Does human embryonic stem cell research get a fair chance?

The use of human embryonic stem cells (hESCs) in research is of course highly controversial, raising ethical questions that for many people amount to serious dilemmas. In our April editorial we didn’t address the moral questions at all, but criticized recent efforts to discredit hESC research.

We’ve received two letters chiding us for the editorial. Though we can’t publish these letters in Nature Neuroscience, we are happy to discuss the matter on Action Potential. We invite the authors of the two letters to join us on the blog, and everyone else of course is also welcome to chip in.

Here are the links to the editorial, and the two pieces we discussed as examples for the new trick of spinning stem cell science against stem cell science. All are available for free:

Nature Neuroscience April 2007 editorial

Maureen L. Condic, “What We Know About Embryonic Stem Cells”, First Things, January 2007

The White House Domestic Policy Council, “Advancing Stem Cell Science Without Destroying Human Life”, January 2007

Ahissar et al.

Dyslexia and the failure to form a perceptual anchor

Reading appears to be primarily a visual task, but it has been proposed that children suffering from dyslexia may actually have in impairment in auditory processing. This study reports that a set of learning-disabled and dyslexic children had trouble with certain sound discrimination tasks, supporting the idea that the root of dyslexia could lie in auditory cognition.

Robbe et al.

Cannabinoids reveal importance of spike timing coordination in hippocampal function

In vivo multi-unit recordings from rats reveal that cannabinoids desynchronize hippocampal neuron assemblies without affecting the average firing rate. The loss of synchrony correlates with cannabinoid-induced memory deficits in a hippocampus-dependent task.

This paper received quite some coverage in the popular press. Even the free rag metro NY (distributed on the subway here) covered it, with the fabulous headline “Baked neurons behind marijuana memory loss”.

(Thanks to Jan Theunissen from Nature Biotechnology for alerting me to the metro article.)