War, what is it good for?

Exhibitions, if nothing else.

I popped down to War+Medicine today, the latest temporary exhibition at Wellcome Collection.

It is an experience filled with potent imagery. Take Theatre, the opening film by artist David Cotterrell, for example. On entering a darkened room, I took a low seat close to the back. Projections on the far wall create the illusion that I’m on the floor of an RAF Hercules as its crew and medics go about their business. The footage is from a training exercise in Afghanistan—a simulation of a simulation. But the effect is deeply immersive. The waist-high point-of-view and muting of conversation by the four propeller engines of the Hercules give a feeling of aloofness, as though I’m an injured soldier propped up against the fuselage. This is a virtual reality, and not a pleasant one.

Beyond the film, the exhibition tells the story of health and medicine on the battlefield, starting with the Crimean War of the 1850s. This was a real turning point for the British Army, when logistical ineptitude led to thousands of preventable deaths through lack of basic treatment.

From here, my notions of battlefield medicine were challenged. Treating soldiers bears little similarity to civilian medicine. For example, if you had to choose between helping a soldier with a minor flesh wound and another with a bullet to the hip, you might treat the former in preference to the latter, so as to return him to the battlefield more quickly. Those who need more protracted attention might face amputation, plastic surgery and psychological recuperation—all topics covered in other parts of the exhibition. The photos of early attempts at facial reconstruction are particularly striking; weird tubes of flesh stretch from chest to cheek in an effort to cover burns with skin grafts.

Battlefield medicine coevolves with the weapons of war. New treatments and protections followed the introduction of nuclear and chemical weapons, and the current conflicts in Iraq and Afghanistan raise their own challenges. Roadside blasts account for many of the injuries to allied forces. Modern body armour often prevents death, but gives little protection to the limbs and face. The exhibition brings home this grim reality, with photographs such as this.

The squeamish will squeam, but War+Medicine deploys graphic imagery and insightful explanation with tactical perfection, producing an exhibition that is both memorable and moving.

War+Medicine runs until 15 February. Entry is free. A series of events throughout the winter support the exhibition.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

War… what is it good for?

I was searched by the police again this morning. Not that this happens all the time, but I’ve been searched at Kings Cross station three times over the last two years, as part of some recently introduced anti-terrorism scheme. I don’t really mind, although given that there are 77.5 million passengers passing through Kings Cross every year, I can’t help but feel I’m bucking the statistical average (for more mind-boggling London Transport facts, click here)

This got me thinking about how the situation in the Middle East ripples out to affect everyone, and in particular, how it affects chemists. For example, the Department of Homeland Security in the USA recently announced a list of 300 chemicals that require regulation to deter terrorism. The list includes several commonly used chemicals, such as ammonia and chlorine. US universities and other research sites will now be required to make inventories of these chemicals if they have more than the DHS-approved quantities. This may be something of a logistical nightmare, but it could have been worse – acetone was originally proposed to be on the list. How many chemistry departments are there that don’t use acetone?

Perhaps more worrying is the effect of the war on funding. Several US academics that I’ve spoken to have said that government funding for research has been squeezed, because money is being diverted in other directions. But then again, this might depend on the area you work in; biosensors for detecting toxins such as ricin are a hot topic nowadays, with interest not just from government funding bodies, but also from business. But as David Russell (a UK chemist who works in this area) pointed out in a recent interview in Chemistry World, it’s a shame that more people aren’t interested in biosensors for cholera. Subscribers to Science might be interested in reading the following open letter to the NIH on the theme of funding for security-related research, and the NIH’s response.

And then there are more personal cases, such as the recent example in the UK where a man labelled as a potential terrorist has been prevented from taking basic-level chemistry classes (Nature subscribers can read our news report about this here.)

So has the war against terror affected your working life? Has security at chemistry departments increased in recent years? Or are you seeing any trends in areas of research that attract funding? I’d be interested to know.

Andy

Andrew Mitchinson (Associate Editor, Nature)

2 thoughts on “War… what is it good for?

  1. 0) Homeland Severity

    1) Add water to the Homeland Severity list to render it perfect: carte blanche to break, enter, search, and seize without court-issued warrant; a legal monopoly targeting physical force against legally disarmed victims.

    2) Ayn Rand: “The only power any government has is the power to crack down on criminals. Well, when there aren’t enough criminals, one makes them. One declares so many things to be a crime that it becomes impossible for men to live without breaking laws.”

    3) Nothing must stay our hand against discovering and destroying agents of Emmanuel Goldstein.

  2. I’ve never been stopped and/or searched once in 12 years of using the station (or however long ago it is that Nature moved to an office next door to it). Maybe they can tell I am not a chemist. Biophysicists evidently do not have the same cachet.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *