News blog

European Research Council grantees want better status in Italy

Italian scientists are exceptionally good at winning European Research Council (ERC) grants. That means a lot, since ERC Starting Grants and Advanced Grants are highly prestigious and unusually lucrative – they can bring up to €3.5 million to the host institute over five years, enough to establish a well-endowed research group.


Yet rules at home make it so complicated to operate the grants that a large proportion of Italian winners choose to bring them to a host institute in another European country – meaning that Italian institutions (such as the University of Padua, right) lose out.

Now 30 ERC grant holders working in Italy have written to their research minister, Mariastella Gelmini, asking that they be excluded from a number of restrictions introduced in a new law on universities which came into effect in January. The law was designed to regularise national academic hiring practices, but in practice sets conditions that are not internationally competitive.

They also ask to be independent of controversial 2008 rules restricting turnover of academic staff. The government hopes to save money by gradually reducing the total number of professors at Italian universities.

“The research ministry was not thinking about ERC grants when they wrote these rules,” says particle physicist Vincenzo Greco at the University of Catania, who won an ERC Starting Grant in 2009 and signed the letter. “It doesn’t make sense that all the rules should apply when money is brought in from outside – particularly when it is intended to bring a culture of excellence with it.”

The twists and turns of the new universities law mean that a grant holder wishing to spend part of the grant on hiring academic colleagues for his or her research group has two options, both unattractive.

One option is a one-size-fits-all contract for a maximum of four years which offers no pension. “This makes it hard to attract a person from abroad with the skills you might want; even if you find someone suitable in Italy, you feel guilty that you are depriving him or her of years of pension,” says ERC grant-holder Guildo Martinelli, director of SISSA (International School for Advanced Studies) in Trieste, who organised the petition to the ministry.

The second option – rather theoretical in practice – is a faculty position. Even though money for an ERC grant comes from outside Italy, the research ministry requires that an ERC associate professorship, for example, be considered as one of the fixed number of faculty positions available. The grant holder would firstly have to fight for one of the rare positions internally – and then take it through a national competition. Even if successful, those procedures could take a year or more, making it somewhat unrealistic in the context of a five-year grant, particularly since the outcome of a national competition may not be predictable. In any case, such a position would by definition carry a significant teaching load which a foreign researcher might find unattractive.

The letter asks the ministry to allow more flexibility in fixed-term contracts for researchers hired on external grants. It also says that a new position of research professor should be created which would allow academics to be hired fixed-term on a regular contract without teaching requirements. The current situation, where scientists designated as excellent by the ERC are unable to operate competitively in Italian universities, is “absurd”, it says.

The European Commission, which finances the independent ERC, said that it was aware of the problem and “it is up to the Italian ministry to respond to the researchers’ letter”.

But advanced ERC grant holder Massimo Inguscio, says the situation is “not so dramatic”. He signed the letter because there are “clear problems” he says, but he thinks they will be addressed. The new university law includes a clause which could allow special status for those holding European grants, he points out. “The ministry is already trying to make rules that will work for ERC grant holders.”


  1. Report this comment

    michele ciavarella said:

    You may be interested to know that the discussion about this problem is still going on. The ERC grantees have received special attention, at least those in Universities, not so far those in research centers, since they can at least hope for direct hiring procedures. However, despite the procedure is allowed by the law, and some ERC grantees were hired by some faculties, still the central Minister for Research has not responded about validating these nominations.

    In general, there is now a large appeal about the lack for support to excellence in research and universities, see this link in the Harvard blog


    Which suggests some ambitious plans. However, if this is only wishful thinking, and Italy is still not prepared to respond to the need of competitive universities in the international framework, this is still to be seen. The new Minister has not responded so far to the appeal, maybe Nature would like to write an article about it?

    Prof. Michele Ciavarella
    Politecnico di BARI

Comments are closed.