Goldstein, a researcher at the Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory in New York and a leader of the project. The Dead Sea work was funded by the International Continental Scientific Drilling Program and by Israel, Germany, Japan, Norway, Switzerland and the United States.

Experiments in the past using water from the Dead Sea had suggested that the lake could not disappear totally because the loss of water would concentrate salt within the lake, inhibiting further evaporation. But the new findings call that assumption into question. Climate forecasts suggest that the region will grow warmer and drier in the future, says Emi Ito, a lake researcher at the University of Minnesota and a principal investigator on the drilling project.

The lake level has been dropping precipitously recently because Israel and Jordan divert water that previously flowed into the Dead Sea. In the past 14 years, the lake surface has lowered by 14 metres and now stands at 425 metres below sea level. Israel and Jordan are considering a controversial proposal to refill the lake by constructing a canal from the Red Sea into the Dead Sea.

photo: Dead Sea Drilling Barge (credit: OSGGFZ, ICDP)

Cool climate paper sinks journal editor

remotesensing-logo260.jpg

The editor of the journal Remote Sensing resigned today, saying in an editorial that his journal never should have published a controversial paper in July that challenged the reliability of climate models used to forecast global warming. The paper, by Roy Spencer and William Braswell of the University of Alabama in Huntsville, proposed that climate researchers have likely made a fundamental error by overestimating the sensitivity of the climate to greenhouse-gas pollution.

The climate-research blog Real Climate and other mainstream researchers complained that the paper was itself fundamentally flawed, but the Remote Sensing article garnered support from climate skeptics and significant press attention, thanks in part to an overly hyped press release. The editor of Remote Sensing, Wolfgang Wagner of the Vienna University of Technology, said he now views the paper as “fundamentally flawed and therefore wrongly accepted by the journal. This regrettably brought me to the decision to resign as Editor-in-Chief—to make clear that the journal Remote Sensing takes the review process seriously.”

Continue reading

Earthquake shakes eastern United States

dc evac.jpgVibrations from a major earthquake in rural Virginia rattled residents across much of the Eastern United States today, prompting evacuations of many buildings in Washington DC, New York and Boston. Ivan Semeniuk, from Nature’s Washington DC bureau, snapped this image of evacuees on Pennsylvania Avenue, within sight of the Capitol building.

The US Geological Survey pegged the quake size at a magnitude 5.9, which would make this shock one of the biggest in Virginia’s recorded history. A quake of about the same size occurred in the state in 1897. Today’s quake struck at 1:51 (EDT) and reverberated up the east coast, momentarily interrupting a busy working day in some of the most densely populated cities in North America.

Major earthquakes in the eastern United States are rare because the crust is old and mostly stable. But when quakes do occur, the strong crustal rock transmits the seismic waves with relatively little loss of energy, so they can race across vast distances. Initial reports suggested the vibrations were felt at least as far as New Hampshire, some 500 miles away.

Continue reading

Greenland reveals its warm secrets

<img alt=“Bedrockb260.jpg” src=“https://blogs.nature.com/news/thegreatbeyond/Bedrockb260.jpg” width=“260” height=“198” align=right />

New results from a drilling project in Greenland suggest that the ice sheet there may be more stable—and Antarctica’s may be less stable—than previously thought. The findings, which come from the North Greenland Eemian Ice Drilling (NEEM) project, were presented on Thursday at a symposium on Antarctic science at the University of Wisconsin in Madison.

Researchers concerned about the potential for catastrophic sea level rise have long worried that global warming might melt parts of the West Antarctica Ice Sheet and the Greenland Ice Sheet. Substantial loss from either could raise sea levels by several meters, inundating parts of New York, London, and many other of the world’s major cities.

One way to assess the stability of the ice sheets is to look at how they fared during the Eemian period, the warm spell from 130,000 to 115,000 years ago that came just before the last ice age. During the Eemian, temperatures in Greenland were as much as 5 degrees C higher than recent values, a temperature hike on par with what that area might experience by 2100 if greenhouse-gas concentrations continue to rise. So researchers have been chasing Eemian ice for decades by drilling holes through the thick Greenland ice cap. But those earlier efforts have all come up empty. The Eemian ice had either been melted or mangled by the slow movement of the ice sheets.

Continue reading

Evidence of puddles on Mars

Posted on behalf of Adam Mann

flowonmars.jpg

Scientists no longer debate whether water exists on Mars. There is water ice at the planet’s poles and abundant evidence of frost and subsurface ice in other spots. What’s not settled is whether water currently flows openly on the surface at times, creating gullies in craters and dunes. Most of the time, Mars’ surface stays below the freezing point of water and its atmosphere is so thin and dry that any open water should quickly evaporate.

On 10 March, a couple of scientists presented new evidence of liquid water on the Martian surface. The findings were reported at the Lunar and Planetary Science Conference in The Woodlands, Texas.

In one presentation, Nilton Renno, an atmospheric scientist at the University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, showed spectral evidence for briny water existing as “puddles” up to 25 metres across. Mars’ rusty soil is very bright in the near-infrared whereas salt water deposits would absorb this wavelength and reflect in the blue-green portion of the spectrum. Using images taken from Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter (MRO), Renno analyzed spots of dark soil near the planet’s polar region and found that they looked the same as brine.

Continue reading

Are antibiotics making our kids fat?

posted on behalf of Nicola Jones

obeseman.gif

Farmers have long known that feeding low levels of antibiotics to their animals helps to beef up their beef. The drugs aren’t used just to keep diseases at bay – they also kill off normal gut bacteria that help to metabolize fats, leading to bigger pigs and cows.

This makes microbiologist Martin Blaser of New York University wonder if the same thing might be happening to people. Could overuse of antibiotics be one cause of the obesity epidemic in the United States? “I think this is what we’re doing to our kids,” he says.

“The average child in the United States gets 15 courses of antibiotics in the first 15 years of life,” he told the International Human Microbiome Congress in Vancouver, Canada, on 10 March. “That’s the average. And it’s all on the assumption that there are no long-term effects.”

Blaser is using mouse models to test his theory. So far he has reproduced the farming effect; low-levels of antibiotics (lower than would be used to treat disease) can boost mouse fat by 40%. When combined with a high fat diet, he says, he can get boosts of up to 300%. The group now aims to test antibiotic regimes more relevant to humans — pulses of higher doses, rather than chronic, low levels.

Obesity is a growing problem in the United States and elsewhere. Though sugary drinks, junk food, and lack of exercise are surely partly to blame, Blaser says gut microbes (or a lack of them) might play a big role too. Dusko Ehrlich, co-ordinator of the Metagenomics of the Human Intestinal Tract (MetaHIT) project in Europe, says that idea seems to fit with what his group is finding about obesity. MetaHIT has found that a class of obese people with 30% fewer gut microbes tends to put on more weight over time. “We couldn’t believe it,” he says of the radically depleted microbe numbers. What’s causing the microbial depletion? They don’t know. But antibiotic use, says Ehrlich, is a definite possibility.

image: USDA

Hot dates for scars on Mars

Posted on behalf of Adam Mann

newcrater.jpg

When researchers want to know how old a particular lava flow is on Mars, they count the number of craters that pockmark the feature. Older surfaces have more craters than fresh ones. But this technique only allows scientists to estimate the relative age of one part of Mars to another.

New data may now help researchers create a crater clock that can help them pin down the absolute ages of features. Ingrid Daubar of the University of Arizona in Tucson and her colleagues are doing this by measuring how quickly craters are appearing on Mars today. By comparing images of the Martian surface taken at different times, the researchers found 201 craters that were created in the last ten years. She presented the group’s latest results at the Lunar and Planetary Science Conference in The Woodlands, Texas, on 8 March.

The team estimates that impacts create approximately 94 new craters each year that are at least several metres in size. The information is an important step in “allowing us to extrapolate this back in time and get dates that mean something on Martian surfaces,” says Jay Melosh, a geophysicist from Purdue University in West Lafayette, Indiana, who was not associated with the work.

The team has used similar techniques to come up with cratering rates for the Moon, which appears to accumulate at least 800 metre-sized impacts per year. Daubar stresses, though, that this number is based on only a handful of observations. Still, knowing the relative rate of crater formation on the Moon and Mars is significant, she says.

Image of craters on Mars: HiRISE/NASA

Oil spill commission calls for stronger science role

oil spill burning.jpg

In its final report, which was released today, the presidential commission investigating the Gulf Oil Spill called for scientists to play a more important role in the federal government’s decisions about where to allow offshore oil production and also in how the government responds to spills. At a press conference in Washington, DC, Bob Graham, a co-chair of the commission said “Science has not been given a sufficient seat at the table. Actually, I think that’s a considerable understatement. It has been virtually shut out.”

The commission asked Congress to supply more funding for scientific and environmental studies and to involve science agencies more formally in decisions about which areas should be opened to exploration. Specifically, the commission urged Congress to change the Outer Continental Shelf Lands Act to give the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration a formal role in assessing plans to lease offshore areas. The commission criticized the March decision by the Obama administration to expand areas available for exploration without consulting NOAA.

The commission also called for:

*More money for research in how to respond to oil spills.

*More research on dispersants, including their long-term effects on the environment.

*Faster access to oil spill sites by scientists so they can start independent studies.

*Plans by the Environmental Protection Agency to address human health impacts from large spills.

*Restoration efforts that are well funded and based on scientific research.

Relating to that last point, the commission requested that 80 percent of the penalties collected for violating the Clean Water Act should go to restoration efforts in the Gulf of Mexico

Looking ahead, the commission warned about exploration efforts off the coast of Alaska, particularly in the Chukchi and Beaufort Seas. These areas are biologically rich but there is relatively little scientific information about most of the species living there. And a spill in those regions would stretch the resources of the Coast Guard, which currently only has one operational ice breaker—a gap that has hampered scientific studies in the Arctic and Antarctic. The commission advised Congress to provide the Coast Guard with more resources and urged the government to carry out a comprehensive research program on oil spills in the Arctic.

Image: U.S. Coast Guard

A Rising Star

kwok small.jpg

Nothing is quite as surreal in science as watching America’s top geophysicists boogie to a cover of Journey’s “Don’t Stop Believing.” But Nature jumped down the rabbit hole last night and joined the fun at the American Geophysical Union’s awards banquet, where journalist Roberta Kwok was honored for her feature story “The Rock that Fell to Earth,” which ran in Nature last year.

Kwok’s article told the tale of researchers who tracked an asteroid from the moment it was first spotted in space to the time, months later, when scientists found fragments of the extraterrestrial body strewn across the Nubian desert in Sudan. The article won the geophysical union’s Walter Sullivan journalism award for feature writing.

This week, Meteoritics and Planetary Science published a series of new papers describing the discovery and analysis of the asteroid, known as 2008 TC3.

When she wrote the piece, Kwok was an intern in Nature’s Washington, DC, office. She is now a freelance writer in the Bay area and has written several other articles for Nature, including a profile of synthetic biologists Ham Smith and Clyde Hutchison. It is unusual for an intern to win a major writing award, and Kwok’s achievement is a testament to her skills as both a reporter and a writer.

The AGU also honored Pallava Bagla of Science for his news article last year that examined inaccuracies in a report by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Both stories are well worth reading and Nature salutes the two writers for their achievements.

Photo of Roberta Kwok and Peter Jenniskens, of the SETI Institute, who discovered the fragments of 2008TC3 in the desert. In front of them is a piece of the meteorite.

Image courtesy of Roberta Kwok