Bone marrow donors can be paid, US court rules

bonemarrow.JPG

In a ruling that may bring relief to cancer patients across the US, a federal appeals court said that a decades-old law banning the sale of human organs does not apply to bone marrow donations.

The US National Organ Transplant Act of 1984 prohibits financial compensation for human organ donations, including bone marrow, but allows people to be paid for blood and plasma donations. At the time, lawmakers made that distinction because the method used to extract marrow was dangerous, and monetary kickbacks could have encouraged desperate people to take unnecessary risks. As a disincentive to sell organs, the crime was made punishable by up to five years in prison. But a group of cancer victims, parents of sick children, a physician and a Californian non-profit called MoreMarrowDonors.org challenged the status quo, arguing that reimbursement was essential to plug the country’s shortage of bone marrow donors.

In a decision released yesterday, the US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, which covers much of the western part of the country, agreed. “The court’s decision will fundamentally change treatment options for people with deadly blood diseases,” Jeff Rowes, the attorney from the Institute for Justice in Arlington, Virginia who argued the case, told Nature Medicine.

Continue reading

I heart Facebook: Scientists turn to social networks to study cardiovascular health

heart-facebook.png

Status update: Facebook could be good for your heart.

That’s the hypothesis behind the Social Heart Study, a new social network-based project aimed at understanding how Facebook friendships contribute to cardiovascular health.

The study is the brainchild of University of California–San Francisco epidemiologist Mark Pletcher and University of California–San Diego behavioral geneticist James Fowler. They wanted to find a low-cost way to see if time spent ‘liking’ and ‘poking’ on Facebook has either favorable or adverse effects on people’s hearts. So they decided to go straight to the source. They created a Facebook app and started asking people to share their health data and online activity patterns.

The Social Heart Study went live last week and is still in beta mode. But eventually, the organizers hope to recruit a cohort of more than a million adults who are willing to pour their hearts out (so to speak) for science. All this personal information should form a huge online database for observational and interventional studies into cardiovascular health, and should reveal new online ways to prevent heart disease, the organizers say.

Continue reading

Pfizer braces for big hit after generic versions of Lipitor hit the market

Lipitor.jpg

It’s the end of an era for the pharmaceutical industry. Tomorrow, the most popular prescription drug in the world, Lipitor, is due to go off-patent in the US. And no product looks set to equal or surpass the cholesterol-lowering agent’s peak annual sales of $13.7 billion, which it achieved back in 2006.

Lipitor, known generically as atorvastatin, is used by nearly 9 million Americans and has made Pfizer more than $130 billion globally since its 1997 launch. As the drug stands poised at the edge of a proverbial patent cliff, analysts at EvaluatePharma forecast that the loss of the megablockbuster will rob the New York–based drug giant of its top spot in the pharmaceutical league rankings by revenue. As the expiry looms large, patients, pharmacies and the drug industry are all holding their breaths, waiting to see how the introduction of generic atorvastatin will affect them.

For long-term Lipitor users, the patent expiry should be great news. Although Pfizer is expected to take a huge hit with the loss of Lipitor’s exclusivity — about $10 billion a-year by some estimates — consumers should save big. The generic substitute for Lipitor is expected to eventually cost up to 90% less than Pfizer’s drug, and co-payments are expected to drop from an average of $25 per month to $10, saving patients about $180 per year, according to CBS News. To begin with, the Indian drugmaker Ranbaxy Laboratories will hold the exclusive right to manufacture and sell generic atorvastatin in the US, which should help keep the price of the drug relatively high through mid-2012. New Jersey-based Watson Laboratories will simultaneously sell a licensed generic, which will be manufactured by Pfizer. But after six months, other generic version of atorvastatin could flood the market, triggering prices to plummet, and thereby saving consumers and the US health system a whole lot of money.

Continue reading

Breast cancer approval revoked for problem-plagued Avastin

The US Food and Drug Administration announced today that it would be revoking the agency’s approval of Avastin (bevacizumab) for first-line treatment of metastatic breast cancer. The FDA concluded from several studies and a public hearing held in June that the Genentech drug — a monoclonal antibody that inhibits vascular endothelial growth factor — was not safe or effective for women with breast cancer.

“Women risk life-threatening side effects… from taking Avastin and these can be justified only if there was good evidence that use of the drug would benefit the patient,” said FDA commissioner Margaret Hamburg in a media briefing this morning. “After reviewing the available studies, it is clear that there is no proof of a benefit in breast cancer patients.”

The side effects of Avastin include severe bleeding, high blood pressure and heart attacks. Nonetheless, the drug will remain on the market for other types of cancer — including colon, lung, kidney and brain — for which the efficacy outweighs the risks.

The FDA conditionally approved Avastin in 2008 under an accelerated approval process, after positive results from a single study showed almost a half year average increase in progression-free survival in people taking the drug. After two consequent trials by Genentech failed to confirm the original benefits seen, an FDA advisory committee voted 12-1 in July 2010 to revoke Avastin’s approval for this indication. Genentech contested the FDA’s position, requesting a public hearing this summer, but a second, six-member panel unanimously stood by the original decision. Today’s announcement by Hamburg puts a final chapter on this saga.

Continue reading

Mississippi votes against embryos’ human rights, but national debate continues

mississippistatecapitol.JPG

Yesterday, Mississippi voters headed to the polls to weigh in on a highly controversial ballot initiative that would give embryos in that state ‘personhood’ status, and wreak havoc on reproductive therapy and research in the process. Despite the fact that the constitutional amendment, known as Initiative 26, was supported by Republican and Democrat candidates for Mississippi Governor as well as the state’s Attorney General Jim Hood, it ultimately failed as 58% of the voters rejected it.

The ballot initiative came out of an ongoing nation-wide campaign launched by Personhood USA, a Colorado-based Christian non-profit.

Many doctors in Mississippi are letting out a collective sigh of relief. Had this initiative passed, every fertilized human egg would have become a ‘person’ protected under US law. This would have subsequently made abortion illegal and restricted use of birth control pills and fertility treatments such as in vitro fertilization, in which embryos are sometimes destroyed.

Initiative 26 could have also affected the state’s embryonic stem cell research. “Any stem cell research that leads to destruction of the pre-embryonic person would have been problematic,” says Jonathan Will, director of the Bioethics and Health Law Center at Mississippi College in the state capital, Jackson.

Even though the initiative failed, some still worry that it might have a snowball impact in areas of the country with more high-profile stem cell research communities. “I don’t know that there’s a huge amount of stem cell research going on in Mississippi,” says bioethicist Ron Green of Dartmouth College, in Hanover, New Hampshire. But if this legislation were to encourage other, larger states to go down the same road, “the implications are going to be somewhat chilling,” Green says.

This possibility is not far from the truth—activists are working to get personhood initiatives on the ballots of seven states in the 2012 election, including Oregon, Florida, Ohio, Nebraska, Montana, Alabama and Kansas. “If you extend this to states like Oregon and Florida, it would put a halt to the development of new stem cell lines by any of the standard methods which are now permissible under the Obama Administration’s policies,” Green says.

According to Will, the debate has been raging for years and Personhood USA who is “very vocal” will continue to lobby for its cause. “This issue is not going away,” Will says.

Image by Shawn Rossi via Flickr Creative Commons

New Parkinson’s therapies aim to halt disease, not just symptoms

NEW YORK — The introduction of levadopa therapy more than 40 years ago marked a milestone in the treatment of Parkinson’s disease. The dopamine replacement drug helps control the motor symptoms associated with the neurodegenerative disease, but it does not prevent the further loss of dopamine-producing neurons, so researchers have been on the hunt for more neuroprotective treatment options.

At the Parkinson’s Disease Therapeutics Conference here last week — hosted by the Michael J. Fox Foundation (MJFF) and the New York Academy of Sciences — a who’s who of Parkinson’s researchers met to discuss some of the more promising approaches, ranging from small molecules that hit novel drug targets to the first vaccine to enter clinical testing.

One lead involves blocking Cav1.3, a subunit of a calcium channel that enables the channel to stay open and facilitates dopamine-dependent neuron activity. Two years ago, James Surmeier, a physiologist at Northwestern University in Chicago, first linked calcium signaling, particularly through Cav1.3 channels, to the selective degeneration of dopaminergic neurons. Building on those findings, at the meeting last week Surmeier reported the results of a high-throughput screen showing that a compound called pyrimidine 2,4,6 trione blocks the Cav1.3 channel in cell culture. These findings dovetail with a paper published earlier this year by another group at Northwestern University showing that similar compounds were also neuroprotective in a cultured cell model of amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, suggesting that the drug candidates may be useful across neurodegenerative diseases.

Surmeier’s group is now following up his unpublished cell-based findings with experiments in rodent models of Parkinson’s. Despite the results being very preliminary, they are already creating quite a buzz. “This is a totally different idea,” says Anders Björklund, a neuroscientist from Lund University in Sweden who was not involved in the research.

Continue reading

Small resveratrol trial shows metabolic benefits, and might give hope to drug developers

resVida.jpg

A small study has lent much hoped-for support to the idea that resveratrol — a natural organic compound found in red wine — can positively affect the metabolism of obese individuals through the activation of the sirtuin-1 gene. These findings give new hope to pharmaceutical drug developers that have been stymied by years of debate about the compound’s efficacy and how exactly it works.

Last year, GlaxoSmithKline-owned Sirtris Pharmaceuticals, based in Cambridge, Massachusetts, abandoned its resveratrol-based drug SRT501 designed to treat multiple myeloma, after kidney failure was seen in patients involved in their phase 2 trial of the compound. Other trials seeking to show its ability to aid weight-loss have similarly fumbled, and researchers had a tough time demonstrating that it acted on the sirtuin-1 gene as purported.

The new study, published today in Cell Metabolism, involved 11 obese men, who received resVida, a resveratrol pill produced by DSM Nutritional Products and widely available as a supplement. Study author Patrick Schrauwen from the University of Maastricht in the Netherlands and his colleagues measured the volunteers’ liver fat and blood sugar, among other things. After taking resVida, the 11 participants experienced a drop in levels of liver fat and blood glucose. Systolic blood pressure also fell by 4% compared with the participants’ blood pressure when on the placebo pill.

Notably, while participants didn’t lose weight, protein analysis indicated that resveratrol increased sirtuin-1 levels and improved mitochondrial function, mirroring the metabolic effects of exercise and restricted calorie intake.

Continue reading

Drug shortages may derail careers along with trials

kristentamburro.jpg.bmp
PhD in peril: Kristen Tamburro.

In virologist Dirk Dittmer’s lab at the University of North Carolina–Chapel Hill, there are two silent rooms. One contains a hulking, quarter million-dollar robot, custom-made to analyze blood samples; the other contains a small protein-synthesis machine. Most days, scientists don’t enter either room. The machines sit there gathering dust while Dittmer’s team waits on a massive clinical trial in African patients with AIDS to begin — a trial that has been delayed indefinitely due to drug shortages.

The issue of drug shortages has posed a growing problem for doctors and patients in the US. In the first eight months of this year, for instance, the country’s Food and Drug Administration (FDA) recorded nearly 200 such shortages, in contrast to the 178 shortages reported in 2010 overall. As a result, hundreds of clinical trials hang in the balance, and the delays are jeopardizing the careers of many clinical investigators.

One person on Dittmer’s research team facing a career dilemma is graduate student Kristen Tamburro, who received a prestigious Howard Hughes Medical Institute fellowship in September 2009. Tamburro joined Dittmer’s lab to pursue translational medicine, tempted by the promise of data from the AIDS trial — which aimed to test Janssen’s Doxil (doxorubicin), currently approved to treat ovarian cancer and multiple myeloma, in patients with AIDS who have developed the deadly cancer Kaposi’s sarcoma. Halfway toward obtaining her PhD, when the trial remained on standby, she realized she needed a new plan.

“Since the samples won’t come in before I graduate, the project has been removed from my thesis,” she says. Although she analyzed several small, observational trials to salvage her thesis, a trial of this magnitude and scale could have transformed her career. “It would have been a great experience to have had,” she says.

Promotional material

Another paused phase 3 trial aims to treat acute myeloid leukemia (AML) in the elderly. It is waiting for the chemotherapy drugs Cerubidine (daunorubicin), manufactured by Winthrop Pharmaceuticals, and Tarabine PFS (cytarabine), made by several companies, including Hospira. James Foran, a medical oncologist at the Mayo Clinic in Jacksonville, Florida, heads the study. The trial is his baby — he started working on it five years ago and was hoping to have preliminary data in 2013. “This is the sort of trial that can get me promoted to professor someday,” he says. “If it fails, I will have to go straight back to the drawing board.”

Continue reading

Abbott splits into two companies to lessen reliance on Humira

Abbott Laboratories announced plans this morning to split into two companies. The separation is not a bitter one, however; it’s simply a smart way to give the Chicago–based company — the eighth-largest drugmaker in the world, with global sales of around $40 billion in 2010 — a valuation bump in the eyes of investors, analysts say.

The two new companies will have distinct product profiles. The first, as yet unnamed, will be a research-based pharmaceuticals company with Abbott’s trademark brand-name medicines, including the rheumatoid arthritis drug Humira (adalimumab), prostate cancer drug Lupron (leuprolide) and Synagis (palivizumab), a monoclonal antibody targeted at the respiratory syncitial virus. The second company, which will keep the Abbott moniker, will be a diversified medical products business including lab diagnostics, generic drugs, nutrition products and medical devices.

The problem with the status quo, according to Abbott spokesperson Adelle Infante, is that Humira has overshadowed all the company’s other offerings. “I believe this one product alone represents about 20% of the company’s profits,” Infante told Nature Medicine. Consequently, for example, the medical products arm does not get as much attention from healthcare investors, she explains.

Continue reading

Protein folding pioneer named new director of NIH’s basic research arm

ChrisKaiser.jpg

The US National Institutes of Health announced today that cell biologist Chris Kaiser will head up the $2 billion basic research arm of the federal funding agency. Kaiser, currently chair of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology’s biology department, expects to take over the reins of the US National Institute of General and Medical Sciences (NIGMS) from interim director Judith Greenberg in the spring of 2012.

“This job is probably one of the only jobs I would ever consider leaving MIT for. It is so important,” Kaiser told Nature Medicine. “I view it as one of the most important administrative positions in science.”

The NIGMS has funded Kaiser’s research at MIT for the last 20 years — ever since he set up shop as an independent investigator. His work on protein folding and membrane trafficking in yeast models is closely aligned with the NIGMS’s major objective: to understand basic biological processes at a molecular level.

As director of the NIGMS, Kaiser says his top priority is to work within current and future budget constraints to keep the traditional NIH funding streams alive and working for extramural researchers. He also plans to support training of graduate students and postdoctoral researchers, and encourage people to join the scientific workforce. “That is something I take very seriously,” Kaiser says. “I want to make sure the training programs do their best at bringing the brightest young people into research careers.”

For more on the NIGMS, read our Q&A from earlier this year with former director Jeremy Berg, who left the agency in June.

Image Credit: NIGMS