Video journal to be indexed in Medline and PubMed

The Journal of Visualized Experiments (JoVE) has announced that its online video protocols will be indexed in the popular US National Library of Medicine repositories MEDLINE and PubMed.

Founder and chief executive Moshe Pritsker views the MEDLINE–PubMed listing as a sign that the scientific community has accepted video-based publications. “It was a very important decision for us, and for scientific publishing,” he says.

Since JoVE was founded in 2006 with support from an angel investor, the journal has published more than 200 videos, most produced by professional videographers. It aims to improve the reproducibility of scientific results by using videos to clarify subtle experimental details. The journal was itself an experiment in video publishing and remains the only video-based scientific journal.

From Nature 455, 13 (2008).

Nature’s special issue on ‘big data’

The Big Data special package of articles in this week’s issue of Nature (4 September 2008) looks at how massive influxes of data are changing the way science is done in many fields, and includes a feature story on ‘Wikiomics’ that might be of particular interest to the scientists who work with “web 2.0” tools. Coping with floods of data is now one of science’s biggest challenges, so the Nature special issue assess the need to complement smart science with smart searching; looks at what the next Google will be; interviews the pioneering biologists who are trying to use wiki-type web pages to manage and interpret data; and recalls that the first mass data crunchers were not computers, but the remarkable women of Harvard’s Observatory. All the articles, as well as downloadable PDFs of the print versions, are free online for two weeks from the publication date. We encourage you to download everything you are interested in—and then to spread the word to friends and colleagues about what you like (and don’t like!) via email, blog, by commenting online at the Nature website, or other means. And of course, Nature always welcomes Correspondence submissions.

The contents of the Big Data ‘special’ in full:

Editorial: Community cleverness required

Researchers need to adapt their institutions and practices in response to torrents of new data — and need to complement smart science with smart searching.

Special Report: The next Google

Ten years ago this month, Google’s first employee turned up at the garage where the search engine was originally housed. What technology at a similar early stage today will have changed our world as much by 2018? Nature asked some researchers and business people to speculate — or lay out their wares. Their responses are wide ranging, but one common theme emerges: the integration of the worlds of matter and information, whether it be by the blurring of boundaries between online and real environments, touchy-feely feedback from a phone or chromosomes tucked away on databases.

Party of One column: Data wrangling

Collecting and releasing environmental data have stirred up controversy in Washington, says David Goldston, and will continue to do so.

Features: Welcome to the petacentre

What does it take to store bytes by the tens of thousands of trillions? Cory Doctorow meets the people and machines for which it’s all in a day’s work.

Features: Wikiomics

Pioneering biologists are trying to use wiki-type web pages to manage and interpret data, reports Mitch Waldrop. But will the wider research community go along with the experiment?

Commentary: How do your data grow?

Scientists need to ensure that their results will be managed for the long haul. Maintaining data takes big organization, says Clifford Lynch.

Books & Arts: Distilling meaning from data

Buried in vast streams of data are clues to new science. But we may need to craft new lenses to see them, explain Felice Frankel and Rosalind Reid.

Essay: The Harvard computers

The first mass data crunchers were people, not machines. Sue Nelson looks at the discoveries and legacy of the remarkable women of Harvard’s Observatory.

Review: The future of biocuration

To thrive, the field that links biologists and their data urgently needs structure, recognition and support. Doug Howe, Maria Costanzo, Petra Fey, Takashi Gojobori, Linda Hannick, Winston Hide, David P. Hill, Renate Kania, Mary Schaeffer, Susan St Pierre, Simon Twigger, Owen White & Seung Yon Rhee

Podcast Extra: Big Data

As Google celebrates its 10th anniversary, we find out how science is coping with massive datasets generated by unprecedented computing power. BoingBoing blogger Cory Doctorow tells us about his visits to the LHC data storage facility and the genome sequencing Sanger Centre.

Method of the Year 2008: cast your vote!

When the Nature Methods editors sat down last year to select a Method of the Year for 2007, it was with the firm intention of initiating a yearly tradition. This year, the editors are are asking for your opinion, so please nominate candidate methods as well as vote and comment on posted suggestions.

From the editorial in the September issue of Nature Methods (5, 749; 2008):

The Method of the Year event is a celebration of methods development and innovation because we think that methods developers should have their share of the limelight. It is also a fun opportunity to assemble Commentaries, technical information and news items about a method we consider particularly important among the developments that we, as editors, continuously observe across a broad range of disciplines. But we also wanted to take the pulse at the bench and see what you, with firsthand experience, think of recent methods developments. This online one-click voting and nomination process is your opportunity to speak up.

We are interested in methods that have come into their own in 2008 and have had a proven impact, but also in your views on burgeoning methods which, while they are not quite ready for prime time, are worth watching.

Cultural media at Nature Reviews Microbiology

Chris Condayan, manager of the Public Education Outreach Initiative at the American Society for Microbiology, writes an Editoral in the September issue of Nature Reviews Microbiology (6, 646; 2008) about how self-created audio and video content enable more microbiologists to share knowledge and news online. From his article:

As the science audiences for newspapers, radio and television decline, the future for audio and video podcasts, blogs and social networking looks bright. On the horizon we are starting to see the emergence of science-related social networks and a movement towards ‘open science’ that allows scientists and researchers to collaborate on projects, communicate results, share data and publish papers with the same recognition that is afforded to colleagues who publish in print journals. Specific details of how open science will work are still murky, and concerns over citation, peer review, accuracy, scooping and accountability resound even among its strongest supporters. But this has not stopped microbiologists from engaging with one another on wikis, such as EcoliWiki, TOPSAN or Proteopedia, or prevented thousands of scientists from sharing their poster presentations, lectures or laboratory methods through iTunes or video destination sites, such as YouTube, SciVee and JoVE.

Podcasting for audio or video is generally defined as episodic content that listeners or viewers can subscribe to for free and which they can consume at any time and on any device, whether it be a computer, iPod, mobile telephone or television set. Audio podcasts are easy and affordable to create, and can be used to make a radio-style show or to make lectures available to a wider audience. Uploading and sharing videos on websites such as YouTube, or creating a video podcast show, is more time consuming and requires more equipment and a video-editing software program.

Chris Condayan goes on to provide some examples of microbiologists who produce online resources to educate and promote microbiological research, and the MicrobeWorld sevice of the American Society for Microbiology, which includes the popular resources MicrobeWorld Radio and MicrobeWorld Video.

Changing the publication landscape with Nature Precedings

Nature Cell Biology wishes Nature Precedings a happy birthday in its July Editorial (Nature Cell Biology 10, 753; 2008), in the process taking stock of the usefulness of “web 2.0” publishing ventures to cell biologists (and other scientists).

Nature Precedings allows rapid posting of unpublished (and unreviewed) manuscripts, conference posters and slide presentations. Entries are subject-tagged, searchable and citable. Postings are screened by curators for scientific legitimacy, plagiarism and scope, but not peer-reviewed for novelty or data quality; commenting and voting by readers is encouraged.

The immediate question for most cell biologists and other scientists is whether posting material on a preprint sever is worth the risk of being scooped. Nature Cell Biology concludes that although many cell biologists are still wary of preprint servers, they could consider posting solid data that are not likely to be published in traditional journals because they are confirmatory or negative. Well-controlled negative data are immensely useful to colleagues, so documenting them in a citable form on a preprint server is a valuable community service.

Related posts:

Peer to Peer on the first year of Nature Precedings.

Nature Network post by Hilary Spencer of Nature Precedings.

Nature Network online discussion forum for the Nature Cell Biology editorial.

Futher information about Nature Precedings is available here.

Preservation of content in electronic journals

Via Knowledgespeak press release:

Two years after a meeting calling for urgent action to preserve scholarly e-journals, the results of a survey of 1,371 library directors of four-year colleges and universities in the United States have been released.

Most library directors who responded believe their own institution has a responsibility to take action to prevent intolerable loss of scholarly records. But although larger libraries support one or more e-journal preservation initiatives, most respondents from smaller libraries are yet to support any preservation effort and secure permanent access to e-journals for their institutions.

The survey, conducted by Portico and Ithaca, raises questions about how the responsibility for preservation of critical electronic resources should be supported by the community, even as electronic resources expenditures expand substantially at libraries across the spectrum. The organizers hope that the report will be a catalyst for leaders of libraries, consortia, and other organizations to provide a mechanism for digital preservation. The full report is available for download as a PDF. (A summary is available here.) Readers are also invited to share comments and reactions in the provided online discussion space.

Proposal for a centralized grant repository

Noam Y. Harel of Yale University writes in Nature’s Correspondence page (Nature 452, 409; 2008):

Writing grant proposals is difficult enough; keeping track of different deadlines makes for an endless cycle of procrastination and frantic preparation. The added stack of bureaucratic forms, with arcane variations from agency to agency, can tip one over the edge as a deadline nears.

Is it almost too obvious to wish for a centralized proposal repository? Investigators could submit proposals at any time, in a common format that highlights the science rather than obliterates it with red tape. Funding agencies could search the repository for proposals matching their interests. A minimum of bureaucratic information would be required up front. Budget details could be worked out between funding agencies and investigators as necessary.

Ideally, all proposals would be publicly accessible. However, most of the scientific community has not yet accepted the inevitable dawn of truly open science. Submissions to a central repository could therefore be made accessible only to funding agencies that agree to keep proposals private (unless a submitting investigator indicates a willingness to share his or her proposal publicly).

The repository would make life easier for scientists by eliminating the hassle of searching for suitable grant mechanisms and the stress of meeting various deadlines. It would make life easier for funding agencies by expanding the pool of applications from which to choose. Of course, the best proposals could attract offers from multiple agencies. Rather than forcing investigators to choose non-overlapping sources of funding for each project, why not use the repository to mediate shared funding agreements that could benefit everyone involved? In effect, it would serve as the mediator between grant-seekers and grant-providers.

In a world where eBay, Facebook and Google powerfully demonstrate the communal nature of the Web, it is a pity that scientists and funding agencies don’t have a similarly modern forum for matching their interests and offers.

Consistent guidelines for clinical interventions

An Institute of Medicine report recommends that the United States government create a programme to provide consistent guidelines for clinical interventions. The reliability of the guidelines will depend on the availability of the clinical data to be assessed, according to this month’s (March 2008) Editorial in Nature Medicine (14, 223; 2008).

The problem is that “Widespread regional variation in how health care providers treat some conditions in the United States reflects the sobering fact that, for many interventions, there is no consensus about what constitutes effective clinical care. Physicians and health care providers must try to make sense of innumerable and conflicting guidelines in order to choose the best available intervention for their patient. Scientific, systematic review of data from medical literature and clinical trials is crucial to forming a reliable evidence base of what actually works in health care. With this in mind, professional medical organizations, patient advocacy groups, government agencies and others have synthesized available data on the efficacy of particular interventions and have produced guidelines recommending certain courses of action for specific conditions. The problem is that there is no consensus among the approaches to systematic review, and, more troublesome, no clear understanding of the best methods for assessing the evidence.”

The Institute of Medicine has stepped in to recommend a plan to help resolve conflicting medical advice (reported in a news story at Nature Medicine 14, 226; 2008) by three methods: first, identify interventions that are priorities for evaluation; second, develop standardized and reliable methods for performing systematic reviews of all the available data about a given intervention; and third, develop standards for producing clinical guidelines. The Editorial discusses some of the practical difficulties, concluding that the Institute of Medicine report is an important step forward but will require legislation if it is to work.

Nature Methods recommends deposition of proteomics data

Starting this month (March 2008), Nature Methods strongly recommends deposition of proteomics data to public repositories before manuscript submission. From the Editorial in the March issue of the journal (Nat. Meth. 5, 209; 2008):

“Several proteomics data repositories are now available that differ in terms of their goals, structure and the formats they accept. They include ”https://www.ebi.ac.uk/pride">PRIDE, PeptideAtlas, Global Proteome Machine Database (gpmDB) and the file distribution system Tranche. The newest addition, Human Proteinpedia, is a community-based annotation tool that hosts experimental data (Nat. Biotechnol. 26, 164; 2008).

Importantly, the major database administrators have shown their willingness to work with users and with each other to facilitate data deposition. At this stage, the process can still be labor-intensive, but a repository like PRIDE provides extensive technical assistance. Under the umbrella of the ProteomExchange consortium, the major repositories are also devising ways to share their data in a collaborative fashion, capitalizing on their complementarities to minimize submission hassle while maximizing benefits.

We support these efforts and consider it premature to recommend a particular repository. Rather we will rely on community experience to determine which database or combination of databases emerges as the most useful. However, there are specific features that editors favor. In particular, we like the possibility currently offered by PRIDE and Human Proteinpedia to provide peer reviewers with access to datasets associated with a manuscript before public release, in an anonymous fashion, and to coordinate public release of the data with publication. "

Nature Methods welcomes comments on this Editorial, and the recommendations it makes, at the journal’s blog Methagora.

The Nature journals’ policies on data and materials availability, including links to editorials on these policies, can be found at the author and reviewers’ website.

Non-traditional publishing choices for biologists

Zeba Wunderlich and Kishore Kuchibhotla of Harvard University write in Nature’s Correspondence page (451, 887; 2008):

The paramount importance of publishing in biology dissuades many young scientists from making non-traditional choices with regard to where and how we publish our work. My colleagues and I believe it is in our own interests to identify the shortcomings of traditional publishing and to explore other publishing possibilities that are free of those problems.

What can we do? First, learn about our options. There are several innovative developments poised to change the publishing landscape dramatically. Video publications, preprint archives and high-throughput online journals are but a few that have recently surfaced (for a discussion, see Nature Network’s Publishing in the New Millennium forum).The onus is on all of us to investigate these resources and to consider how they might enrich our science.

To make a difference, we also need to contribute. Frustrated by technical difficulties in reproducing published experiments? Then publish a video protocol in the Journal of Visualized Experiments. Have you benefited from a colleague’s comments at a conference? Then extend the experience, and comment on articles published by PLoS One and posted on Nature Precedings. These initiatives will take hold and achieve their full potential only with strong support from the scientific community.

If we collectively embrace these ideas, publishing will become more effective. Although the psychological and social barriers to submitting a contribution initially are surprisingly high, becoming involved has proved to be rewarding. Ultimately, scientific progress and the published record have a symbiotic relationship — improved communication will enhance the pace, progress and efficiency of research.

[Note added by Maxine: In addition to the resources mentioned above, Nature Protocols is an online resource which welcomes the upload of protocols, in video or written form, and provides users with an interactive network for comments and additions.]