AAS 2010: Washington DC

capitol.jpg Howdy folks: It’s a frigid morning here in Washington DC, the site for this year’s American Astronomical Society meeting, where 3,500 attendees are expected to pack into the Marriott Wardman Park hotel. This is where I live and work, so instead of tumbling down to the conference from a warm hotel room, I had a lung-scouring walk to the hotel against the wind in 20 degree weather. On the flip side, I know where the bars and restaurants are. Happy to provide advice. After an opening talk from Kepler PI Bill Borucki — stay tuned for the latest discoveries from this mission that could very well bag the first exo-Earth — the conference is underway.

Image: Rob Shenk via Flickr

Lepton Photon 2009: An LHC in every home

livingston.JPGSo what’s next for high-energy physics? The LHC won’t be the end. Physicists will want to go to higher energies. The question is, how? The International Linear Collider — a planned linac that will do for positrons and electrons what the LHC did for protons — is what the community wants right now, but it won’t go to any higher energies. It might be too expensive to build just to match the LHC’s capabilities. Machines like the ILC struggle to achieve accelerating gradients of 30 MeV per metre, and the radio wave power delivered to the metallic cavities would melt them were they not supercooled and superconducting.

But all is not lost. SLAC’s Mark Hogan gave a talk about all the novel accelerating technologies in the works. He presented the so-called Livingston chart, which at right shows the hard-won exponential increase in accelerator energies with time. Every few decades or so, an order of magnitude increase in energy is earned. But you can also see how each successive family of accelerator technologies – cyclotrons, synchrotrons, storage rings – leap to new heights, but taper off with time. Something has to be done. And Hogan thinks that wakefields will be the way to go — using initial pulses to create a wave in a plasma, or a fiber, that in turn allow successive electron pulses to surf on the wake.

Of course, the technology is years away — but it could offer gradients in the GeV per metre range. That would put desktop light sources within reach. Who knows — maybe there could be desktop colliders, too. The future is wide open. But my future at Lepton Photon is quite limited. I am skipping out on Friday, the last day — but have enjoyed my time in Hannover thoroughly. Thanks very much to the organizers.

Lepton Photon 2009: Hint of a Higgs?

cdf.JPGSo nearly all of the talks at this conference have been reviews — not surprising, given the paucity of fresh data in the field. But there is one machine still chugging along — the Tevatron — and new results were presented by each of the main experiments, CDF and DZero. The new Higgs search results weren’t all that surprising, just incremental advances on the last big rollout of results in the spring. But let’s look at the latest results for CDF in the plot here. You can see that, even without combining their data together for a joint analysis, the individual teams are getting close to excluding certain ranges of Higgs masses. In particular, it is interesting how the plot shows observed values exceeding the expected values, especially in the low mass regime around 120 GeV — precisely the region where many theorists expect to find the Higgs. Could this be the beginning of a signal? CDF spokesman Rob Roser says it’s only a one-sigma difference from expectation — barely a blip on the radar in the physics world. But nonetheless, he says it’s a motivation to his team. This is precisely the part of the energy spectrum where the LHC is the worst at detecting the Higgs — a place where the LHC will need a year or two of data to say anything. So it helps give Tevatron continued justification to run in 2011. And it means that, if the Higgs is in fact a low-mass particle, the race for priority is still on.

Lepton Photon 2009: Shining a light through a wall

While most of the talks here at Lepton Photon have focused on blowing up the Standard Model at high energies — i.e., firing up the LHC — Joerg Jaeckel of the University of Durham in the UK gave an interesting talk on how you can look for new physics at energies of just an electron-volt or so. The LHC might miss particles that only rarely interact with normal matter. And so Jaeckel extolled the virtues of exquisitely sensitive experiments that probe this alternative (and cheaper) ‘low-energy’ frontier.

One classic example is the GammeV experiment at Fermilab, which basically tries to shine a light through an opaque wall. On one side of the wall you can have a source that shoots 10^20 photons per second. On the other is a detector so sensitive that it could catch a single photon per second — a full 20 orders of magnitude sensitivity. Now photons can’t go through walls. But a weakly interacting particle could, something like an axion — a hypothetical dark matter particle. And there are certain rare scenarios where photons could create axions. If that happened, the axion could pass through the wall and create a photon on the other side.

There are plenty of other low-energy experiments — some have looked for slight differences in the way light is polarized in the vacuum, and some have looked for axions in the presence of a strong magnetic field. One has even found hints of an anomaly in the standard model by looking at that way the spin of a muon deviates in a magnetic field.

But these experiments in general get little attention. I suggested to Jaeckel that maybe it’s because the LHC is guaranteed to discover new things, whereas these experiments could end up being as fruitless as the seemingly pointless effort of shining a light on a wall. Jaeckel had a nice analogy. “[The LHC] is digging a broad ditch. With a low-energy experiment, you’re digging a hole. It’s a very deep hole, but you may be drilling in the wrong spot.”

Lepton Photon 2009: The malaise

lppeople-2.jpg Here are the several hundred physicists that made their way to Hamburg for the conference. It’s a relatively small conference, and since there is only one plenary session at a time, with invite-only talks given, there is none of the helter-skelter feeling of something like an APS meeting. But several people complained to me that there are only about half as many people as usual — and that that reflects the growing ennui, malaise even, of a community that hasn’t pushed at the energy frontier in decades. You can see that more people made the trek out to Korea for the last Lepton Photon in 2007 in the group photo from that year.

High energy physics has been waiting for something like the LHC for 25 years, says Bob Cousins of UCLA, and a deputy spokesman on CMS. He remembers a DOE advisory committee in 1983 that outlined the need for a super-collider — some machine that would reach beyond the TeV energy scales where the Standard Model breaks down. Sure, the Tevatron has done plenty of interesting things in the interim — but there has been no upheaval to the overall picture. The community has watched as the Superconducting Super Collider got partway built and then was canceled. And it has waited patiently as the LHC worked its way slowly into existence. It really has taken a generation for the LHC, Cousins says. “The lost generation?” I asked. “Yeah, something like that — my generation,” he said. But if they can hold on a little longer, they could end up being the greatest generation.

Lepton Photon 2009: Clamping down

So in all of the discussions of the status of the LHC, there has been little change to the new plan that emerged a few weeks ago: the machine will run at half-energy through most of 2010. The two general purpose experiments, Atlas and CMS, will just have to be patient. But at the end of an LHC status talk, the Atlas team’s Mel Shochet, of the University of Chicago, had a question: how will the LHC fix the problem with the splices for good? Mel had heard a rumor that the LHC would be shut down for quite a while as the welded splices were replaced with clamps — a simpler technology used effectively at Fermilab’s Tevatron.

Would LHC engineers do the clamping over the course of several planned shutdowns each winter? If so, that could put the time when the LHC could operate at full 14 TeV energies way off in the future. On the other hand, shutting down to do all the clamping at once would mean that the LHC would have to be shut down for a long time — maybe even a year — which presents a problem of its own.

In the hallways, I found Rolf-Dieter Heuer, the Gandalf-like director general of CERN, and asked him for his sage thoughts. “Clamping hasn’t been decided, but it very well could be an option,” says Heuer, who is having a bit of a homecoming here — he was the research director of DESY for many years. Heuer says the main thing is to get some data to the experiments and give engineers a feel for the machine. Deciding how to fix the bad splices will come later, he said.

Lepton Photon 2009: Hamburg

leptonphotonposter.jpgWelcome to Lepton Photon 2009, the premier high-energy physics conference of the summer, this year taking place in Hamburg: Germany’s second largest city and, with its system of rivers, dammed lakes and canals, the country’s biggest port. It’s also the place where the Beatles, back in the early 60s, cut their teeth, playing night after night in the city’s famous red-light district.

Not sure where the title of the conference comes from, though I think it’s pretty sweet. As one of my colleagues said, it could be a good name for a rock band. But at least here at the beginning of the conference, we’re not going to be hearing about leptons or photons, but, rather, protons: updates on the status of the proton-smashing LHC, and its two main detector experiments, Atlas and CMS. As most know, the LHC fizzled out last year after a bad weld vaporized — and so most of the people in the room have been closely following every detail of the machine’s rehabilitation. Most of the plan is settled after a new energy schedule was set by LHC management on 6 August, so we’re not expecting any new revelations, but let’s wait and see.

The greening of the pre-Cambrian

icelandmoss.jpg It’s one of the biggest problems in the Earth’s history: What prompted the Cambrian explosion of multi-cellular animal life? (Though calling it the ‘Cambrian explosion’ is a misnomer at this point; most geologists agree that life took off a bit earlier than the Cambrian 540 million years ago — probably 50 million years or so before that boundary.)

Now, a new study in Nature [subscription] presents an intriguing explanation: It was photosynthetic life on land, beginning 850 million years ago, that allowed oxygen levels to rise in the atmsophere. Higher oxygen levels, in turn, allowed respiratory animals to get bigger. As I explain in an accompanying news story, the land life wasn’t plants — it was more likely a dense, mossy, worldwide matting.

The evidence is indirect: isotope records trapped in carbonate rocks formed in shallow seas. Some researchers are skeptical since fossil evidence is virtually non-existent. Moreover, the study will be controversial in geochemistry circles because the authors’ interpretations of the isotope data is very different from another popular line of thinking, which sees radical changes in ocean chemistry closer to the Cambrian boundary as being the impetus for the animal explosion.

Image: Diego Cupolo

Eric Hand is a staff reporter in Nature’s Washington Bureau.

APS 2009: Back to DC

I’m set to head to the airport in a bit, and so this is sayonara. As usual, I didn’t get to half the sessions that I wanted to, but that’s part of the appeal. Just to keep us on our toes, it looks like APS is having its next April meeting in February. But it will be in Washington, DC, my home, so I’ll be happy to offer insider tours. I’m a journalist, so my rates are cheap!

APS 2009: Pierre Auger backs off claims for cosmic ray source

quadriple.jpg The mysterious origin of ultra-high energy cosmic rays is, it seems, still a mystery. Two years ago, scientists at the Pierre Auger Observatory in Argentina thought they had it solved. They published a paper in Science, based on two dozen particles, that there was a correlation with the location of Active Galactic Nuclei — supermassive black holes that accelerate jets of material at near-light speed throughout the universe. At the time of the announcment, there was some doubt: The Hi-Res project, which scans the northern sky like Auger does the south, found no such correlation.

And now, today, Stefan Westerhoff, an Auger scientist from the University of Wisconsin at Madison, said that, based on new particle detections — they have more than 50 now — the correlation no longer holds. “The signal strength is certainly considerably weaker now,” he told his audience. “This is certainly a disappointment.”

But the correlation isn’t so weak that they can give up. The 70% correlation between the cosmic rays and the AGN at the time of the Science publication has now dropped to about 40% — considerably less, but not enough to support the null hypothesis. What could cause some particles to come from AGN, but not others? Westerhoff says it might have something to do with their composition. Maybe the protons come from the AGN, whereas higher mass cosmic rays, say iron nuclei, do not.

Westerhoff says this will be sorted out as they track more particles — which can only come with more time and bigger detectors. If Pierre Auger is the size of Rhode Island, the proposed Pierre Auger North, not too far from Denver, would be the size of Massachusetts — and Westerhoff showed a slide how they can get the necessary statistics in a decade or two. No offense to the lovely state of Colorado, but I say keep the cow pasture free of Cerenkov detectors, and give folks like JEM–EUSO a chance to stick their 2.5-meter camera on the space station.

Image: Pierre Auger