APS 2010: The hair on a black hole

smbh.gif Have you ever seen the videos of stars whirling around the supermassive black hole at the center of the Milky Way? They’re wild. But wouldn’t you want to see pictures of the black hole itself?

On Saturday at APS, there were talks showing how two rival approaches are getting up close and personal to the hole, called Sagittarius A*. One group even says that they will soon be able to actually image the hole — and that the data they have already shows that the hole’s accretion disk is oblique to use, rather than facing us perpendicularly, like a doughnut.

By analyzing the orbits of those nearby stars, astronomers already know the mass of Sgr A* quite precisely — it has swallowed the equivalent mass of four million Suns. But the second fundamental characteristic in defining a black hole is its spin, which would explain something about the history of the hole — a sort of timeline of its appetite — that in turn would help explain the history of the galaxy. And David Merritt of RIT said that scientists are close to spotting the spin. He just needs to find two stars within 20 astronomical units (an AU, or the distance between the Earth and Sun) of the hole and track them. And he says a new instrument, called GRAVITY, expected to be put onto ESO’s VLT in a few years, should do the trick.

While the VLT will peer past the Milky Way’s dust to get at Sgr A* in the near infrared, Shep Doeleman at MIT wants to use radio telescopes to achieve an incredible resolution that he compares to reading the date off a quarter held up in Los Angeles from Washington DC. He has already linked up three radio telescopes — arrays in California, Arizona and Hawaii — giving him an effective baseline of a single telescope 4,500 kilometres across. In a 2008 Nature paper, he used this set up to show that the Sgr A* was one-third of an AU across — which essentially proves that Sgr A* is a black hole, since nothing else could fill up that small of a space with that much mass.

At APS, Doeleman announced that with new data from his radio arrays, he now knows something about the shape of the accretion disk of gas that is feeding the black hole. Instead of facing us like a doughnut, the accretion disk is probably somewhat edge-on or oblique to the Earth. “It’s not as sexy as it used to be,” says Doeleman. Eventually, he wants to bolster his virtual telescope by adding more than a dozen stations in Chile, Antarctica and elsewhere. At that point, this Event Horizon Telescope would be able to make time lapse movies of the hole’s surface, which could be spinning and have hotspots. The animation shown here gives a sense of what some of the researchers think they can achieve.

APS 2010: Science and secrecy

secrecy.jpg Is the censorship of sensitive science becoming more or less pronounced? Yesterday, during a session on ‘science and secrecy’, Steven Aftergood, who leads the project on government secrecy for the Federation of American Scientists, had numbers that told a mixed tale.

On the hand, he said, there were 23 million classification decisions in 2008, up from 8.6 million in 2001 and 3.5 million in 1995. These 2008 decisions were made by 4,000 government classifiers, and cost taxpayers $9.85 billion. And with science from World War I still restricted, Aftergood says that bureaucratic inertia resists the more open dissemination of scientific knowledge.

On the other hand, Aftergood pointed out that the amount of classified science, as a percentage of all science, is shrinking fast. And, because of a presidential order in December, all agencies are conducting a review of their dozens of classification schemes with an eye towards eliminating ones that are obsolete or inappropriate.

Perhaps that will lead to a world where there is less wanton secrecy. Peter Galison of Harvard was also on hand, partly to promote his new movie, in which he asserts that the US government classifies five times as many pages of information as are added to the Library of Congress.

APS 2010: Sculpting physics

kryptos2.jpg During a press conference today, I was pleased to meet the artist Jim Sanborn, a specialist in scientific sculptures who is probably one of the Washington DC’s most important artists. Sanborn is currently most famous for a piece, pictured here, that sits near the entrance to the CIA headquarters in Langley, Virginia. Using techniques taught to him by a former CIA spook, Sanborn in 1990 created the undulating copper screen with its 1,800 encrypted characters. Most have already been hacked, and the letters translate to three ambiguous and slightly sinister messages. But the last part, 97 or 98 characters long, has remained unsolved. Sanborn, a tall, rugged man at once both coy and curmudgeonly, says he wouldn’t mind if it stayed unsolved for another 20 years, even after his “demise”. (According to Wired, his will contains the solution.) I asked Jim to throw a bone to the armies of amateur cryptologists who hang on his every word. He said that they should wait for a book he’s working on that will “contain more clues.”

Jim also described a forthcoming work, one that will open this summer in Denver. It looks terrifying and magnificent, and continues to reflect his interest in the history of nuclear weapons. In an earlier work, called “Atomic Time”, Sanborn recreated Manhattan Project equipment, like nuclear still-lifes – and even reconstructed bomb models that pretty much just needed uranium or plutonium to work. For the new show, called “Terrestrial Physics”, Sanborn built a working Van de Graaf particle accelerator that he uses to actually fission uranium – having modeled the giant pieces after stuff he found gathering dust nearby at the Carnegie Institutes of Washington, where in 1939, physicists made one of the first confirmations that fission existed. Part of the point, he says, is to show how relatively easy it is to build the equipment and infrastructure of nuclear weapons some 70 years after it all began. “I felt that it was important for people to see the real thing,” he says. “So far a nuclear device has never failed to work. It’s that easy. The whole point is, absolutely, to reduce and stop the production of fissile materials.”

Image: CIA

APS 2010: American Physical Snowciety

capitolsnow.jpg So the physicists have arrived in Washington DC for the April APS meeting to find themselves surrounded by a couple feet of snow. This is because the April meeting, this year, is in February. Nice one. Normally, February wouldn’t be so bad in Washington. This year was different. For arriving physicists who have somehow ignored the news over the last week, Washington has been hit by two blizzards within a single week. First was Snowpocalypse (aka Snowmageddon), followed up four days later by Snoverkill. But everyone seems to be cozy here in the Mariott Woodley Park hotel, and attendance isn’t down too much. I hope to check in through the President’s Day weekend with newsy bits and blurbs.

Image: Cycle the Ghost Round via Flickr

AAS 2010: Another super-Earth! Are you yawning?

superearth.jpg Astronomers have found the second smallest exoplanet, HD156668b, a so-called “super-Earth” that’s just four times the mass of the Earth. With an orbit of just 4.6 days (compare that to Mercury’s 88-day orbit), this planet would not be a nice place for life. Yet, that such a small planet can be duly reported at AAS amid shoulder shrugging by the scientists and press alike shows just how far the exoplanet field has come in a few years.

The week of AAS began with discoveries from Kepler, and its search for transiting planets. And now it’s ending (or at least my blog posts are ending) with this discovery, which comes from astronomers using the twin 10-metre Keck telescopes in Hawaii to look for the wobble caused by the planet on its parent star.

The two bookends show not only the race between the space-based and ground-based observatories, but also the different approaches they use: transits, which give planet diameter, and the wobble searches, which give mass.

But as much as the two groups are competing, they also need each other. Not just to confirm planets — there are many false positives out there — but also to get both size and mass so that density can be calculated. Density, it turns out, is the crucial measurement that will tell us whether these distant worlds are puffed up and full of gas, buoyant and watery, or hard as rock. For now, all we know about HD156668b is that it is damn hot.

Image: L. Calcada

AAS 2010: the Universe — older than you think

It’s no surprise that people do the best job conceptualizing the spatial and temporal scales of the everyday — the length of a car; the length of a work day — and have a much harder time with extreme scales, like the age of the universe.

But people are slightly worse at understanding extreme scales of time than space, according to Aaron Price of Tufts University, who gave a neat astronomy education talk on Wednesday.

In a survey of more than 400 undergraduates, Price found that students consistently underestimated big time scales and overestimated the duration of the quickest phenomena — worse than they did for spatial scales. But in both situations, Price says, the mind is trying to condense the two extremes towards something more manageable in the middle — which suggests that mental number lines are inherently logarithmic.

AAS 2010: Gemini struggles without the UK

gemini.jpg Anyone want some time on a really big telescope? Gemini, the observatory with twin 8-metre telescopes in Hawaii and Chile, could use the money.

In November, the UK cemented its decision to withdraw as a 25% partner from the six-nation observatory by the end of 2012. This is just one of many cuts Britain is making as the STFC tries to climb out of budget hole. The UK had flirted with maintaining some time in the northern hemisphere (since it already has access to ESO telescopes in Chile), but the Gemini board nixed that.

At a town hall meeting at AAS, Gemini director Doug Simons discussed his plans to carry on. Instead of dealing with a sudden drop at the end of 2012, the observatory is cutting budgets by 7% to 10% each of the next three years.

“2010 may be the biggest budget that we have for a very long time,” he said. “I do not expect Gemini to be the same observatory at the end of this process.”

He says the most savings will come from altering the science operations – which may diminish the custom ways in which the observatory manages its science queue.

But Simons is still hopeful that Gemini, which provides the vast majority of large-diameter telescope time for US astronomers through NOAO, will remain relevant. Five new instruments are nearly finished, and Simons wants to keep its unique capabilities in the infrared.

AAS 2010: Charlie Bolden, science cheerleader

bolden3.jpgThe astronomers heard what they wanted to hear. Even as NASA sits in limbo, awaiting a presidential decision on the future of the human spaceflight programme, NASA Administrator Charles Bolden told hundreds of astronomers that their budget would be sacrosanct. “The future of human spaceflight will not be paid out of the hide of the science budget,” said Bolden on Tuesday in a jam-packed NASA town hall at AAS.

But whether Bolden can deliver on that promise won’t be revealed until February, when the Administration releases its fiscal 2011 budget, and also when President Barack Obama delivers his state of the union address. Rumor has it that the speech will reference NASA’s future, and will contain Obama’s long-awaited decision, one that was supposed to come in the wake of a blue-ribbon report chaired by Norman Augustine last summer. That report laid out the grim options for human spaceflight at NASA, a programme that was perhaps $3 billion a year short of returning to the moon. While Bolden claimed not to know anything about Obama’s impending decision, it is not hard to read the tea leaves. Many of the Augustine report options favor jettisoning the Ares I rocket in favor of commercial providers of rockets. NASA would then focus on a heavy lift vehicle, though it might take a different guise than the current Ares V.

In the absence of hard facts, Bolden stuck to the role of cheerleader, telling war stories about his delivery of Hubble Space Telescope to orbit as a shuttle pilot. He exhorted the scientists to focus on outreach and education, almost exactly the opposite of the approach of former Administrator Mike Griffin, who at a conference two years ago dismissed outreach as not being part of NASA’s core mission. Bolden also told the audience that they better get used to international partners and collaborations. He mentioned how he was encouraging JAXA, the Japanese space agency, to turn a space station cargo rocket into something that could ferry people.

But a reporter pressed him: Will the US have a human-rated rocket by 2020? Bolden said he was confident Obama wouldn’t end human spaceflight. Bolden said he would be shocked if the US didn’t have something by then. Later, Bolden said he was shocked the US didn’t have the capability already. If in 1980, “you had told me that we would not be back on the moon today,” he said, “I would have told you you were smoking dope.”

Bolden is all heart — an emotional, sincere and passionate speaker. He sometimes chokes up — something that belies his past as a Marine Corps attack pilot. The contrasts between him and the bluntly logical Griffin are impossible to ignore. But no amount of positive thinking will change the reality that NASA is in a pickle. Even if the science budget isn’t robbed, it could be starved: many predict flat budgets for the agency next year, and there is still time for the $4.5 billion James Webb Space Telescope, due for launch in 2014, to continue to eat up the astrophysics budget.

Last year was great for NASA astrophysics, with the launches of Kepler and WISE and Herschel, and the continued success of Fermi. By contrast, when Bolden detailed the years ahead for NASA, the only mission he could point to in 2010 was SOFIA, a 747 with a puncture wound in its side that contains an infrared telescope. It is set to begin science flights in 2010, but its budget has also ballooned over the years and many say the mission will be out-performed by Herschel.

Yet Bolden, ever the optimist, pointed out that, relative to the deeper past, times have never been better. In 1990, astrophysicists could gather data from five missions in operation. In 2000, there were nine. In 2010, he said, there are 15.

AAS 2010: Mind the gap

neptunegap.jpg

UPDATE: I have a story on a slightly different aspect of the Kepler results — asteroseismology — up on the main Nature News site.

So the Kepler mission announced its first exoplanetary discoveries today: four huge planets bigger than Jupiter, and one about the size of Neptune, all hotly hugging their parent stars in tight orbits of a few days. There were a few neat tidbits that Kepler PI Bill Borucki offered up about the finds in talks today. One of the hot Jupiters has a density as fluffy as styrofoam. Some of them are hotter than molten lead. Looking at them is like looking into a “blast furnace”, says Borucki. Overall, the discoveries serve notice: Kepler is in action. The finds themselves? Not so special really. Of the 415 known exoplanets, the vast majority are hot Jupiters.

One interesting angle in the discoveries, however, is the gap between the four Jupiters and the one Neptune. Neptune is just 17 times the mass of Earth; Jupiter is more than 300 times the Earth’s mass. Why didn’t Kepler find anything in between? Dimitar Sasselov, a Kepler co-investigator from Harvard, says it is because the gap is real. There is a cutoff mass, bigger than Neptune, where a runaway accumulation process occurs during planetary formation. Anything bigger than, say, 30 Earth masses, will eat up any gas it can find in a solar disk and become a big hulking Jupiter. Smaller than the cut off, and it will stay Neptune-like. UC Santa Cruz’s Greg Laughlin was pointing this out a year and a half ago on his terrific blog — that this cutoff mass was expected. But Kepler — one of the first instruments to be capable of reaching low mass planets without selection effects — is starting to show that the “Neptune Gap” is real.

Image: NASA