AAAS: Star Trek Fans Rejoice!

Rocky planets resembling Venus, Mars and the Earth may be as common in our galaxy as any Star Trek fan could hope, according to University of Arizona astronomer Michael Meyer, who announced a new finding from NASA’s Spitzer space telescope at a AAAS press conference today on planetary discovery.

The new Spitzer data, from a survey of 309 very young, sun-like stars in our immediate galactic neighborhood, suggest that rocky planets form around 20% to 60% of them, said Meyer—a very large fraction. True, he said, the evidence is indirect. Instead of seeing actual planets, Spitzer detected the infrared warmth of fine dust grains that orbit the stars at Earth-like distances. But astronomers believe that such dust grains are the byproduct of constant collisions among larger, asteroid-sized chunks—the ongoing process of cosmic bump-‘em cars by which the chunks coalesce into full-scale planets. And soon, Meyer added, we should have even better evidence from NASA’s Kepler mission. Due for launch in February 2009, Kepler will be the first observatory able to detect Earth-sized (and smaller) extrasolar planets directly.

Meanwhile, as NASA science chief Alan Stern described in the same press conference, NASA is already planning for an even more capable planet-finding mission to be launched in about 2015. This mission is mired in controversy at the moment, because the US Congress recently gave NASA a mandate to pursue one specific technical approach, known as the Space Interferometry Mission (SIM) (See Nature, 15 January 2008) But Stern insisted that that issue is far from settled. The final design of the new mission should and will be made in close collaboration with the scientific community, he said—probably in the 2010 time frame, after the astronomers have had a chance to analyze the early results from Kepler.

AAAS: Star Trek Fans Rejoice!

Rocky planets resembling Venus, Mars and the Earth may be as common in our galaxy as any Star Trek fan could hope, according to University of Arizona astronomer Michael Meyer, who announced a new finding from NASA’s Spitzer space telescope at a AAAS press conference today on planetary discovery.

The new Spitzer data, from a survey of 309 very young, sun-like stars in our immediate galactic neighborhood, suggest that rocky planets form around 20% to 60% of them, said Meyer—a very large fraction. True, he said, the evidence is indirect. Instead of seeing actual planets, Spitzer detected the infrared warmth of fine dust grains that orbit the stars at Earth-like distances. But astronomers believe that such dust grains are the byproduct of constant collisions among larger, asteroid-sized chunks—the ongoing process of cosmic bump-‘em cars by which the chunks coalesce into full-scale planets. And soon, Meyer added, we should have even better evidence from NASA’s Kepler mission. Due for launch in February 2009, Kepler will be the first observatory able to detect Earth-sized (and smaller) extrasolar planets directly.

Meanwhile, as NASA science chief Alan Stern described in the same press conference, NASA is already planning for an even more capable planet-finding mission to be launched in about 2015. This mission is mired in controversy at the moment, because the US Congress recently gave NASA a mandate to pursue one specific technical approach, known as the Space Interferometry Mission (SIM) (See Nature, 15 January 2008) But Stern insisted that that issue is far from settled. The final design of the new mission should and will be made in close collaboration with the scientific community, he said—probably in the 2010 time frame, after the astronomers have had a chance to analyze the early results from Kepler.

AAAS: Why the Road not Taken Might Not Matter

Harvard’s Dan Gilbert discussed a very new finding in the Memory and Imagination pres conference Saturday: The roads not taken don’t actually haunt us.

Gilbert is one of a number of neuro- and cognitive scientists studying the interplay of memory (of past events) and imagination (of future possibilities). It’s recently been discovered that these two processes use virtually the same brain circuits, as discussed at the press conference by Daniel Schacter of Harvard and Eleanor Maguire of University College, London. But Gilbert has been looking at the interplay from a slightly different angle. One of the things memory is for, he says, is to help us pick good futures and avoid the bad ones. Yet we’re remarkably poor at doing that. You think that winning the lottery will make you really, really happy for a really long time—and then it doesn’t. You think that going blind will make you really miserable—and then when that happens, you adapt and get on with life.

What Gilbert has found is a new mechanism for why our imaginations fail us this way: the alternatives to an event have a profound effect on how much you think you will enjoy it—but almost no effect on how much you actually do. In one experiment, for example, half the subjects were offered a potato chip while they were sitting in a room full of chocolate. Faced with a more desirable alternative, they said they felt so-so about eating the potato chip. But the other half of the subjects were offered the potato chip while surrounded with canned haggis and sardines. Not so attractive. They said the chip would taste great. But in both cases, once the chip was in their mouths—salty, greasy and crunchy—the alternatives faded away, and both groups said they enjoyed the potato chips equally. The sensory reality overwhelmed the imaginary one.

AAAS: Why the Road not Taken Might Not Matter

Harvard’s Dan Gilbert discussed a very new finding in the Memory and Imagination pres conference Saturday: The roads not taken don’t actually haunt us.

Gilbert is one of a number of neuro- and cognitive scientists studying the interplay of memory (of past events) and imagination (of future possibilities). It’s recently been discovered that these two processes use virtually the same brain circuits, as discussed at the press conference by Daniel Schacter of Harvard and Eleanor Maguire of University College, London. But Gilbert has been looking at the interplay from a slightly different angle. One of the things memory is for, he says, is to help us pick good futures and avoid the bad ones. Yet we’re remarkably poor at doing that. You think that winning the lottery will make you really, really happy for a really long time—and then it doesn’t. You think that going blind will make you really miserable—and then when that happens, you adapt and get on with life.

What Gilbert has found is a new mechanism for why our imaginations fail us this way: the alternatives to an event have a profound effect on how much you think you will enjoy it—but almost no effect on how much you actually do. In one experiment, for example, half the subjects were offered a potato chip while they were sitting in a room full of chocolate. Faced with a more desirable alternative, they said they felt so-so about eating the potato chip. But the other half of the subjects were offered the potato chip while surrounded with canned haggis and sardines. Not so attractive. They said the chip would taste great. But in both cases, once the chip was in their mouths—salty, greasy and crunchy—the alternatives faded away, and both groups said they enjoyed the potato chips equally. The sensory reality overwhelmed the imaginary one.