News for authors and readers of Nature Photonics

One or two changes for authors and readers are announced in the January issue of Nature Photonics (3, 1; 2009). The journal’s design has been revitalized by updating its fonts, removing unwanted white space and creating a new fresh look that presents information in a clearer, more concise fashion. The result is a journal with a look that is easier to read and navigate. The editors report:

“We’ve also taken the opportunity to make a few other changes. To bring us in line with other Nature research journals in the physical sciences its time to say goodbye to “This issue” and “Photonics at NPG”. At the same time, we’ve expanded our Technology Focus supplement in 2009 with longer, industry-perspective pieces; a double-page spread of research highlights; and the addition of a profile piece describing the activities of a young, emerging firm in the relevant area. The aim is to provide a more concentrated and in-depth insight into an important technology within photonics that has a strong application and industrial focus. In 2009, we will be running four such Technology Focus supplements on the topics of semiconductor light sources, materials processing, imaging and organic photonics. The first of these — semiconductor light sources — appears this month and brings together a collection of articles on the topics of quantum cascade lasers (QCLs), long-wavelength vertical-cavity surface-emitting lasers, quantum-dot lasers and tapered-laser diodes, as well as an update on the business and product news in the sector.

Following the positive feedback on our August 2008 special focus on slow light, we have plans for several more focus issues in 2009, and of course we will continue our programme of regular review articles throughout the year.

We are also busy with preparations for another Nature Photonics conference that will take place in Tokyo on 20–22 October 2009 on future perspectives for photovoltaics. This will be our second event and follows our successful 2007 conference on the future of optical communications. A website for the 2009 event is currently being designed, and we will update you when it’s ready and the programme of speakers has been finalized."

Nature Photonics journal homepage.

Guide to authors of Nature Photonics.

Nature Photonics focus archive.

Nature Genetics on teamwork and consortia

For the genetics field as well as others, an increasing number of research papers are the products of research consortia. In its January Editorial, Nature Genetics (41, 1; 2009) reports on how the journal is coping with the effects of team knowledge production on publication, and advises authors of what they can do to expedite the publication of their work.

One of several points made in the Editorial is that “Scientific productivity is rapidly increasing thanks to collaboration, and this has created a greater need for communication and coordination. In response, publishers have now begun to offer researchers customized unique contributor identification services such as ”https://www.researcherid.com/“>ResearcherID. However, we recognize that it would be unrealistic to expect something as central as individual identity and reputation to be definitively provided or controlled by any organization. What is really needed is a database or convention of online contributor identity, controlled by knowledge producers themselves, a service that records consortium membership with dates of joining and leaving, roles within consortia and authoring groups, and funding sources.”

Nature Genetics guide to authors.

The Nature journals’ policies on authorship.

A single author identification system

An international author identification system could allow scientists to receive credit for all their scientific contributions and would solve the problem of identity in a world of limited surnames. This is the premise of an article in the December issue of EMBO Reports (9, 1171-1174; 2008) by Howard Wolinsky. Not a new premise, by any means, but are we any closer to achieving this end? And what are the pros and cons?

Timo Hannay, publishing director of nature.com is quoted in the article: “I’d love a user of Nature.com to be able to click on an author’s name and to be able to see a list of everything that we publish by them. And that kind of thing, which seems really trivial, should be very straightforward, but actually isn’t because we don’t have identifiers associated with them … We’ve got a world in which scientists have assigned numbers to all kinds of things: to genes, to species, to stars, to molecules, to the articles they write. The one thing they left out was themselves…..A global author ID does bring you the same benefits that you already have from [a] unique article ID, and you can locate an article very quickly and easily online if you know what its DOI [digital object identifier] is.”

The article goes on to describe some of the challenges and complexities of this apparently simple goal (which is, in fact, anything but simple). One issue is whether people would want to assign themselves such a number in principle, given concerns about privacy and possible misuses. Another is the extent of cooperation that would be required by many publishers, databases, institutions and other organizations, as well as the interoperability of their technical systems.

Wolinsky concludes: “In the end, whether an author ID system is a universal database or a connected and compatible network of databases, it has to serve the needs of the scientific community. There is a careful balance to be struck between giving credit where credit is due and knowing everything about everyone. Where that balance lies will be up to the community and those who collaborate to make such a system a reality.”

Authors on authorship, collaboration and output measures

Publishing a paper in a journal has traditionally marked the end of a research project, but increasing numbers of academics are becoming interested in the publication process itself, according to the Editorial in the November issue of Nature Nanotechnology (3, 633; 2008). Many of these ‘papers about papers’ are concerned with citations and impact factors — researchers looking to get more citations for their papers are advised to write longer papers, work in teams or write the first paper on a topic (references in the Editorial). However, other authors have started to look behind the scenes at issues such as the changing nature of collaboration. The Editorial goes on to discuss some of these issues, including the h-index, a relatively recent yet controversial method of assessing a scientist’s output.

Previous Nautilus posts about the h-index.

Previous Nautilus posts about authorship.

Previous Nautilus posts about citation analysis.

Science students need artistic skills

This is the text of a Correspondence from Nature 455, 1175 (2008) by Kenneth R. Jolls of Iowa State University:

In your ‘Big data’ issue, Felice Frankel and Rosalind Reid call for an “investment in visual communication training for young scientists” to prepare them for modern methods of data representation (‘Distilling meaning from data’ Nature 455, 30; 2008). But the problem goes deeper than that.

Graphic artists who collaborate with scientists have often been shaped by the other of C. P. Snow’s ‘two cultures’. Although well-intentioned, many artists’ understanding of basic science is inadequate for meaningful participation in high-level technical work. Cognitive art is like commercial art and technical writing: it has never garnered respect from the artistic establishment, and its practitioners are left to fend for themselves.

From the start of schooling, distinctions are made between students with a talent for science and those with leanings towards the arts. In our technology-focused society, science receives more attention and an emphasis that does not include visual-thinking skills. Calculus, for example, is learned through symbolic operations, but portraying those procedures by using curves and surfaces and tangents and intercepts is typically considered to be an unnecessary frill.

Thus the two cultures diverge, and if we try to reassemble them later to let one benefit the other, we have serious difficulties: the world views don’t match. Subjective ideas can be stifled by objective thought but, by the same token, physical reality can be mismanaged by well-meaning attempts at creativity.

We must indeed invest in visualization skills for science-bound students, but there should be a parallel path for science-illustrators-to-be to learn the basics of physics, chemistry and mathematics. Collaborators who understand each other’s language have a much better chance of finding the common ground they need for the cooperation they seek.

Nature Methods, looking back and moving forward

The fourth anniversary of Nature Methods’ arrival on the publishing scene and a change in leadership offer an opportunity for reflection and editorial fine-tuning, as described in the journal’s November Editorial (5, 911; 2008).

From the Editorial: “When Nature Methods made its debut in October 2004, just over 4 years ago, it was an anxious but exciting time for our founding chief editor Veronique Kiermer and manuscript editors Nicole Rusk and Daniel Evanko. We were all novices at scientific publishing and more comfortable calibrating a pipette than editing a fledgling journal.” The Editorial goes on to outline developments and other changes at the journal since then. Veronique is taking on the role of publisher for Nature Methods and Nature Protocols, and Daniel is taking over as Chief Editor of Nature Methods. Reviews, Perspectives and Research Highlights are to be expanded, while the Protocols section is closing. (Authors are encouraged to submit their protocols to the online publication Nature Protocols.) The Editorial concludes: “We hope that our journal has helped dispel the notion that methods are less important than results and deserving only of small print at the end of a paper. Debunking this myth has been and will continue to be our main mission. We will persist in our efforts to bring you, every month, a journal that allows methods to be featured prominently in their own right—as the cornerstones upon which results are based.”

Nature Methods guide to authors.

How to submit to Nature Methods.

Aims and scope of the journal.

Methagora, the Nature Methods blog.

Two million hours of science

G. N. Greaves of Aberystwyth Univesity and co-authors write in a Commentary in Nature Materials 7, 827-839 (2008):

“The world’s first dedicated X-ray synchrotron radiation storage ring, the Synchrotron Radiation Source or SRS (Fig. 1), is closing down this autumn after 27 years of operation. Designed, built and commissioned at Daresbury Laboratory in less than four years, it thrust the United Kingdom into a world-leading position in 19801, delivering the first uninterrupted beams of intense X-rays. Since then, the use of synchrotron X-rays has led to major advances in both fundamental and applied science, which at the SRS has ranged from the structure of glass to catalysts in operation, from the crystallography of proteins to elements at high pressure, and from semiconductor surfaces to the magnetism of atomic layers, to take just a few examples. The SRS has had a substantial role in what has truly become a revolution in characterization science. With over 5,000 papers published, research and instrumentation from the SRS continues to influence facilities across the world.”

The authors review the range of fields of science in which the SRS has made significant contributions, calculating that since 1981 “the SRS has served a staggering 11,000 individual users from 25 countries, and been the training ground of over 4,000 doctorate students and 2,000 post-doctorate researchers. With materials research making up around 40% of this research programme, the legacy of the SRS in this field is enormous. We have picked out examples where the international impact of the SRS has been particularly impressive, but there are many more: developments in industrial materials, biomaterials, electrochemical materials and, very recently, heritage materials. The international conference series, ‘Synchrotron Radiation in Materials Science’, which began in Chester, UK, in 1994, charts this progress and involvement of the SRS over the years. Indeed, many of the new concepts, experiments, theory and instrumentation in X-ray science owe their origins to research at Daresbury, starting 27 years ago when the SRS heralded the age of dedicated synchrotron radiation.

It is worth reflecting on the relatively short time taken for authorization to build the SRS by the then Science Research Council. The decision in the late 1970s followed the briefest of approval procedures compared with the current process-driven practice of seeking the widest consultation before dipping into the public purse. If the gut-reaction decision to build the SRS had taken any longer, it would have jeopardized its place as a world-first and, more importantly, the confidence to build new science over the next generation — much of which has been internationally leading and continues to influence the synchrotron radiation community worldwide.”

Digital identifiers could keep up with authors’ moves

Raf Aerts of the Division of Forest, Nature and Landscape, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, writes in Nature Correspondence (454, 575; 2008):

Litera scripta manet: ‘written words will endure’. But not, it seems, in the case of the e-mail addresses of corresponding authors in the scientific literature.

To investigate the survival rate of author e-mail addresses, I sent an e-mail to the first one hundred corresponding authors of peer-reviewed papers whose addresses were returned in a Google Scholar search for 2007 and 2003. Roughly one out of five messages was undeliverable in 2008 (from 2007: 17%; 2003: 25%), indicating that those e-mail addresses were no longer valid.

E-mail addresses of scientists, particularly those without tenure, are volatile. Researchers leave behind a trail of obsolete e-mail addresses, phone numbers and fax numbers in the printed literature.

Unique digital author identifiers, as proposed in Correspondence (Nature 453, 979; 2008), could be linked to up-to-date e-mail addresses and other contact information. This would increase the traceability of authors, facilitate scientific networking, and even speed up the peer-review process.

Digital identifiers work for articles, so why not for authors?

Raf Aerts of the Katholieke Universiteit Leuven writes in Correspondence in Nature (453, 979; 2008):

Several Correspondences, including ‘Give south Indian authors their true names’ (Nature 452, 530; 2008) and ‘Name variations can hit citation rankings’ (Nature 453, 450; 2008), have illustrated difficulties in identifying authors and their papers, citations and h-index.

In an academic world in which decisions on promotion and funding often depend on the applicant’s scientific impact, an incorrect publication or citation record in an online database can be very inconvenient. Scopus and Thomson’s Web of Science, which make available abstract and citation databases, acknowledge the issue and have come up with solutions: the Author Identifier and ResearcherID, respectively.

These systems assign an identifying code to each author. Unfortunately, a single author can have more than one Author Identifier in Scopus (I am cryptically known as 7006716603 and 16551750300). And as only invited researchers can register for a number, ResearcherID is not yet used as a unique author key in the Web of Science — making it difficult to differentiate me from a highly cited ecologist from the Netherlands, despite the ‘Distinct Author Sets’ feature.

If it is possible to have DOIs for objects (or, so they say, enough IPv6 addresses for every molecule on Earth), why is it so difficult to implement DAIs for authors?

(See the author and reviewers’ website for more about DOIs, or digital object identifers.)

Location of authorship and quality in nanotechnology research

According to the Editorial in the June issue of Nature Nanotechnology 3, 309 (2008), “when the papers published so far in Nature Nanotechnology are classified according to the country in which the corresponding author was based at the time, we find that 47.6% of them come from the US, followed by 8% from the UK, 7.4% from Japan and 6.7% from Germany.

Classifying papers according to the affiliation of the corresponding author is clearly an approximation, but given the fact that papers can contain ten or more authors with affiliations in three or more countries, it is necessary to make such approximations if we want to understand which areas of the world are strongest” in a particular discipline.

The Editorial goes on to explain some of its “authorship” assumptions used for its analysis of several journals that publish high-quality research in the nanotechnology, leading to the conclusion that “although the number of nanotechnology papers published by Chinese researchers is increasing rapidly, the US and Europe continue to lead in terms of quality.”