Western Australian agency lets sharks off the hook

Western Australia’s Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has halted the controversial culling of sharks off Western Australia, citing “too much uncertainty” about the impact on marine fauna.

Following a series of fatal attacks on swimmers and surfers, state authorities said last year that shark populations off affected beaches and coastlines would be deliberately reduced. The plan caused an outcry among ecologists and marine conservationists. Scientists were particularly concerned about Western Australia’s vulnerable population of great white shark (Carcharodon carcharias).

The Western Australian Shark Hazard Mitigation Drum Line Program was a plan to aggressively hunt sharks from 2014 until at least 2017. Earlier this year, 170 sharks — none of them white sharks, according to reports — were caught and killed by means of baited hooks attached to floats.

But following an expert examination, the EPA has now concluded that the programme should be discontinued.

“After careful deliberation, the EPA has concluded that there is a high degree of scientific uncertainty as to whether the proposal can meet our objective for Marine Fauna,” the agency says in a statement released on 11 September.

“At this stage, the available information and evidence does not provide the EPA with a high level of confidence. In view of these uncertainties, the EPA has adopted a cautious approach by recommending against the proposal.”

The government of Western Australia has two weeks to appeal the decision. The state’s premier, Colin Barnett, said to reporters that an appeal was unlikely.

 

Ozone recovery helped by warming climate

Posted on behalf of Mark Zastrow.

The ozone layer appears to be continuing on the path to recovery, an international panel of 300 scientists reports today. Atmospheric levels of the chemicals that destroy ozone have now declined by 10–15% since peaking in 2000, a sign of improving health.

The current ozone hole over Antarctica is shown here in blue.

The current ozone hole over Antarctica is shown here in blue.{credit}NASA{/credit}

A report released by a team from the United Nations Environmental Programme (UNEP) and the World Meteorological Organization documents a clear trend of ozone increasing in the upper stratosphere, approximately 42 kilometres high, at a rate of over 3% per decade. The data also suggest that the total amount of ozone in the atmosphere is growing, but they are not yet conclusive.

Models estimate that levels of ozone-depleting chemicals will fall to their 1980 levels by 2030, and the total amount of ozone will rebound soon after, preventing an estimated 2 million cases of skin cancer.

Ozone-destroying industrial chemicals known as chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs), once widespread in air conditioners and aerosol cans, cause the annual ‘hole’ in the ozone layer that forms every year in the Southern Hemisphere’s spring. CFCs were banned worldwide by the Montreal Protocol in 1987, which was ratified by all UN member nations.

However, like CFCs, the chemicals that replaced them — hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs) — are potent greenhouse gases. The report recommends switching to alternatives with less greenhouse potential, such as hydrofluoro-olefins.

In fact, ozone levels are linked tightly to climate. The report finds that half of the ozone recovery is due to greenhouse gases’ changing the temperature structure of the atmosphere. By trapping heat in the troposphere, the gases let less heat escape to the stratosphere — and cooler temperatures enable ozone production, explains Steve Montzka, an atmospheric scientist at the US National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration in Boulder, Colorado.

“I think the great message is that if we act now in understanding the connection between ozone and climate action we can avoid a major problem,” said Achim Steiner, UNEP’s executive director.

Team members hope that the success of the Montreal Protocol will encourage similar action on the reduction of greenhouse gases. “There is tremendous scope for achieving further changes,” Steiner said.

Rise in greenhouse-gas concentrations continues at alarming rate

brwlarge

A US atmospheric observatory in Barrow, Alaska, is part of a global network that monitors carbon-dioxide concentrations.
Credit: NOAA

The carbon dioxide concentration in the atmosphere increased in 2013 at the fastest rate in almost 30 years, spurring concerns about global warming ahead of a United Nations climate summit later this month.

According to the annual Greenhouse Gas Bulletin of the World Meteorological Organization (WMO), released on 9 September, the average amount of CO2 in the atmosphere reached 396.0 parts per million in 2013 — 2.9 parts per million above the 2012 level. This is the largest annual increase since 1984. Averaged over an entire year, the global annual CO2 concentration is now expected to pass the symbolic threshold of 400 parts per million in 2015 or 2016.

The report is based on observations from the WMO’s Global Atmosphere Watch network. Preliminary data suggest that reduced CO2 uptake by plants and soils might add to the worrying increase in atmospheric CO2 concentrations resulting from fossil fuel burning.

Atmospheric methane, the second most important long-lived greenhouse gas, also reached a new high of about 1,824 parts per billion last year, mostly due to increased emissions from cattle breeding, rice farming, fossil fuel mining, landfills and biomass burning.

Between 1990 and 2013, radiative forcing by long-lived greenhouse gases — the main cause of global warming — has increased by 34%, according to the WMO report.

The question remains, however, of why the rise in global mean temperatures near the surface has apparently slowed, after a series of exceptionally warm years in the 1990s. Scientists have suggested a number of possible explanations for the global warming pause. According to the latest hypothesis, regularly occurring changes in circulation patterns in the Atlantic and Southern Ocean may have caused an increased volume of relatively warm water to sink to the depth of the ocean, thus reducing the amount of ocean heat escaping to the atmosphere.

The world’s oceans take up one-fourth or so of CO2 emitted into the atmosphere. As emissions have been steadily rising for decades, the corresponding changes in ocean chemistry are dramatic: the current rate of ocean acidification seems to have been unprecedented in at least over the last 300 million years, according to an analysis included in the WMO report.

World leaders are set to discuss steps to reduce greenhouse gas emission at the United Nations climate summit on 23 September in New York.

Philanthropists aid Keeling curve

The iconic ‘Keeling curve’, a 56-year record of rising atmospheric carbon dioxide levels, will continue with support from American philanthropists Eric and Wendy Schmidt. A five-year, US$500,000 grant, announced on 3 September, will help ease funding pressure on the greenhouse-gas monitoring effort run by researchers at the Scripps Institution of Oceanography in La Jolla, California. 

The measurements were started at Mauna Loa, Hawaii, in 1958 by Charles Keeling. His son, Ralph, a geochemist at Scripps, now runs an expanded monitoring programme that tracks atmospheric CO2 and oxygen. In July 2013, when Keeling’s funding from US government agencies was in doubt, the scientist launched a ‘crowdfunding’ campaign to support his work.

That raised about $20,000, Keeling says, enough to keep programme staff on his payroll during lean months earlier this year. The new Schmidt grant will allow the Scripps team to chip away at a years-long backlog of air samples to measure changes in the ratio of carbon isotopes, which provides information about manmade sources of CO2. And Keeling’s pioneering oxygen-monitoring programme, which helps researchers to calculate how much CO2 is being absorbed by oceans and plants, has received roughly $400,000 from the US National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA).

“The [financial] need now is not the same as it was eight months ago,” Keeling says.

Keeling has documented a decrease in oxygen levels that is due to fossil-fuel combustion, which uses up oxygen and releases CO2. By accounting for both CO2 and oxygen levels in the atmosphere, scientists have calculated that oceans and plants each absorb roughly one-quarter of humanity’s CO2 emissions, leaving half to build up in the atmosphere.

While NOAA maintains its own atmospheric CO2 record, it does not track atmospheric oxygen, says Jim Butler, director of the agency’s Global Monitoring Division in Boulder, Colorado. “Ralph is one of the few people in the world who do this,” he says. “He has the longest ongoing record. We intend to continue funding this programme.”

 

Indian Ocean signal was not crash of flight MH370

Posted on behalf of Declan Butler.

nature-MH370map-050914.jpg

Hopes have faded that hydroacoustic signals picked up on the floor of the Indian Ocean might help to locate the Malaysian Airlines flight MH370 airliner that disappeared in March. Data from an additional sensor suggest that the signal probably resulted from geological activity and not the sound of an aircraft crashing into the ocean’s surface.

In June, Australian scientists had reported that sensitive microphones off the Australian coast had detected a distinctive signal at 01:30 coordinated universal time (UTC) on 8 March, around the time satellites lost contact with the Boeing 777 airliner.

The initially reported signals were discovered by an ocean acoustics group at Curtin University’s Centre for Marine Science and Technology in Perth, Australia. They were studying data from an acoustic station in Perth Canyon, about 40 kilometres west of Rottnest Island off the country’s west coast (see ‘Sound clue in hunt for MH370′).

That station is one of six belonging to Australia’s Integrated Marine Observing System (IMOS). The team then confirmed the signal using data from the Cape Leeuwin acoustic station, operated by the Comprehensive Nuclear-Test-Ban Treaty Organization (CTBTO) southwest of Australia. This gave a rough fix on the location of the origin of the sound as somewhere along a strip in the northwest of the Indian Ocean (see ‘Lost trail’).

On 3 September the researchers recovered data from another IMOS station at Scott Reef, off northwestern Australia. It contains a signal at 01:32:49 UTC that the researchers believe could correspond to the sound event they had detected earlier. Combining the data gave a fix on the location of the sound as the geologically active Carlsberg Ridge, midway between the Horn of Africa and India.

The sound signal also had a low amplitude tail, and taken together these two findings suggest that the event was geological — caused, for example, by an earthquake, underwater landslide or volcanic eruption, says Alec Duncan, a scientist in the Curtin University group.

Updated: Icelandic volcano erupts

Update, 23 August 23:27 BST: As of this evening, Icelandic experts are reconsidering whether an eruption has begun or not. With no surface changes visible, and no meltwater rushing downriver as of yet, the Icelandic Meteorological Office reports “there are no signs of ongoing volcanic activity”. The aviation alert remains red, “as an imminent eruption cannot be excluded”.

 A volcanic eruption has begun near the caldera of Bárðarbunga, the Icelandic Meteorological Office (IMO) announced on 23 August. Officials have raised the area’s aviation colour code to red, signifying that an “eruption is imminent or in progress”.

All is quiet on the surface above the Bárðarbunga caldera.

All is quiet on the surface above the Bárðarbunga caldera. {credit}Halldór Björnsson/Icelandic Meteorological Office{/credit}

The eruption is taking place beneath 150–400 metres of ice, north and east of the Bárðarbunga caldera. For the past week magma has been rising from the deep and forming a long underground sheet of freshly cooled rock, known as a dyke. The formation of the dyke has been marked by a series of intense earthquakes stretching from Bárðarbunga towards a glacier called Dyngjujökull (see ‘Icelandic volcano shakes ominously’).

Scientists from the IMO and the University of Iceland flew over the eruption today and reported no visible signs at the surface. The eruption was probably detected by seismic stations monitoring the region, as the shaking produced when water interacts with magma and turns to steam has a distinctive energy signature. Since the earthquake swarm began on 16 August, Icelandic scientists have been peppering the region with extra seismic and global-positioning instruments to capture just such an event.

Officials have also moved mobile radar observation stations into place around Bárðarbunga, to monitor any plumes if the volcano starts to emit ash. All airports in Iceland remain open, although airspace of approximately 140 by 100 nautical miles (260 by 185 kilometres) has been closed over the eruption site. If the eruption begins to produce ash, the volcanic ash advisory centre responsible for the region may issue an alert. Those alerts can be monitored here.

How the eruption proceeds will depend on how much magma is forcing its way upward and at what rate. The last eruption in Iceland happened in 2011 at the Grímsvötn volcano and was the most powerful in nearly a century. Like this new one, it took place under the Vatnajökull ice cap, and it broke through the ice to spew ash 20 kilometres high. So far, there is no indication that the new eruption will do anything like that, although the interaction of magma and ice is notoriously unpredictable.

volcano_status (3)

{credit}Icelandic Meteorological Office{/credit}

Oceans need saving before science is nailed

NOAA_Seahorse

{credit}Mohammed Al Momany/NOAA{/credit}

Don’t just gather data, do something. Scientists need to stop using a lack of knowledge as an excuse for not doing more to protect threatened species, a major gathering of marine conservationists has been warned.

“Science matters deeply, but we can’t let ourselves be trapped by the need to gather more data,” Amanda Vincent, a marine researcher at the University of British Columbia, told delegates at the opening of the International Marine Conservation Congress, which kicked off on 14 August in Glasgow, UK.

Vincent’s work with seahorses has involved fighting for better control of the international trade in these animals, many of which are endangered. Trade in seahorses is now restricted under the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species (CITES). If scientists had waited until they knew everything about every species – or even until they had enough data to propose detailed plans for managing catches in individual countries – this protection would never have arrived, she says.

Vincent told the meeting that every speaker who called for more data on a conservation issue should also be prepared to present a recommendation for something that could actually be done now.

Making an analogy with the medical profession, she told the meeting that doctors use all available evidence when deciding how to treat their patients, but when there is a lack of evidence for a particular condition they don’t generally stand by and do nothing. The oceans are under threat, says Vincent, and “you don’t do research while your patient is dying”.

She warned the gathering of conservation researchers that “we’re a bit weasely sometimes in hiding behind our lack of knowledge” and told them to “just get going”.

Follow the meeting on twitter via @dpcressey and #IMCC3

Ban all ivory sales for 10 years, says conservationist

The international community should ban all sales of ivory — including seized tusks and antique pieces that were created when trade was legal — for at least 10 years, argues a peer-reviewed essay published today in Conservation Biology. Without such measures, the epidemic corruption and high demand will ruin attempts to save African elephants, the author says.

The article comes from Elizabeth Bennett, who is vice president for species conservation at the Wildlife Conservation Society (WCS), a non-profit organization based in New York. The WCS has previously voiced opposition to some legal ivory markets, but Bennett told Nature, “This is not a fundamentalist stand that we believe ivory should never be sold”.

She added, “Under current conditions and lack of controls, closing all markets for at least 10 years and after that until poaching no longer threatens wild populations is the only way to get the situation under control and give a break to the elephants.”

Ivory seized in the United States and destroyed in 2013.
Kate Miyamoto / USFWS.

Conservationists have long complained that legal markets, which exist across the globe and can include sales of antique ivory pieces or new carvings of ivory sold legally from stockpiles, are used as a cover for ivory poached from Africa’s elephant herds. Concern has increased as poaching has recently surged in Africa. If a vendor is allowed to trade ivory, it can be difficult to determine whether a given product is actually from a legal source or has been poached and then integrated into the legal market.

But legal markets in other countries have also come under increased scrutiny lately, with New Jersey state banning all trade in elephant ivory and rhino horn this month.

Some countries, including the United States and China, periodically destroy stockpiles of seized ivory to avoid fuelling the growing demand. However some African states are known to be keen keeping limited legal sales, especially of the large amounts of illegal ivory they have seized. Supporters of such ‘one-off sales’ say they can reduce pressure on wild elephants by flooding the market.

In her article, Bennett says legal markets cannot be tolerated because of the level of corruption among government officials in charge of them. She points out that six out of the eight countries identified as the world’s leading offenders in global ivory trafficking are in the bottom half of league of corruption drawn up by Transparency International. And six of the 12 countries in Africa that have elephants populations are also in the half.

“If we are to conserve remaining wild populations, we must close all markets because, under current levels of corruption, they cannot be controlled in a way that does not provide opportunities for illegal ivory being laundered into legal markets,” she writes.

Science shut down at crippled UK Antarctic base

UPDATE – 12/8

The British Antarctic Survey has confirmed that the problem at the base was caused by a coolant leak in the heating systems, which prompted the generators to overheat and shut down.

“Scientific instruments that are used for atmospheric research remain switched off so that the electrical energy can be used to heat the living accommodation,” said BAS in the 12 August update. “Planned station engineering and research for the forthcoming season is being rescheduled.”


Original story

Science has ground to a halt at the UK’s Halley Research Station in Antarctica in the wake of a mysterious power failure.

The British Antarctic Survey (BAS), which runs the station, says that staff on the site are safe but are still attempting to determine the exact cause of “a serious operational incident” on 30 July that took down both electrical and heating systems.

The Halley Research Station just recorded a record low temperature

The Halley Research Station just recorded a record low temperature{credit}British Antarctic Survey{/credit}

Although some power and heating has been restored, “all science, apart from meteorological observations essential for weather forecasting, has been stopped”, says a BAS statement. Exactly what this will mean for ongoing research is unclear, but the BAS say it is likely that ozone monitoring, meteorology related to climate science and studies of the upper atmosphere used for forecasting space weather have all been disrupted.

As it is currently winter in Antarctica, the base was not fully operational, but still had 13 staff maintaining various functions through the seasonal darkness. Two staff members tweeted that during the power outage, the base recorded its lowest ever outside temperature: –55.4 degrees Celsius.

“Throwing a cup of boiling water into the air resulted in a small explosion as the water instantly turned into a cloud of ice crystals. This obviously didn’t help us on station at the time but it was nice to see a record set!” wrote Anthony Lister, an electrical engineer at Halley, on his blog.

Google maps methane leaks

Posted on behalf of Mark Zastrow.

Google’s fleet of city-mapping cars are now working to measure urban natural gas leaks.

The technology giant’s collaboration with the Environmental Defense Fund (EDF), announced on 16 July, equips Google’s Street View cars with sensors to detect methane leaking from ageing city pipes, through city streets and into the atmosphere. The sensors were developed by researchers at Colorado State University in Fort Collins.

The project has released online methane maps for Boston, Massachusetts; Staten Island in New York; and Indianapolis, Indiana. The team found thousands of leaks in Boston and Staten Island at a rate of roughly one per every mile (1.6 kilometres) of road driven, whereas Indianapolis’s roads are leaking only once every 200 miles (322 kilometres) — a sign of newer infrastructure.

These leaks are too small to be a health or explosion risk, but they are also a growing climate concern; methane is 86 times more powerful as a greenhouse gas than carbon dioxide, over a 20-year period, according to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Massachusetts passed legislation in June that requires utilities to speed up their pipe replacement, and California is considering following suit.

“We think [this technique] will offer a new way for utilities and regulators to evaluate their ongoing leak detection and repair programs,” says Mark Brownstein, the leader of the EDF’s natural gas efforts. The group says that utilities could reduce their emissions 2–3 times faster by prioritizing those larger leaks.

But just how utilities might actually use the data in practice remains to be seen, says Susan Fleck, vice-president of pipeline safety for National Grid, a London-based private utility that is also collaborating on the mapping project. “You know, I just have to be really up front about this. This is a pilot programme, right? So it’s kind of hard to say exactly how this is going to work out,” she told reporters.

Nathan Phillips, an ecologist at Boston University in Massachusetts, is sceptical that the data will help utility operators identify specific leaks. Phillips’ team pioneered car-borne urban methane mapping in Boston and has a separate project funded by the EDF, but is not involved with the Google effort. He points out that utilities already know from their own records where the ageing and leak-prone cast iron pipes are. “It doesn’t take a lot of guesswork to say, ‘There’s a 120 year old pipe running under this street, it’s probably a leaky street.’”

What excites him are the project’s plans to go nationwide and the opportunity to compare data across cities. Already, he says he is struck by how few leaks Indianapolis has compared to Boston and Staten Island, a sign of its newer infrastructure. He wonders if publicly owned gas networks (such as that of Indianapolis) will prove less leaky than those owned by private companies that need to balance expansion and market share with maintenance of existing infrastructure; it’s the type of question ‘Big Data’ could answer.

“That’s the beauty of what Google and EDF are getting into,” he says. “This is just a kind of teaser.”