Momentum and meritocracy?

Open Access as a model for the future? So writes Evelyn Harvey in a news report at Nature Network. Is open access publishing an unstoppable force? Does it face immovable objects in the shape of publication costs, quality control and copyright? These were questions addressed by the third Lonon open research conference last month.

The successes of open access were highlighted by some speakers: it makes research available without access barriers or subscription costs. BioMedCentral and others believe they have shown that it can be a strong publishing business model. There were also various demonstrations of personalised readership profiles that can be created using metrics such as number of times a paper is downloaded.

The problems include the removal of the main source of income for scientific societies, and a possible compromise in quality via self-publication and inadequate review.

Evelyn writes that most delegates agreed that open access is here to stay, but that big challenges lay ahead. As one researcher said when confronted with the copyright risks: “My problem isn’t plagiarism, it’s obscurity!”.

Nature’s two extensive debates on access to the literature, including commissioned articles from a range of perspectives, can be read here (free access!).

Access to journals in developing world

More than 100 STM publishers, including Nature Publishing Group, and three UN organizations (WHO, FAO and UNEP) have announced the extension of programmes that provide free, or almost free, access to online peer-reviewed journals to several developing nations that lack access to information and training. Microsoft has also announced its support of technical assistance to enhance access to online research for scientists, policymakers, and librarians in these countries.

The three sister programmes – HINARI (research on health), AGORA (research on agriculture) and OARE (research in the environment) – provide online research access to more than one hundred of the world’s poorest countries. All three programmes have official commitment from their partners until 2015, marking the target for reaching the Millennium Development Goals.

In a World Health Organisation (WHO) survey conducted in 2000, researchers and academics in developing countries ranked access to subscription based journals as one of their most pressing problems. In countries with per capita income of less than $1000 per annum, 56 per cent of academic institutions surveyed had no current subscriptions to international journals. These three programmes aim to solve this problem and make research as easily accessible in countries such as Sierra Leone as it is in the United States.

Timo Hannay and the Daily Transcript on “the web opportunity”

In this post on Nascent, NPG’s web publishing and science blog, Timo Hannay provides a draft of his recent article in STM news : Nascent: Foo and beyond. The whole section is worth reading (and there is a good graphic of the opportunities provided by the “scientific web”), but here is an excerpt:

“The idea that everyone can now do their own publishing, making publishers superfluous, is misguided. But publishers do need to adapt. Online communities don’t just happen, they require initiators, motivators, organisers, moderators, summarisers and guides. They also need trust systems based on user identification and reputation. In many ways, these, too, are traditional publishing roles, but they require new skills. Writers and editors now need to double as moderators and hosts. Publishers need to become adept at mitigating gaming and spamming of their systems, and at monetizing web traffic rather than selling subscriptions. On top of that, they need to become better at cooperating — with each other and with other organisations outside the industry. This particularly applies to online interoperability (even horror of horrors, with competitors), which is a positive-sum game that can benefit all participants. CrossRef has blazed a trail in this area, and we should build in its success.

Above all, publishers need to be leading the online charge, not following the scientists we serve. We are the information dissemination experts, so if we aren’t pushing the boundaries and testing what’s possible in this new world then we’re not merely missing out, we’re also not doing our jobs. Cynics will point out that most apparent ‘opportunities’ are a long way from turning a profit, and many probably never will. They’re right. Do any of the STM projects I’ve mentioned above make a lot of money? No. But are they representative of the future of scientific communication, and do they provide a platform on which to build information businesses of the future? You’d better believe it.”

In a similar vein, Alex Palazzo of The Daily Transcript blog wrote about Nature Publishing Group’s “game plan” as he calls it, regarding science publishing and web “2.0” (the social, interactive web). The post arose from Alex’s attendance at Nature Network Boston’s pub night. This post, and the lively set of comments accompanying it, range over the the topic of the value of publishing in a journal, “open access” publication, and whether the unit of publication will become the paper itself rather than the journal in which it is published.

The unsung scientific record

In which I contemplate the unsung scientific record – Mind the Gap – Jennifer Rohn’s blog on Nature Network

There is a very chatty conversaton happening at the above post on MInd the Gap, Jennifer Rohn’s Nature Network blog. Jennifer’s post is about the plea In Nature by Sydney Brenner and Richard Roberts to scientists to save their notebooks and correspondence and donate them to historians.

Jennifer writes: "Of course I agree that such materials should be preserved, which is probably why I can’t bring myself to throw away the two boxes of gently moulding lab notebooks, spanning thirteen years of research, stashed up in the loft. I’m sure these are not the papers that Brenner and Roberts had in mind, though – they want to preserve the detritus of the Watsons and Cricks of this world, not of ordinary research folk like me.

But then I got to wondering. Why not? My lab notebooks might make pretty compelling reading to some future historian starved for scraps of how 99.9% of (non-celebrity) researchers spent their days and nights in the lab. Why not document the parade of meaningless or ambiguous data that make up most researchers’ records? The ‘non-Eureka moments’, if you will? "

Join in the conversation here or at the Mind the Gap post’s comments section, which has taken some fascinating tracks along avenues of clear communication and the virtue of electronic notebooks as well as the importance of a good cup of coffee.

Tim Berners Lee on video

Web inventor Tim Berners-Lee Unplugged: Semantic Web better than APIs for data access

Via Berlind’s Testbed blog, Sir Tim Berners-Lee, inventor of the world-wide web, received the 2007 lifetime achievement award of the Massachusetts Innovation and Technology Exchange in Boston on 5 June. After the reception to honour his achievement, “Sir Tim” (as David Berlind calls him) answered questions about the semantic web, data access and standards. The session is captured on video at the link above.

British Library report on archive digitization

Publisher Digitisation Service

The British Library has just launched its Publisher Digitisation Service (see link above), which, it says, is the first fully integrated journals digitization service on the market. One of the greatest challenges for a publisher undertaking a digitization of its archives is finding content — one publisher had to locate 75% of the content for its programme from third parties. The British Library has an unrivalled collection of serial content and is aiming to save publishers time and money in locating material and providing it in online, searchable format. At the webpage linked to above are more details of the service, and a link to a downloadable PDF of the white paper ‘Journal backfiles in scientific publishing.’

All the Nature journals have searchable online archives back to issue 1 available via each journal’s website, except for the oldest, Nature. Nature’s online, searchable archive currently extends back to 1950 but will be complete to issue 1 (4 November 1869) by the end of this year. In the meantime, the first issue of the journal is available online at the “about the journal” page of the Nature website.

A new look for chemical information

In its June Editorial, which is freely available, Nature Chemical Biology (3, 297;2007) reports on new online features to enhance interdisciplinary communication and to increase the accessibility of chemical information for readers.

Most published chemical content is traditionally contained in the schemes, figures and tables of scientific papers. Authors also use abbreviations, acronyms or numbering schemes to identify specific molecules. Though these shorthand notations simplify the presentation of chemical information, they tend to make chemical papers less accessible to the general reader. This is a concern for chemical biology articles, which are intended to attract an interdisciplinary audience. Moreover, since the advent of the Internet, the way by which scientists acquire scientific information has changed. Though some scientists continue to read journal articles in print, most turn to the online HTML and PDF versions of published manuscripts. This expanded use of electronic resources offers an excellent opportunity to make chemical information more accessible and user-friendly to readers of scientific papers.

The Editorial provides details of the resources now available to authors and readers, and asks for your evaluation of what has been done so far, and your ‘wish list’ for new chemical or biological functionality that will foster communication and collaboration between researchers at the interface of chemistry and biology.

Update on Live Search Academic

Microsoft’s scholarly search engine, Live Search Academic, has been available in a beta (trial) version for more than a year. Launched 18 months after Google Scholar, it has a lot of catching up to do in order to make researchers aware of it and want to use it in preference to other search services. To this end, it has expanded the range of articles in its index from computing and physics only, to all disciplines. When it launched in 2006, it contained around 7 million articles; now it contains about 40 million.

Unlike Google Scholar, Live Search Academic content is not scraped remotely from the web, but uses feeds from CrossRef, HighWire, JSTOR, PubMed and others, making it part of the network of connected scholarly information. By so doing, it hopes to have better relevancy in search query returns, because the engine is indexing a regularly updated feed, is flexible and able to adapt immediately to new citation links and taxonomies. Microsoft is also aware that, as the amount of web content grows ever larger, there is a danger that services like Google Scholar will get bogged down with the sheer quantity of information that needs to be signposted. Google Scholar brings academic researchers more results, but Microsoft´s hope is that Live Search Academic results will be more relevant to users.

HINARI now includes 2,500 institutions

The HINARI Access to Research Initiative of the World Health Organisation has announced the registration of the 2,500th institution to access free or low-cost online medical journals and databases. These publicly funded and non-profit institutions include universities, medical schools, hospitals and research institutes drawn from 109 developing countries. Through HINARI, they are able to access 3,750 journals online from 100 different publishers covering medicine, nursing and related health and social sciences – including Nature, the Nature journals and all journals published by Nature Publishing Group.

HINARI facilitates teaching, research and the delivery of health care in the developing world while helping researchers in these countries to get their work published and made available to a wider international audience. Access is free for institutions in countries with a GNP of less than $1000 per year while there is a small charge for countries with a GNP of $1000$3000. The income generated is used for local training initiatives.

Launched in January 2002, HINARI Access to Research Initiative is managed by the World Health Organisation in partnership with The International Association of Scientific, Technical and Medical publishers, 100 publishers and Yale University Library. The HINARI website is the main port of call for thousands of librarians, scientists, students, medics and healthcare researchers in the world’s poorest countries. They benefit from free access to the leading international biomedical peer-reviewed journals and other information resources.

There are similar initatives for agricultural research (AGORA); and climate and environmental research (OARE). Nature and all Nature Publishing Group journals are included in these programmes.

Geological Society opens up Lyell Collection

The Geological Society of London, one of the world’s oldest national scientific and professional societies for earth scientists, is opening up its archive of published material free to anyone for four weeks from 17 May to 18 June.

The Lyell Collection represents the digitized content of the society’s extensive range of publications, covering journal and book articles from the mid 1800s to the present. The Lyell Collection was created to mark the Geological Society of London’s 200th anniversary, and is one of the largest integrated collections of online earth science literature.

Although a subscription will be required for full access from June 18, many aspects of the service will remain entirely free for public use. This includes a sophisticated search functionality, access to summaries and abstracts and e-mail alerts about new content as it is added.