Harvard adopts opt-out open-access policy

From Nature 451, 879 (2008):

Harvard University has adopted guidelines under which the ‘final drafts’ of academic papers written by researchers at its Faculty of Arts and Sciences will automatically be published on the university’s website, unless the authors request a waiver. Immediate open access to papers could conflict with the copyright policies of many journals including Cell, Nature and Science.

Many institutions keep open-access repositories of papers but the decision makes Harvard the first US university to sign up to default open-access publishing for its research staff. Although the University of California has toyed with the idea for years, it has yet to agree on a policy.

Stuart Shieber, the computer scientist at Harvard who proposed the scheme, says that any request for an exemption will be granted. The university has not yet worked out how to define what constitutes a ‘final’ draft of a scholarly paper, nor come up with a time limit for submission.

Critics of open-access policies worry that highly selective journals with large readerships will suffer, and that non-peer-reviewed research will become more prominent.

A longer version of this article is available at Nature News.

There is also an online debate on the Harvard announcement in the Publishing in the New Millennium forum at Nature Network, with several updates and links to further information.

Expanded licence for reuse of genome papers

From an Editorial in today’s (6 December) issue of Nature (450, 762; 2007):

Although Nature and the Nature journals are built on a business model funded by subscribers and other sources of revenue, various initiatives have been implemented to enhance the accessibility of the research papers published in these journals.

They have long been freely available to researchers in the 100 or so poorest countries through the World Health Organization’s Hinari initiative and others like it. Machine access is being enhanced by the open text-mining initiative of the Nature Publishing Group (NPG). Preprints of original versions of papers can be deposited in arXiv and Nature Precedings without compromising their acceptability for publication. And final authors’ versions of papers can be deposited in PubMed Central and other public servers from six months after publication. Authors retain copyright of their work, whereas NPG retains the licence to publish it.

For many years, a more generous arrangement has been made for papers reporting full genome sequences. (The paper reporting the sequence and analysis of 12 species of Drosophila is the most recent example, see Nature 450, 203; 2007). These papers are freely accessible on NPG’s website from the moment of publication. This recognizes a consistent character of ‘genome’ papers: they represent the completion of a key and fundamental research resource, describing and reflecting on what has been revealed but not usually providing insights into mechanism. Although some papers in other disciplines might also be characterized in this way, the fundamental character of the genome has led NPG to make a systematic exception.

In the continuing drive to make papers as accessible as possible, NPG is now introducing a ‘creative commons’ licence for the reuse of such genome papers. The licence allows non-commercial publishers, however they might be defined, to reuse the pdf and html versions of the paper. In particular, users are free to copy, distribute, transmit and adapt the contribution, provided this is for non-commercial purposes, subject to the same or similar licence conditions and due attribution.

In 1996, as human genome sequencing was getting under way, leading players stated: “It was agreed that all human genomic sequence information, generated by centres funded for large-scale human sequencing, should be freely available and in the public domain in order to encourage research and development and to maximise its benefit to society”. These principles have continued to guide the field, and NPG has consistently made genome papers freely available in keeping with them. This new licence allows us to formalize the arrangement.

New standard for indexing by search engines

Via an industry press release, I learn that a new standard for search-engine indexing has just (29 November) been launched, called the Automated Content Access Protocol (ACAP). This standard has been devised by publishers in collaboration with search engines to “revolutionise” (the word used in the press release) the creation, dissemination and use of copyright- and licence-protected content on the internet .

According to the release, ACAP is an open, non-proprietary standard through which publishers, societies, institutions and other content providers can communicate permission for access and use to online intermediaries. ACAP provides a framework that will allow any publisher to express access and use policies in a language that search engines’ robot “spiders” can be taught to understand, hence making more content available to users through search engines. Members of ACAP can be seen here.

New phase for environmental research literature project

Via the SciDev.Net website, I read that a new phase of the international initiative ‘Online Access to Research in the Environment’ (OARE) was launched on 6 November. In the first phase of the project last year, institutions from 72 countries subscribed. Now, interested institutions from another 36 developing countries will have access to an environmental and related sciences research database.

The United Nations Environment Program (UNEP) and Yale University sponsor the public-private consortium initiative. Around 350 publishing and society partners also support it, including Nature Publishing Group journals.

Primary research papers and other content in our journals are made freely available online to readers in countries that are members of HINARI, AGORA and OARE, greatly extending the reach of the papers as well as providing information in a timely fashion to people who might not otherwise be able to obtain it or obtain it promptly.

SciDev.Net is an independent online science and development network providing news, views and information about science, technology and the developing world. It is a free access website and features several articles a week from Nature, selected by the SciDev.Net editors.

US Congress vote on NIH publishing options

From the current issue of Nature, News in Brief (Nature 450, 148; 2007).

“US investigators funded by the National Institutes of Health (NIH) may soon be compelled to publish only in journals that make their research papers freely available within one year of publication.

Congress is this week expected to take final votes on a bill incorporating this directive. The measure is contained in a spending bill that boosts the biomedical agency’s effective budget by 3.1%, to $29.8 billion in 2008.

President George W. Bush has vowed to veto the bill, which will fund the Department of Health and Human Services and other agencies, because it includes what he calls “irresponsible and excessive” levels of spending.

But congressional Democrats have attached to the measure an unrelated but politically popular bill funding the Department of Veterans Affairs. They hope that this will generate the two-thirds support needed in both houses of Congress to override a presidential veto.

The open-access requirement in the bill would apply only during fiscal year 2008; it would need to be renewed in yearly spending bills in the future.”

When a manuscript is accepted for publication in a Nature or other NPG journal, authors are encouraged to submit their version of the accepted paper (the unedited manuscript) to their funding body’s archive, for public release six months after publication. Nature journals are hence already more than fulfiling the conditions in the proposed bill. In addition, we encourage authors to archive this version of the manuscript in their institution’s repositories and, if they wish, on their personal websites, also six months after the original publication. Authors should cite the publication reference and DOI number on any deposited version, and provide a link from it to the URL of the published article on the journal’s website. See here for details of our licence policies.

Molecular Systems Biology’s new author licence

Via Seven Stones blog:

Molecular Systems Biology (published by a partnership of the European Molecular Biology Organisation and Nature Publishing Group) has changed its publishing licence for all articles accepted after 1 October 2007 (see updated instruction to authors). The new procedure allows the journal’s authors to choose between two Creative Commons licences: one that allows the work to be adapted by users (“attribution-noncommerical-share”: by-nc-sa), the other that does not allow the work to be modified (“attribution-noncommercial-no derivative”: by-nc-nd). The first articles to be published under the new licence are appearing online at the beginning of this month. The journal’s content is therefore not only freely available to all, but also authors can decide to make their research fully open for reuse and adaptation.

Thomas Lemberger, EMBO editor of Molecular Systems Biology, who runs the Seven Stones blog, notes that he initially wanted to make this announcement only after the first paper published under the new licence (accepted after 1 October) had appeared online, but in light of a recent Editorial in PLoS Biology (“When Is Open Access Not Open Access?”), reviewing in detail the subtleties of publishing licenses and the concept of “open access”, he bought forward the announcement of Molecular Systems Biology’s new policy. “Unfortunately, this Editorial, at the time of its publication (16 October), included erroneous information on Molecular Systems Biology, given that we had updated our policy on 1 October.”, Thomas writes. “In any case, it is somewhat ironic that MacCallum chose to stigmatize Molecular Systems Biology as an example of a journal that “promulgates” confusion about open access. As it turns out, Molecular Systems Biology is dedicated to the concept of making research freely available and to engage authors themselves in decisions that would achieve this goal with their own research. It is in this spirit of openness and respect for authors that we have recently adapted our license to publish.”

NPG and Portico digital archive

Portico and Nature Publishing Group (NPG) have signed an agreement to preserve Nature and all the other NPG journals and online databases across the life, physical and applied sciences and clinical medicine, to ensure that these publications are preserved and available for future readers.

Portico began as the Electronic-Archiving Initiative launched by JSTOR in 2002 with a grant from the Andrew W. Mellon foundation to extend the foundation’s E-journal archiving programme. The goal was to build a sustainable electronic archiving model: for more than two years, project staff developed technology and discussed approaches with publishers and libraries. In 2004, the Electronic-Archiving Initiative became a part of Ithaka Harbors, Inc., a non-profit organization with a mission to accelerate the productive uses of information technologies for the benefit of higher education around the world. The electronic archiving service, known as Portico, was then developed and launched in 2005, with support from JSTOR, Ithaka, the Library of Congress and the Andrew W. Mellon foundation. The service aims to be a permanent electronic archive of scholarly journals. With the addition of the NPG titles, there are more than 6,200 publications in the archive.

Access to the literature, Nature and PRISM

From Nature 449, 13 (2007):

The Association of American Publishers* is taking part in an initiative to protest against what it calls government interference in the scholarly communication process.

Some groups and legislators are pushing for all publicly financed research to be made freely available to the public. Many traditional publishers object, and some have used aggressive tactics to fight the movement (see Nature 445, 347; 2007).

The initiative — called the Partnership for Research Integrity in Science and Medicine — says that it wants to provide the public with more information about scholarly publishing. One of its principles is that “society is best served by sustainable business models and reasonable copyright protections”. News of the group’s formation did not go down well in the blogosphere, where a number of critics attacked it for implying that open-access publication harms peer review. (*Nature’s US division, Nature America, is a member of the Association of American Publishers.)

Timo Hannay, Nature Publishing Group’s web publishing director, writes on Nascent blog: “Although Nature America is a member of the ”https://www.publishers.org/“>AAP, we are not involved in ”https://www.prismcoalition.org/“>PRISM and we have not been consulted about it. NPG has supported self-archiving in various ways (from submitting manuscripts to ”https://www.pubmedcentral.nih.gov/“>PubMed Central on behalf of our authors to establishing ”https://precedings.nature.com/“>Nature Precedings), and our policies are already compliant with the proposed NIH mandate.” The Nature journals’ policies on archiving and preprint servers can be found at our author and reviewers’ website.

Timo’s further thoughts and opinions about PRISM, “open-access” publishing and the manners of some individuals involved, are provided in his excellent Nascent post, which I recommend you read if you have any interest in this topic. There is a comment thread at the Nascent posting, to which you are welcome to add, or you may comment here.

August editorials on sharing, naming and credit

The Nature journals this month (August) feature several editorials on the publishing process. A short round up (with links) follows:

Nature Genetics (39, 931; 2007), in ‘Compete, collaborate, compel’, calls for procedures for microattribution to be established by journals and databases so that data producers have an overwhelming incentive to deposit their results in public databases and thereby to receive quantitative credit for the use of every published data accession.

In ‘Got data?’, Nature Neuroscience (10, 931; 2007 ) points out that data sharing is not only good citizenship for researchers, but is also required by funding agencies and many journals. The scientific community needs to develop better incentives to encourage compliance and reward those who share.

And in ‘Name that gene!’, Nature Structural & Molecular Biology (14, 681; 2007) warns that scientists coin new terms, or neologisms, at a tremendous pace, but name choice can have unforeseen results.

Molecular Systems Biology July issue

The July issue of Molecular Systems Biology, NPG’s open access journal published in partnership with EMBO (European Molecular Biology Organisation), is live. This month’s featured article is Systematic evaluation of objective functions for predicting intracellular fluxes in Escherichia coli, by Robert Schuetz, Lars Kuepfer & Uwe Sauer (Molecular Systems Biology 3, 119; 2007), with an accompanying News and Views article by Jens Nielsen (Molecular Systems Biology 3, 126; 2007). See the journal’s home page for more research papers, News and Views, Perspectives and Editorials, as well as links to systems biology papers published in the Nature journals.