Podcast, videos and more!

I just wanted to point you in the direction of some more chemistry offerings from NPG that have just hit the airwaves.

First up is the latest edition of the podcast – I’m sure it’s already popped in to your iTunes libraries, but for the few of you out there who don’t subscribe, you can visit our ChemPod homepage and feast upon the goodies there. The latest instalment includes an interview with Vince Rotello about his work that is featured on the cover of the September issue of Nature Chemistry as well as a studio chat with yours truly about my impressions of the Lindau Nobel Laureate Meeting that was held in Germany earlier in the summer. There are also segments about ripping electrons from molecules, DNA circuit boards and how best to store hydrogen if you want to use it as fuel in your car.

Second, the first two videos from our ‘Nobel reactions’ series from the aforementioned Lindau meeting are now available, and the remainder will be released over the coming few weeks. Keep an eye out for the conversations between the young researchers and Agre, Ernst & Tsien, and Schrock. These are freely available to view on our website.

Finally, just a quick note to let you know that former Sceptical Chymist blogger Retread now has his own blog – you can read his latest musings on the teaching of organic chemistry to medical students over there now.

Stuart

Stuart Cantrill (Chief Editor, Nature Chemistry)

Nobel reactions

Back in the height of summer, I found myself at the Lindau Nobel Laureate Meeting held in Germany on the shores of lake Constance. I was there as part of a film crew sent by Nature Publishing Group to capture conversations between the young researchers and Nobel Laureates – much in the same way as the physics-themed meeting was covered last year. The first of the chemistry films goes live in a few days time, but to whet your appetite, here is a trailer:

For more details about the meeting, you can also read my report (freely available) from the September issue of Nature Chemistry – which went live yesterday. The latest edition of the ChemPod will also go live in the next few days and you can hear me chatting with Mark Peplow about the Lindau experience and my thoughts about a change in career…!

Stuart

Stuart Cantrill (Chief Editor, Nature Chemistry)

Lindau09: Island hopping

Tomorrow the Lindau Meeting shifts to another island in Lake Constance. Early in the morning, delegates will climb aboard a boat and be ferried across the lake to the island of Mainau – a trip taking more than a couple of hours. Here we will be treated to a panel discussion about ‘Global Warming and Sustainability’ with quite a distinguished line-up. As well as Laureates Molina and Schrock, the panel also includes Rajendra Pachauri, Chairman of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) – which won the Peace Prize in 2007. Other participants include the author Bjorn Lomborg, and Professors William Moomaw and Thomas Stocker.

Because it is unlikely I’ll have good web access tomorrow, I figured I should briefly post about Thursday’s activities before I go. The first session of lectures amounted to a green fluorescent protein (GFP) extravaganza, with talks from Shimomura, Chalfie and Tsien (last year’s recipients of the chemistry prize). We were treated to some very colourful slides, including a green bunny and the incredible hulk! It was nice to hear both Chalfie and Tsien talk about Doug Prasher’s contribution to the area – the ‘missing’ Laureate in GFP research.

Both Chalfie and Tsien had stories to tell about getting their seminal papers published. Editors at a certain high-profile journal objected to Chalfie using the word ‘new’ in the title of his paper, saying that all work they published was new! Perhaps more amusing, however, was when someone from the art department got in touch with Chalfie about his cover image – they really liked the picture, but there was one colour they didn’t really like to use on the cover, so could they get rid of the green…?! ‘No’, said Chalfie.

Tsien’s story about publishing the crystal structure of GFP was one of referee trouble (at the same journal Chalfie struggled with). The first referee said that it was a competent crystal structure, but the protein was not very interesting! The second referee said it was all well and good but the paper didn’t answer the most important question about GFP – it’s biological role in the jellyfish! The manuscript was rejected and when Tsien appealed, the editor sent it to a third referee. Many months passed, however, and the third referee never replied. Then, on the internet, Tsien found a comment from someone saying that they had solved the crystal structure of GFP and it was coming out the following month in a different journal – Tsien forwarded this to the editor and the paper was accepted the next day! Moral of the story – be careful what you say on the internet…

Both Chalfie and Tsien had some great quotes – I include a few below (I can’t guarantee that I have the wording exactly correct, but the meaning remains unaltered):

Chalfie:

It’s very hard to tell if an animal is touch-sensitive if it is dead!

I’m the accidental Laureate that got into the middle of this.

Students and postdocs are the real innovators in science.

Tsien:

Biology has the most interesting grand questions in all of science currently doable by individuals.

I was no smarter the day after I received the Nobel prize than the day before, but it made me a lot more famous!

Prizes are ultimately a matter of luck, so avoid being motivated or impressed by them.

After the coffee break, the final two lectures at this Lindau Meeting were delivered by Richard Schrock (Chemistry 2005) and Werner Arber (Physiology or Medicine 1978). Schrock gave us a tour through his Mo and W metathesis catalysts, showing some recent work on being able to make Z-olefins, rather than the more thermodynamically stable E isomers. He was also eager to point out that although his catalysts are air and water sensitive (in contrast to the Ru catalysts of Grubbs and others), this does not matter if (i) you’re making a billion-dollar drug or (ii) there is no other way of doing the same reaction. Anyone out there in pharma-land wish to comment on part (i)?

Finally, Countess Bernadotte wrapped up this part of the meeting, thanking the Laureates, the young researchers, the organisers and even the media – very nice to get a mention! We then headed off with Schrock to film with two students, although extracting a Nobel Laureate from adoring fans who want photos and autographs is not an easy task… but eventually we made it to the shoot location in a nearby hotel. Once that was finished, my headache finally got the better of me and I headed out of the heat and back to where I am staying – and now because it’s a really early start tomorrow (and I’m not a big fan of those), I’m off to bed…

Stuart

Stuart Cantrill (Chief Editor, Nature Chemistry)

PS: There are lots of other people blogging from the meeting – check out some of these posts and have a poke around at each place for other Lindau entries here, here, here, here and here (apologies to those posts/bloggers I may have missed – feel free to leave links in the comments to this post).

Lindau09: And now for something completely different

Wednesday morning at the Lindau meeting saw a full slate of talks from half-a-dozen Chemistry Laureates: Marcus (1992), Wüthrich (2002), Kroto (1996), Huber (1988), Kohn (1998), Agre (2003) – and some of the highlights are covered below…

Marcus joked that he was going to speak for a couple of hours, but finished exactly on time after 35 minutes, giving us a tour of catalysis in many different forms, such as the ‘on-water’ work by Sharpless through to single-molecule enzyme catalysis. The next lecture was from Wüthrich, who started off by telling us that ‘NMR’ does not stand for ‘no meaningful results’ and then proceeded to take off his belt – and fortunately he stopped there! He then went on to use his belt to illustrate the human genome.

The final talk of the first session was from Kroto, who spoke on themes of science, society and sustainability. His lecture was a barrage on the senses (albeit a very entertaining one), with slides popping up at a high rate of knots, with occasional sound effects to boot. We were shown examples of artwork that Kroto had produced, including stamps, and even a new design for the flag of Japan. He then moved on to topics such as creationism and religion in general, Web 2.0 opportunities for science and scientific education, and the fact that he may have to give his prize back if no one finds a use for C60 in the near future! Kroto left the stage to the longest and loudest applause of the meeting so far.

After the coffee break, Huber was the first speaker, although the computer on which the presentations were loaded would not play ball. Problems finally solved, he went on to tell us about protein degradation. Kohn was next up and apart from a brief intro and wrap up, his ‘lecture’ consisted of showing a film he had made, called ‘The power of the sun’ – narrated by John Cleese of Monty Python fame. No ex-parrots in sight unfortunately! The final talk of the day was given by Agre, who told us about his canoeing trips in the arctic and sub-arctic. Although he tied his talk to environmental themes and climate issues, such as the changing migration paths of caribou and the impact on native hunters, it was hard not to think that we were just seeing his holiday snaps (very pretty ones, nonetheless!).

Lectures over for the day, I went to help out the film crew once more. The first shoot was a conversation between one of the young researchers (Tyler) and Ernst. As the storm clouds gathered in the distance and the thunder got louder, lightning crackled across the sky and the heavens opened – making filming impossible. With lots of camera equipment and a Nobel Laureate in tow, we tried to take the most direct (and driest) route back inside the conference venue. Our way was barred by the conference stewards, who probably assumed we wanted to film the afternoon discussions (which is not allowed – in fact, no press are allowed in those sessions at all) – whereas all we wanted to do was get inside to then go and find a new location. Tyler came to the rescue — his German being better than any of ours — and finally persuaded the stewards to let us in… he pointed out that we had a Laureate with us, who probably shouldn’t get soaked in a thunderstorm. So, there you have it, getting the call from Stockholm can open doors for you!

Two shoots later, with Ciechanover and Tsien, it was time to wind down for the day and plan our activities for Thursday – just one shoot I need to be at today, so may have a little free time later this afternoon to explore Lindau. There may not be a post tomorrow, as we’re off to the island of Mainau and away from the wireless access here in the Inselhalle, but they’ll be a couple of more Lindau posts at some point.

Stuart

Stuart Cantrill (Chief Editor, Nature Chemistry)

Lindau09: Reflections on day 2

Tuesday morning at Lindau saw three talks from Laureates – Aaron Ciechanover (Chemistry 2004), Mario Molina (Chemistry 1995), and Erwin Neher (Physiology or Medicine 1991). Unfortunately I was called away just at the start of the first talk to shuttle our van around Lindau and only made it back half-way through Molina’s talk. Jason – one of my colleagues here – had it even worse, however, as he headed over to Zurich (almost a 300-km round trip!) to pick up essential equipment for the film crew.

After the coffee break, we were treated to the first of two panel discussions here at the meeting – this one was about the role and future of chemistry for renewable energy. Sitting on the panel were Laureates Ertl, Grubbs, Kohn, Kroto, Marcus, Molina and Rowland – quite a line-up! The moderator framed various problems at the opening of the discussion, in particular (i) the fact that fossil fuels will not last forever, (ii) anthropogenic climate change as a consequence of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases, and (iii) security problems with nuclear energy technologies. Each Laureate was invited to respond in an opening statement and some snippets are included below.

Ertl reminded us that we cannot create (nor destroy) energy and that our problems simply boil down to how we can harness the power of the sun to produce useful energy that can be stored in a practical fashion – he suggested that silicon photovoltaics are potentially a promising way forward. Grubbs reminded us that he was the only organic chemist on the panel (the first time I’ve heard him describe himself as an organic chemist!) and that materials science is a crucial and enabling technology for renewable energies, in terms of making energy storage and transport more efficient. Kohn summed up the situation by telling us that tough problems must be tackled by viewing them from many different perspectives.

Next was Kroto, who said that we need to recognise the scale of the problem – telling us that it takes a million years to produce the quantity of fossil fuels we currently consume each year. Water splitting is what we should focus on in his opinion – and recounted someone telling him that if ‘stupid’ trees can do it, then we should be able to do it too! The problem is that trees really aren’t that stupid after all – nature has had a long time to figure out photosynthesis. Sir Harry went on to criticise how science is funded, and pointed out that breakthroughs often come from blue-sky research and that governments and funding agencies should continue to fund such work.

Marcus was next and brought up the point that not only is solar energy conversion an important societal challenge, but is also a very interesting and stimulating intellectual challenge. Large numbers of researchers and good collaborations are required – and he suggested that a mini Manhattan Project is in order (obviously with a very different goal, but using the same principle of bringing together leading scientists and engineers from around the world to tackle a pressing problem).

Molina and Rowland rounded out the opening statements, with Molina suggesting that society needs to double or triple its investment in renewable energy – and although it may look self-serving for a scientist working in this area to say this, it is wholly justified. Finally Rowland lamented the fact that he had to say something original after following six other Laureates! Nevertheless, he did, saying that we should focus on getting rid of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere and also look at other nuclear fusion approaches, although he was less optimistic about these.

Finally, the moderators presented questions to the Laureates that had been prepared by the students – and much discussion ensued about the best way to tackle the energy problems we face as scientists and as a society.

That concluded the open scientific activities for the day and then I went off to my other career here, that of a helping hand with the film crew. First off we filmed a couple of the young researchers chatting with Peter Agre and then headed off to one of the hotels to film a discussion between Molina, Rowland and three students moderated by Olive from the Climate Feedback blog.

After that, there was another production meeting to discuss the filming schedule for today and that will kick into high gear after lunch – and stories will follow tomorrow…

Stuart

Stuart Cantrill (Chief Editor, Nature Chemistry)

Lindau09: Art meets science

On day 1 of the Lindau Meeting, art and science collided in more than one way… here’s what I got up to.

First port of call was the Inselhalle on the island of Lindau (which is connected to the mainland by road and rail). The island is a pleasant 20-30 minute walk from our hotels on the mainland, or just a few minutes drive in the space-age VW van we have been kindly given for the duration of the meeting. It has a few thousand miles on the clock but has a genuine new car smell – so much so, I though it was brand new.

Anyway the morning began in a packed lecture hall and the first Laureate to speak was the 2007 Nobel Prize recipient, Gerhard Ertl. So, the conference kicked off with some hardcore catalysis – the kind that takes place on solid surfaces. We were treated to some pretty patterns associated with complex reactions – such as the BZ reaction.

Art featured much more heavily in the second lecture of the day, which was delivered by the 1991 awardee, Richard Ernst. He told us that there is much beyond traditional science, such as arts and humanities and that we should have ‘passions’ outside of science to make us more complete individuals. His lecture ranged from the cultural history of central Asia – including, in particular, Tibetan art, of which he is a collector – to science education for monks and nuns in south India: ‘Science meets Dharma’. Ernst talked us through some fascinating pieces of art – and then moved on to art restoration and chemical techniques for pigment analysis, nicely weaving together his interests in art and science.

The first session of the day was rounded out by Ryoji Noyori whose theme was very much that chemistry is the key to our future. The moral to his story was that while nature gives us many wonderful molecules, the synthetic chemist can make so many more, and as we develop newer and better methodology, we can make them selectively and efficiently. He ended by saying that education is key and that the young researchers at the meeting are crucial for our (chemical) future.

After the coffee break, the first two speakers were Sherwood Rowland and Paul Crutzen – co-recipients of the 1995 Nobel Prize (along with Mario Molina). If you ever had any doubts about anthropogenic climate change, then you need to listen to these eminent scientists speak. The first day was then rounded out by Hartmut Michel – who received the Nobel Prize in 1988 – telling us about cytochrome c oxidase.

That was it for lectures, but then in the afternoon I turned runner/boom operator for the film crew shooting the Nature videos. I went from Laureate chauffer – driving SIr Harry Kroto and his wife to the location of the filming – to ‘microphone stand’ – which my colleague Sam assures me is the technical term for a boom operator… – I think he might be winding me up…

Anyway, after a successful shoot, Prof. Kroto and his wife had a much smoother ride back to their hotel when someone else drove the VW van, and then finally the team got together for some well-deserved tex-mex as the sun slowly set. Discussions about filming for today ensued, and then we made our way back to our hotels to recharge for today – which you can find out about tomorrow! More then…

For other NPG blogging, check out the Climate Feedback blog and Olive’s post about the renewable energy panel discussion earlier today.

Stuart

Stuart Cantrill (Chief Editor, Nature Chemistry)

Lindau09: Setting the scene

So, the NPG team and film crew arrived on Saturday afternoon in Germany and after checking in to our hotels on the mainland, we made our way over to the island of Lindau to meet some prospective students for the series of videos that we are producing. Much discussion ensued over dinner later in the evening and the plan for the films started to crystallise – calls were made and appointments set.

Sunday morning began with some filming of some of the students chosen to speak with the Laureates in the films. This involved finding locations on the scenic island of Lindau where there was enough sun, but not too much – and as little background noise as possible. You really don’t notice how noisy ‘background noise’ can be until you need to film! Cobbled streets and roller-suitcases make for quite a din!

Sunday afternoon then saw the opening ceremony at Lindau, which began with a very eloquent and moving address to the assembled delegates from Countess Bettina Bernadotte, President of the Council for the Lindau Nobel Laureate Meetings. Two new members were admitted to the Honorary Senate of the Foundation Lindau Nobelprizewinners Meetings at Lake Constance – José Barroso, President of the EU-Commission and Kapil Sibal, Indian Minister for Human Resource Development.

The ceremony drew to a close after a discussion on the stage with five of the young researchers who are attending the meeting, during which they described what is required to succeed in science – with answers ranging from good collaborations, support, ambition, and perhaps even a little bit of luck.

We’ve now just had the first scientific session, with talks from Ertl, Ernst and Noyori – I’ll gather my thoughts and then tell you all about it a little later, but now the second session is moments away. For live updates, you can follow on Twitter!

Stuart

Stuart Cantrill (Chief Editor, Nature Chemistry)

On the road again

Tomorrow sees me hit the road (well, the rails, really) for the start of my conference season. First up is the 2009 International Symposium on Macrocyclic and Supramolecular Chemistry (ISMSC 2009) in Maastricht in The Netherlands. This brings back fond memories of my first trip to an ISMC conference (in the days before the macrocyclic and supramolecular chemistry meetings decided to merge) back in 1998. The venue was Turtle Bay on the Hawaiian island of Oahu. Brownie points for anyone who can spot me in this photo!

Next up, is a trip to the 2009 Lindau Nobel Laureate Meeting – and this year the meeting is dedicated to chemistry (with some climate concerns thrown in for good measure). The Lindau meetings bring together Nobel Laureates and young researchers from around the globe and is not your typical conference that consists of lectures and poster sessions. The laureates and researchers are thrown together for the best part of a week; for lectures, discussions and dinner – the social programme is integrated with the scientific one.

Last year at Lindau the focus was on physics and Nature produced a series of videos featuring conversations between students and Laureates – you can see all of them here. This year, we’re doing a similar thing, so look out for some videos later in the year.

I’ll be blogging from both meetings and perhaps tweeting too… so keep an eye out for what’s going on.

Stuart

Stuart Cantrill (Chief Editor, Nature Chemistry)

SciFinder and the small screen

Oh, the joys of the World Wide Web…

If you have a few minutes to spare, liven up your Friday and check out these promotional videos (“”https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4_WoAR9GdCQ&feature=channel_page">The Party" and “”https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AEUXJ7ydpKI&feature=channel_page">The Paper") for SciFinder – make sure you watch them with the sound on.

The message seems to be that SciFinder will do wonders for your average college student – not only in terms of academic success, but also freeing up more time to do things that aren’t necessarily on the typical college curriculum…

Nice!

Stuart

Stuart Cantrill (Chief Editor, Nature Chemistry)

Outsell and InChIs

Having just launched Nature Chemistry we’re keeping a close eye on whenever we get a mention out there in cyberspace, so that we can get some idea of what the big wide world thinks about us.

One story that caught our eye was from Outsell, which, in their words, ‘is the only research and advisory firm focused on the publishing, information, and education industries’. The article was entitled ‘Chemical Bonding InChI by InChI’ and it offered an analysis of how certain publishers were making use of InChIs – those of you unfamiliar with InChIs can go here for a primer.

In addition to covering Project Prospect from the Royal Society of Chemistry, we here at Nature Chemistry also received some attention for how we are using InChIs and other chemical identifiers. Our friends over at ChemSpider also got a few mentions.

The article them moves on to consider whether CAS (Chemical Abstracts Service), which is owned by the ACS, will also embrace InChIs. The conclusion was that we may have to wait a while for that to happen.

So why do you need to know this? Well, the story from Outsell has been withdrawn (on April 8th) – and more than that, in fact, it has been removed from their archives (although the original story is cached on Google and you can find it here).

Whether it is right to completely remove every trace of a story that you withdraw is a discussion for another day – but now all that remains is a brief notice indicating that the original story did not hold up to Outsell’s internal standards.

Outsell now say that the original article wasn’t balanced and that the ‘tone of the piece could be taken to single out CAS as being late in responding to the trends’. Surely readers could make that judgement for themselves?

The great shame is that the whole article has simply been removed and an analysis of how cross-publisher development on an important topic such as the InChI – which may have a significant role to play in chemistry publishing – has been lost.


UPDATE on April 15: it appears that Outsell have now shortened their retraction notice to just say that they have removed the article – and include no reasons why. For further coverage in the blogosphere, see these pieces at ChemSpider, Depth-First and PMR’s blog.

Stuart

Stuart Cantrill (Chief Editor, Nature Chemistry)