nature.com

Sitemap

  • Log In
  • Register

Action Potential

a neuroscience blog

Advanced search
  • Nature.com Blogs
  • Blog
  • Archive by Tag

Archive by tag | correction

16 May 2012 | 22:47 BST

Call and response

Posted by I-han Chou | Categories: I-han Chou, New in Nature

Call and response

The (highly abbreviated) life story of a paper appearing in Nature often goes something like this: ideas are birthed and experiments envisioned. Pilot experiments are run, yielding beautiful preliminary data. Replication and controls are then gathered over the course of months, if not years of hard labor. The paper is written, submitted, and reviewed. A few (two is typical) rounds of review and revision later, it is published (with highly variable degrees of reviewer and editorial unanimity). But this is by no means the end, rather, just a milestone in the evaluation process by the community.  In journals, post-publication evaluation has traditionally occurred in the form of peer-reviewed follow-up papers or formal commentary.  Read more

Tags:

  • addendum
  • correction
  • fMRI
  • imaging
  • intelligence
  • statistical analysis

Article tools

  • add a comment
  • Email
  • Share/bookmark

    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Delicious
    • Digg
    • Google+
    • LinkedIn
    • Reddit
    • StumbleUpon

About this blog

Action Potential is a forum operated by neuroscience editors at Nature for the entire neuroscience community. We'll discuss what's new and exciting in science, be it in our journals or elsewhere, as well as science policy and publishing and provide updates from major meetings. Although we provide the opportunity to comment as a service to the community, we do not endorse all viewpoints represented here. To contact the contributors directly with confidential questions or suggestions for future entries, please e-mail n.gray@us.nature.com.
  • E-alert
  • RSS
nature.com blogs home

Recent comments on this blog

  • This is a great article; I am pleased to see Action Potential and, importantly, Nature tackling the issue of gender… ... Read more
    -- Anne Churchland

    Reviewing gender

  • This topic is very interesting to me. However, I also can not access the individual articles at this time.… ... Read more
    -- Brittney Scully

    Autism, synapses and mice – pairs division

  • I think it correct: Apparently, rodents have a difficult time holding pasta, requiring them to learn new motor skills to… ... Read more
    -- Miguel Guerrero

    The Fine Architecture of Learning and Joint Publication

Blog Archive

Categories

  • Breaking News
  • Correspondents
  • I-han Chou
  • In the Field
  • Interesting Neuroscience
  • Journal Clubs
  • Neuroinformatics
  • New in Nature
  • Old Updates
  • Popular Press
  • Random Thoughts
  • Science Policy
  • Scientific Publishing
  • SfN Meeting
  • What's New in Nature Neuroscience
  • A view From the BridgeA view From the Bridge
  • Action PotentialAction Potential
  • Flat Chat Flat Chat
  • Free AssociationFree Association
  • House of WisdomHouse of Wisdom
  • IndigenusIndigenus
  • MethagoraMethagora
  • Nature Future ConditionalNature Future Conditional
  • nature.com blogsnature.com blogs
  • Naturejobs BlogNaturejobs Blog
  • Of Schemes and Memes BlogOf Schemes and Memes Blog
  • On your wavelengthOn your wavelength
  • Plant LifePlant Life
  • Scientific DataScientific Data
  • Soapbox ScienceSoapbox Science
  • Spoonful of MedicineSpoonful of Medicine
  • StepwiseStepwise
  • The Sceptical ChymistThe Sceptical Chymist
  • Trade SecretsTrade Secrets
  • About us
  • Contact us
  • Accessibility statement
  • Help
  • Privacy policy
  • Use of cookies
  • Legal notice
  • Terms
  • Nature jobs
  • Nature Asia
  • Nature Education
  • RSS web feeds
Advanced search

© 2021 Springer Nature Limited. All Rights Reserved. partner of AGORA, HINARI, OARE, INASP, ORCID, CrossRef and COUNTER